Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

Posts

Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

#1

Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

charlie belden

>Are YOU A Prototypiste?

( Please excuse the affectateous extra �e� on the end of the word Prototypist - it�s a tongue in chic (sorry, couldn�t resist that) poke at The Art World. )

Seems most turners find one or two types of turning they like - and stick with them - over and over and over again - pens, bowls (natural edged or not), hollow forms, lidded boxes (with or without pulls or finials), multi centers, multi-axis, Post Lathe Enhanced (by color or piercing, carving, sandblasting or bleaching or charring and wire brushing) or some other type of turning.

When you do a LOT of variations of one type of piece, you can keep refining them, as well as the means of turning them. With repetition of a technique or procedure, you can get pretty efficient at literally turning out very nice, refined versions - of basically the same piece, be it Round and Brown or Black and Blue (or Red) or Little Openings,Thin Walls or Elegant, Delicate and Graceful or Really BIG or really TINY etc..

When you do pieces �like you saw in a demo�, or in a magazine, or in a gallery or instant gallery or as done on the DVD you watched, life is so much simpler - and the turning time is so much shorter. You start with a clear image of the goal, sometimes with critical dimensions and often also have the procedure AND the tools to be used AND how the tools are to be used - in what order. If you then turn several variations of the piece you�ve just completed, the turning time drops off even more for the Next One.

The drawback to doing pieces �Like Ones That ______ Does� is that YOUR version LOOKS LIKE ____________�s, but probably not as nice. You get the piece done in a reasonable amount of time - but it LOOKS LIKE ________�s - but not quite. And while you may get really good at making ALL the cuts - in the right order - the end result is a piece that LOOKS LIKE __________�s.

If imitation is the highest form of flattery, I have to wonder if the turner who did the piece that inspired you to turn a version of his/her �signature piece� really cares one way or the other that his/her work is being copied?

In a recent e-mail exchange with Peter Rand, he observed that most of his turnings are prototypes which test a turning idea he had - Proof Of Concept pieces. That�s where the term prototypist came from - a turner who never does the same thing, or much even like it, twice.

But the word �prototypist� sounds like it involves the use of a typewriter, and, unless it�s referring to a Writer, it doesn�t sound all that interesting. It lacks a certain panache that is often associated with Artists. The addition of the �e� changes the pronunciation to more like

proto -type - eest

which sounds more sophisticated - and more arty than prototypist?

Life gets a bit different when you�re a Prototypiste - every piece is a first cut at an idea - a prototype for working out the shape, size and techniques - of that idea. Then - relatively speaking - things take a LOT longer, mainly time spent evaluating the original idea against what you�ve got in front of you as you make the journey to the finished piece, modifying and adapting along the way - or not. And if you are disappointed once in a while by how one of YOUR pieces turns out - imagine that you�ve spent five or ten times more time on it - only to discover at the end that what seemed like such an interesting idea initially - isn�t.

Like turners who stick with one or two types of turning, the Prototypiste often sees modifications that COULD HAVE improved THIS piece - either in the basic shape and form, its proportions, the details, the technique or how the piece works. Were there to be a second version of the original idea it would certainly be better than the first. BUT - by the time the Prototypiste actually finishes - or abandons - a piece - three, four or a half dozen ideas for other pieces are rattling around in the Stuff Between The Ears. One of those ideas HAS TO BE the Next Project - the next prototype. There�s not much Looking Back for Prototypistes.

From a marketing perspective - the Prototypiste is a problem - no easily recognized Signature Piece - no unique and recognizable shape or form or technique or style, no coherent theme for the pieces, no �voice� that stands out from the rest of the choir of voices competing for attention. If you want to make a living turning wood, being a prototypiste probably ain�t the direction to head in.

There are a few who pull it off - Alby Hall and Terry Scott, both New Zealand turners, seem to do a lot of very different types of pieces that don�t have a recognizable Signature Style - other than that their pieces are NOT like any of their other pieces . Oddly, you�ll probably be able to pick their work out of a group of pieces by other turners once you�ve seen two of their pieces.

So to the questions:

Are you NOW or HAVE YOU EVER BEEN - a Prototypiste (or prototypist)?

If you were a prototypiste (or prototypist if the extra �e� just doesn�t sound right to you or feel right for you), but aren�t anymore - why?

If you are a prototypist - do you aspire to developing a Signature Piece and a Signature Style or are you quite satisfied doing all sorts of things and JUST enjoy chasing wild hare - ideas?

If you are NOT a protoypiste, can you provide an example or two of pieces you thought about - but never pursued because your focus remained on one type of piece, style or technique?

Got a name, or names, of some turners you think fit the Prototypiste definition?

Re: Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

#2

Re: Are YOU a ProtoTypiste? (pic)

George Guadiane

>My tag, elsewhere is "Change One Thing - make it your own." I have seen hundreds of ideas that could be adapted and claim as fresh.

That being said, I think I'm a proto (fill in the blank)...

I have ideas that I will never have time to do, ideas that I forget and that sometimes come back in the middle of the night...

In light of the fact that the lathe is the primary tool, there is only so far that a person can go and leave it as a strictly (predominantly) lathe turned piece. But even those limits seem so boundless that I can't imagine finding one (or several) idea(s) that I could develop as a style of my own.

I've done some odd segmenting and want to further develop that include the "OATS" segmenting (pictured), and bandsaw segmenting that is pretty interesting.

I've had a some ideas for both open and closed segmented construction that is a significant variation from what has already been done.

I'm working on several multi/off axis projects that I think are unique.

All said and done, I'm having fun trying new things... I HOPE I can settle down with a few things and develop them for a while, but I don't know which ones they might be.


img

Re: Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

#3

Re: Are YOU a ProtoTypiste? (pic)

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Charlie,

As I do not consider myself an "artiste", at least not yet, just a craftsman trying to earn a muffin, I found myself repeating over and over whatever is selling at one time. I never try to make 2 identical and each shape is determined by the wood itself, but elements and procedures are repeated often. I am always making stuff I never made before and exhibiting along with the rest and see what peoples reaction is, if it is good I start making more of the same.

Jorge

Re: Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

#4

Steven Antonucci

Yes

steve antonucci

>but not to the extent that I need to try something new every day. It can just be new to me...

I also am a tinkerer. I need to know how things are done. Even if I will never personally do any of them. I am a consumer of knowledge, a maker, an engineer. I have an entire shelf of experiments...

Steve

Re: Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

#5

journeyman??

Rick_Allen

>Prototypist(e)? Apprenticeship?

I made a lot of different things in the first 6 years of woodturning. Different object, different materials. I figure it was all part of the learning process. I learned a lot about different wood species, different materials, different grain directions, different mounting techniques, different tools, different turning techniques...

During the first six years I discovered that I like three different classes of objects, platters, stave canisters and occasional tables. Some aspects of those objects are much more predictable and successfully made. But the more platters I make the more ideas about platters there is to explore. To the observers of the objects they may appear very much alike. To me the platters are expanding my knowledge of making platters. The goal is not to make the best platter. The goal is to make a platter which includes a particular technique or feature that results in a platter which is appealing to an observer.

If the first 6 years were spent learning about woodturning then what ere the last 6 years? Journeyman? What about the next 6 years? The way I am going I will continue as a journeyman.

Re: Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

#6

Re: journeyman??

Russ Fairfield

>Plates and platters are both the best and the worst because everything is there for the world to see. They can be the showcase of our skills, and the magnifier our inadequacies as a woodturner.

There is nothing that displays the beauty of a piece of wood better than a platter, and there is nothing that exhibits the woodturners skill better than the perfection of the smooth curve or flat surface of a pletter.

There is also nothing that displays every sanding scratch, torn grain, bruise, tool mark, ripple, unfairness of the curve, or other flaw better than a platter. Add a high gloss finish and they are magnified to even greater prominance

Re: Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

#7

ProtoTypiste and craftsman

john lucas

>Charlie Almost since the beginning of my woodworking I have made modifications to pieces that I tried to build. The rare exception is one of the first serious pieces I made. I copied every detail of a breadbox in issue #1 (I think) of Woodsmith. I made 5 of these things for Christmas.

After that I would see something I wanted to build and would plan it out, but would modify something to make it my own. On furniture there is always a hidden compartment somewhere, with rare exceptions. Often I will change the dimensions of a piece to reflect my feelings of how it should look.

On turning, once I've seen a demo I might make one of that item to learn the technique. Or sometimes I will use that technique to make a hand mirror. A good example of that was after watching John Jordan carve one of his signature pieces. I went home and made a Cherry hand mirror with sap wood that I bleached to lighten it and then carved and textured the back to look like John's carving.

Even last night I was making the Angel that Nick Cook taught in a article. I modified the halo and have already planned the next angel which will have radically different wings, an slanted halo and will be a screw lid box.

I love taking an idea and seeing how far I can take it. I love what you are doing and wish I had the time to make the stuff. I have hundreds of sketches of ideas of pieces to build but have to stop and make things that will sell to pay the bills.

Re: Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

#8

Re: ProtoTypiste

charlie belden

>As usual, I start out with a preconceived notion - that doing multiples, or doing just one or two types of turnings or types of forms or refining one or two turning techniques - would be a dead end - and after a while - boring.

A plate or platter? Big deal. Flat board, cut it round, turn a shallow depression, sand it, put a finish on it - DONE!

WRONG!

Bowls? ANYONE can turn a bowl - and sand it - and finish it. Uses more wood, takes a little longer - but it's "just" a bowl.

WRONG!

Little lidded boxes? You turn a cylinder, cut it in two pieces, drill out most of what you don't want, and turn off the rest. Sure, getting the lid fit just perfect is a little tricky - but . . .

WRONG!

Segmented pieces? THAT"S a really Wild Hare Idea. You'd have to be crazy to get into THAT. My Wild Hare Ideas pieces take long enough - but making 500 to 1000+ parts - with the perfect sizes and shapes? And figure out how to make an interesting pattern? What a total waste of time.

WRONG!

Turn basically the same thing over and over and over? That could get really boring.

WRONG!

The list goes on and on. Preconceived notion? Probably WRONG!

It's always good to get different perspectives of things. And forums like this are a great way to do that.

Maybe that's the attraction of turning - something for everyone - to take as far as they care to - with plenty of things to learn, plenty of things to try - and ALWAYS someone coming up with interesting things to perhaps explore. AND - there's always some interesting piece of wood to play with - often FREE wood.

Thanks for the different perspectives, and for this forum (Ellis - are you listening?)

Springs. Movement. Hmmmmm . . .

Re: Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

#9

Re: journeyman??

Rick Allen

>And after you get past the issues you mention there is also a lot to work on. Width of rim, rim thickness,slope down, slope up flat, wave, decorations of many different kinds, The rim/body interface also presents tons options.

Platters have so many terrific options and so few woodturners devote much turning time to platters.

Re: Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

#10

Steve Kubien

Re: journeyman??

Steve Kubien

>Rick, you make an interesting point, that few turners spend much time on platters. Guilty as charged! I find platters very difficult to make, for all of the reasons Russ mentioned (that I had never thought of but now acknowledge), but mostly because of the trouble I have remounting them to finish the bottom. I know if I had a vacuum chuck it would be easier but alas....

The other tough time I have with platters is suitable stock. With much of the timber that comes my way, if I cut a platter blank out of it I end up with too-small a blank for a salad bowl. Having said that, I do have a few green rough-out platters getting drier as we speak so we'll see what happens.

Steve

Re: Are YOU a ProtoTypiste?

#11

Re: journeyman??

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Rick,

You are right,

Platters are to me more challenging than other pieces and I spend a lot of time hunting for just the right wood to make them and then making them. It has paid me, they are my best sellers.

Jorge