Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Steel City Lathe

Posts

Steel City Lathe

#1

Steel City Lathe

Eric Dickerson

>Hey there! I am considering the purchase of one of the new Steel City lathes. I am looking at one of the new granite bed models. Is there anyone out there that has experience with it? I like it for the size (12x27) and the price. I also am considering a General 12x17 VS model. It is more $ but has VS and outboard capability... Is there any other comparable lathes and is there anyone out there that can help me out?

Thanks for your assistance.

Eric

Re: Steel City Lathe

#2

Re: Steel City Lathe

john lucas

>There is a comparison of midi size lathes in the latest issue of Woodworkers Journal. For my tastes the Jet 12/20VS is a good lathe and the new Delta VS 12" model is the best but is also the most expensive.

Re: Steel City Lathe

#3

Re: Steel City Lathe

Greg Haugen

>I agree with John. I like the Jet or the Delta. It's tough to beat a Jet 1220VS and the new Delta is the "cadillac" of smaller lathes now.

I don't see any reason to have outboard abilities on a small lathe. Someone's going to get hurt. I don't even see the "Comfort" factor for offseting the headstock to get closer to the work. These lathes are all "shortbed" lathes, just stand at the end of the lathe. Even the bigger lathes are going to "sliding" headstocks, not pivoting ones. And the large lathes have a lot more weight and stability. If mistreated, that option on a small lathe is a disaster waiting to happen.

Just my 2 cents...

Re: Steel City Lathe

#4

Re: Steel City Lathe

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>I was at the Cincy Woodcraft yesterday and even though I have all the major toys I still look at the newest offerings.

For anyone who has not seen the new Delta midi in the flesh.....

This is NOT the same Delta midi lathe that I started on and that most of us are familiar with. It looked half again as big as mine. All the main players in the tool market seem to be pulling out all the stops to come up with something better than the other guy. Competition is a wonderful thing.

Re: Steel City Lathe

#5

Re: Steel City Lathe

Gordon Seto

>The 5 speed model is I would avoid.

Speeds:

500, 1300, 2100, 2750, 3600 RPM

The speed jump is too dramatic at the low end to be useful. 1300 is 2.6 times jump from 500. After roughing a 9"+ bowl at 500 rpm, you may want to increase the speed faster, but not quite that fast.

The higher speed end is relatively crowded.

It may be a good lathe, I don't know. It is better to get a lathe from people who knows woodturning.

Re: Steel City Lathe

#6

Re: Steel City Lathe

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>If you buy a Steel City lathe, take it out of the box and check it out thoroughly first. The dealer here has had one on display for months -- with an eighth of an inch of sideways play in the tailstock. The bed is too wide. No Good! And how well will the granite stand up to wear and tear? I really liked the steel bed Steel City, and the Jet. But, if I was buying now, I would have a very hard look at the new Delta. I have not used one but have gone over one thoroughly in the showroom. That is a lot of lathe for the money!

Re: Steel City Lathe

#7

Re: Steel City Lathe

Russ Fairfield

>You might want to wait before buying a new 12" lathe.

There are 2 new 14" VS lathes coming out soon. One is from General and the other is Rikon. The General will something less than $1000, and the Rikon will be in the $1300 range. Ask at your local Woodcraft store. They should have the promo information.

2" might not seem like a lot, but the difference between 12" and 14" is a lot. There is more HP and greater weight, and that equates to strength and stability

Re: Steel City Lathe

#8

Re: Steel City Lathe

Texian

>No experience with that lathe, but have granite counter tops and they have a number of chips out of the surface after only two years' use by previous owner. No doubt they look cool, but I would avoid them. My cast iron lathe bed has a small dent where I dropped a chuck from a few inches high. Shudder to think what would have happened to a granite bed. Only speculation though. Probably their granite is better quality than my counter tops.

Re: Steel City Lathe

#9

The sales rep I just spoke with...

Thad

>...says that they warranty the granite from cracks for 10 yrs.

He said they use granite b/c it's solid (no webbing or engineered support inside the bed) and dampens vibration better. That they use black because it's "purer" than other granites.

He didn't have an answer for the concern about the jump in speeds from 500 to 1350 though.

Just FYI

~ Thad

Re: Steel City Lathe

#10

Re: Steel City Lathe

Eric Dickerson

>Thanks to all of you for the info.I really appreciate the input. If anyone else has some input, send it over! I guess now I have to make a decision...

What are the little cherries by my question and all the responses?

Eric

Re: Steel City Lathe

#11

keep the granit for countertops

bob davis

>

Re: Steel City Lathe

#12

Re: Steel City Lathe

Texian

>It means you have not read that thread, or there has been a new post to that thread since you last read it.

Re: Steel City Lathe

#13

Re: Steel City Lathe

Rich Egan

>Eric:

I have not turned with one of these lathes, but I looked one over and spoke to one of the factory reps about it. It's a nice lathe, and is priced very competitively with other machines in that size. I mentioned to him some things at the time I thought they might change. If I remember, it only had a 1/2 HP motor, which I thought should be at least 3/4 to be on par with other machines. To go along with that, change the pulley set to lower the lowest speed and space the other ranges a little closer together. Upgrade the 5/8" tool post to a full 1" post. The cover for the spindle pulley is held in place with a knurled knob, just above the handwheel. When I spun the handwheel, I tended to scrape my knuckle on that knob. Bad location. Try one out before you buy if you can.

Rich

Re: Steel City Lathe

#14

Re: Steel City Lathe

Eric Dickerson

>Thanks for your suggestion! I'll try to find one to try it out...