Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

Posts

Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

steve antonucci

>Those of you that prototype or experiment frequently- what do you do with you experiments?

As an example, I turned a small winged, suspended bowl on Saturday, just to see if I could do it. It's not sanded, the wood was wet and will move or crack, and it has iron staining from where the chuch jaws were. I kept it (for now) to possibly bandsaw the legs at a later point or practice finishing techniques, but at some point, it will be burned.

I have become somewhat attached to other prototypes and they populate the shop accordingly. Can't really see ever burning them, even though they aren't finished and likely never will be.

So where do your prototypes go?

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

#2

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

David Belser

>Most will sit on my kitchen table for a few weeks or more, giving me time to look at them differently. When exploring a new idea I feel it is VERY important to spend time with it, not just accept or reject it.

After that, then tend to find some place to rest. I can see and put my hands on 5 from where I'm sitting right now. In general I keep them. Occasionally they end up as part of another piece.

I also keep them around for when I give a talk as a way of showing people that the route to a specific piece can be quite convoluted and is also usually filled with plenty of missteps. It really helps to show those people who insist that they "aren't creative" some of my more creative stuff doesn't just materialize as a complete concept.

I should get rid of more of them, but fortunately I work small.

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

#3

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

charlie belden

>Interesting question. And I look foreward to others' responses.

There's usually something one can learn from even prototypes that didn't work, or work as planned. Kept around for a while, these things often convey in some way something worth knowing - and that can be used - later. They sometimes sit quietly - and whisper a little gem - when it's quiet and peaceful.

And there is, as David noted, value in even things that didn't work out. I really like his using them to point out to "I'm just not very creative" turners that really nice pieces, based on an interesting idea, don't Spring Forth Whole and Perfect. We tend to trumpet our successes, and hide our "less successful works", giving the impression that EVERY piece that comes of the lathe is a masterpiece and that "creativity" just happens - if you have The Gift. That false impression may, in part, be why "I'm just not very creative" turners don't even try being "creative".

Practicing finishing on "failures" is a great idea.

Personally, I go with The Surgeon's Approach - brag about the successes - and bury the failures. My Japanese garden is going to be a real mystery for some poor archeologist 200 years from now.

"I don't get it. This site dates from the late 20th and early 21st century - yet I'm finding all these fragments of wooden artifacts that should date several hundred years earlier. And the wood isn't from any native species and some appear to have come from a place on the other side of the globe. They must have had contact with other countries - but trading wood? And I haven't a clue as to what some of these things were used for - a wooden bowl - with a bunch of holes cut in it? Mosaics in glass or fired clay? Sure. But mosaics in wood? Why in the world would someone spend the time making a vessel to hold things - when the piece of wood they started with was so obviously crappy to begin with? There's a thesis paper here, but who will believe the findings and conclusions? Maybe I'll move my next trench over a quarter mile."

Actually, being a Wood Hoarder(sp?) (aka Wood Whore), if a prototype that didn't work out has enough wood to POSSIBLY do something with in the future - it stays - until I start running out of space for More WOOD!

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

#4

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

David Belser

>Good point about practicing finish techniques. There is a distinction between a "prototype" and a mistake. A lot of my stuff is made of multiple parts - if I screw up a part ie. chip it or turn it the wrong size it goes into the scrap box. I have a "Safe Box" lid that I messed the machining up on. I've used it a least 3 times to try out different lid stencils. Put one on, finish remount on lathe and turn the finish off again.

Some of these "failed" parts end up being used for work holding - ie. jam chucks, or to test the next phase of work.

Prototypes on the other hand are pieces that are taken to near or quick completion to test an idea, using cheap common wood and not spending as much time fussing with it.

Charlie, I have a better solution for the ones that really piss me off that I don't want to see again (as long as they are solid wood). I live on a large river - It is very satisfying to watch funnel bowl slowly float away into the distance.

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

#5

Steven Antonucci

I don't have a river, but I do have heavy handles

steve antonucci

>on my gouges and a very short temper when I screw something up... I have been know to quickly dismount a partial piece from the lathe with one swift strike.

I have more partial/experimental/failed pieces than I could burn in a night in my shop. Now when the process is what drives you and not the result, you are truly free...

Steve

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

#6

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

Texian

>Depends. Sometimes good for woodburning practice (as in pyrography, not fireplace). I once made a prototype chisel rack and my design was published in a national magazine in 1988 or '89. That rack is still in use. It's not beautiful, but was good enough (proof of concept).

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

#7

Prototypes?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

#8

It's not a screw up - it's a Funnel Bowl!

charlie belden

>And I MEANT to do that.

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

#9

Steven Antonucci

Definition: a new idea...

steve antonucci

>Something you start to prove a concept or idea that you've never tried. When I turned a winged bowl this weekend, I cut it in 15 minutes, very quickly (still clean, though) just to get the sequence of operations correct and to get feel for cutting mostly air. I'll most likely never really finish it...

Rather than experiment on a real piece, some of us do quick mock-ups of ideas just to get a sense of scale, color, techniques... I'll often use multiple ideas over time on the same pieces. If you don't try new ideas, you don't need to prototype...

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

#10

"Artists" call them studies.

David Belser

>

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

#11

Steven Antonucci

I got a D- on more than one "Study"

steve antonucci

>

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

#12

Re: Follow-up: What do you do with prototypes?

Terry Scott

>Steve I dont throw anything away ,I just so to speak keep kicking them around . They may inspire me to have another go or I rob pieces off the experiment for other works ,cut them up for stands and on and On.

I may also feel inclined to revisit them and use as a canvas for carving or another experiment with texture and colour . I like to think of all my work as an experiment.I often pull a piece from my gallery if it has been sitting and re visit it

If I can come away learning something or think it is an improvement on the last I am smiling