Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?
charlie belden
>Are YOU A Prototypiste?
( Please excuse the affectateous extra �e� on the end of the word Prototypist - it�s a tongue in chic (sorry, couldn�t resist that) poke at The Art World. )
Seems most turners find one or two types of turning they like - and stick with them - over and over and over again - pens, bowls (natural edged or not), hollow forms, lidded boxes (with or without pulls or finials), multi centers, multi-axis, Post Lathe Enhanced (by color or piercing, carving, sandblasting or bleaching or charring and wire brushing) or some other type of turning.
When you do a LOT of variations of one type of piece, you can keep refining them, as well as the means of turning them. With repetition of a technique or procedure, you can get pretty efficient at literally turning out very nice, refined versions - of basically the same piece, be it Round and Brown or Black and Blue (or Red) or Little Openings,Thin Walls or Elegant, Delicate and Graceful or Really BIG or really TINY etc..
When you do pieces �like you saw in a demo�, or in a magazine, or in a gallery or instant gallery or as done on the DVD you watched, life is so much simpler - and the turning time is so much shorter. You start with a clear image of the goal, sometimes with critical dimensions and often also have the procedure AND the tools to be used AND how the tools are to be used - in what order. If you then turn several variations of the piece you�ve just completed, the turning time drops off even more for the Next One.
The drawback to doing pieces �Like Ones That ______ Does� is that YOUR version LOOKS LIKE ____________�s, but probably not as nice. You get the piece done in a reasonable amount of time - but it LOOKS LIKE ________�s - but not quite. And while you may get really good at making ALL the cuts - in the right order - the end result is a piece that LOOKS LIKE __________�s.
If imitation is the highest form of flattery, I have to wonder if the turner who did the piece that inspired you to turn a version of his/her �signature piece� really cares one way or the other that his/her work is being copied?
In a recent e-mail exchange with Peter Rand, he observed that most of his turnings are prototypes which test a turning idea he had - Proof Of Concept pieces. That�s where the term prototypist came from - a turner who never does the same thing, or much even like it, twice.
But the word �prototypist� sounds like it involves the use of a typewriter, and, unless it�s referring to a Writer, it doesn�t sound all that interesting. It lacks a certain panache that is often associated with Artists. The addition of the �e� changes the pronunciation to more like
proto -type - eest
which sounds more sophisticated - and more arty than prototypist?
Life gets a bit different when you�re a Prototypiste - every piece is a first cut at an idea - a prototype for working out the shape, size and techniques - of that idea. Then - relatively speaking - things take a LOT longer, mainly time spent evaluating the original idea against what you�ve got in front of you as you make the journey to the finished piece, modifying and adapting along the way - or not. And if you are disappointed once in a while by how one of YOUR pieces turns out - imagine that you�ve spent five or ten times more time on it - only to discover at the end that what seemed like such an interesting idea initially - isn�t.
Like turners who stick with one or two types of turning, the Prototypiste often sees modifications that COULD HAVE improved THIS piece - either in the basic shape and form, its proportions, the details, the technique or how the piece works. Were there to be a second version of the original idea it would certainly be better than the first. BUT - by the time the Prototypiste actually finishes - or abandons - a piece - three, four or a half dozen ideas for other pieces are rattling around in the Stuff Between The Ears. One of those ideas HAS TO BE the Next Project - the next prototype. There�s not much Looking Back for Prototypistes.
From a marketing perspective - the Prototypiste is a problem - no easily recognized Signature Piece - no unique and recognizable shape or form or technique or style, no coherent theme for the pieces, no �voice� that stands out from the rest of the choir of voices competing for attention. If you want to make a living turning wood, being a prototypiste probably ain�t the direction to head in.
There are a few who pull it off - Alby Hall and Terry Scott, both New Zealand turners, seem to do a lot of very different types of pieces that don�t have a recognizable Signature Style - other than that their pieces are NOT like any of their other pieces . Oddly, you�ll probably be able to pick their work out of a group of pieces by other turners once you�ve seen two of their pieces.
So to the questions:
Are you NOW or HAVE YOU EVER BEEN - a Prototypiste (or prototypist)?
If you were a prototypiste (or prototypist if the extra �e� just doesn�t sound right to you or feel right for you), but aren�t anymore - why?
If you are a prototypist - do you aspire to developing a Signature Piece and a Signature Style or are you quite satisfied doing all sorts of things and JUST enjoy chasing wild hare - ideas?
If you are NOT a protoypiste, can you provide an example or two of pieces you thought about - but never pursued because your focus remained on one type of piece, style or technique?
Got a name, or names, of some turners you think fit the Prototypiste definition?




