Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Need help from hollowers! I had....

Posts

Need help from hollowers! I had....

#1

Need help from hollowers! I had....

Jamie Donaldson

>...a student today that would physically benefit from use of an articulated hollowing system, and I recall Cobra, Monster, and Elbow, but haven't kept up with all the new additions in this area. Your suggestions would be appreciated, and sources would also speed the search.

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

#2

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had.... *LINK*

Doc Green

>I have the Monster system and like it a lot. Randy provides everything you need, including an assortment of cutters, laser system, etc.

My $0.02. ~Doc


Monster Web Site

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

#3

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had.... *LINK*

charlie belden

>Does the student in question have some mental or physical limitation that requires the use of a captured hollowing system - or you just want something that will make it easier for him or her to try hollowing?

Is this for a full sized lathe or a mini/midi lathe?

Are you going to be hollowing smaller diameters and shallower pieces (up to 6" diameter and maybe up to 6" deep) - or - larger stuff with a diameter greater than 6" and deeper than 6"?

Is the wood to be hollowing going to be mounted on a face plate or held in a chuck or an appropriate sized?

Does the captured hollowing system HAVE to have a Laser set up - and if so - have you the time to drum into the student that they have to change the laser position relative to the cutting edge depending on the area of the cutter's edge that'll be cutting (scraping) wood?

More specific info would make answering easier.

Attached link will provide most of what's available.

I've got a JET mini/midi lathe and chose the MiniMonster. There's a link from the attached Compendium page to my evaluation of the MiniMonster and from that page - a link to a turning club member's review after having it and using it for about a month that avoids Owner Bias review shortcomings.


Hollowing Systems Compendium

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

#4

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

Dennis Yoder

>Jamie, I have the Kobra and really like the design. I do not know if Al and Jerry are back into production yet. Don Geiger may be able to answer more questions and have links. Dennis Y

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

#5

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

v

>The Kobra is being built by a new company J & A Tooling and can be contacted at jatooling@yahoo.com

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

#6

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

Texian

>Also have the Monster articulated system and can recommend it. As mentioned, it comes with a myriad of tool bits and attachments. The laser is excellent, and would be particularly helpful to a novice. Randy is a good guy, and has just sent me a free replacment piece for one that I damaged (due to really poor procedure on my part).

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

#7

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

Dennis DeVendra

>Hello,

I have only used the Kelton hollowing rigg. I like it very much. I had spent a lot of time using hollowing tools with just the handles. Once I started using the Kelton rigg, I found I had much more control. Since I have a General maxi lathe with a 12 inch swing and the General 25-650 lathe with a 16 inch swing, I got the small Kelton rigg. You can see the rigg and me in action on a youtube video I made a couple months ago. Go to my website at www.blindwoodturner.com and go to the "Articles and Events" page It is under the "Articles" section.

One more thing. I am blind and find the rigg very easy to setup and use. Good luck

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

#8

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

Cyril Griesbach

>Jamie, I have the Kobra for both my PM3520 as well as Carol's Jet Mini and IMHO they can't be beat. Several friends also have the Kobra and are more than pleased. Another club member is also considering one.

Production is limited and advertising seems nonexistent but Jerry Arnold and Al Crandel are making a fantastic product.

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

#9

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I think I'll throw my nickel into this discussion. I own a small Kelton Hollowing Rig and a Monster. I have also had an opportunity to use the Kobra and the Elbo. Here is a description of my experiences with each.

A small Kobra was the first I tried on a friend's lathe. It is a well made tool and the articulating action is very smooth. Had I been able to afford one at the time I would have bought one.

I had on opportunity to borrow another friend's Elbo, but didn't have a very good experience with it. I mounted it on my Jet mini, but it made the lathe too long to be useful in the location I was working. Had I been in my current astudio, my results may have been different.

The first setup I bought was the Kelton. I will admit that the reason I bought the Kelton was the price as it was on sale at the time. Another influence was that I've been using the Kelton hollowers as my primary hollowing tools for several years. Anyway, this is a nice rig and I enjoy using it, but it's all metal tubular construction makes it a bit heavy to handle after using it for a while. I am able to use both my 1/2" and 5/8" Kelton hollowers in it. It also did not come with a laser, but that is minor to me.

I just recently received a Monster that I purchased out in ABQ at the symposium. I found it quite easy to use and really smooth in its operation. To me, it's smoothness is comparable to the Kobra I tried and it is a match in ease of use. This is a well designed tool and I found it really easy to set up and use; even the laser. It was so easy that the first piece that came off it had walls that were between 1/8 and 3/16" thick.

Sorry for the length of this, but I thought I would share my observations on these four setups.

keithz

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

#10

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

robo hippy

>I started with a home made D handle, and some cutters. I eventualy got the Kelton hollowers (all of them) and prefer them to the cutters that you have to adjust. Much easier for me to change blades than adjust the cutters. I now have a Monster system, and love it. I had Randy make an adapter so I can use my Kelton blades in it. I prefer them for the roughing, and use a carbide tipped Eliminator for the finish cuts. I probably should get some of the Hunter blades as well as I don't think the Eliminator comes with curves blades. I also love the laser from Randy.

robo hippy

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

#11

Re: Thanks for the feedback- looks like.....

Jamie Donaldson

>...the Monster system is the favorite choice, and I will pass that info on.

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

#12

Another vote for Monster

Tommy Holmes in NW FL

>

Re: Need help from hollowers! I had....

#13

Re: Thanks for the feedback- looks like.....

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>Jamie, one of the best things about the Monster that I didn't mention is that Randy made a custom sized base for me...just to fit my new Delta 46-460 Midi. It fits perfectly.

keithz