Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

Posts

JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#1

JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

Ed Moore of SW VA

>HSS tips into shafts for hollowing - which would be best?

For a number of years I have used thick CA glue to cement the HHS cutters into the shafts of some hollowing tools. The bad news is that if the tip gets hot the CA doesn't hold. The good news is that applying heat allows you to get the cutter out when it needs to be replaced.

So, my questions for those with experience with PC-7 and JB Weld is:

Which would you choose to cement the HSS cutters into the shafts of hollowing tools? Which do you think is stronger?

Thanks In Advance,

Ed

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#2

"For a # of yrs..." ??? If it ain't broke...

Thad

>

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#3

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

Ace Foster

>I'd be very surprised if you could see any difference. It's not what you could call a well controlled experiment. Use whichever is easier, or cheaper, or altready on hand.

Ace

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#4

Steven Antonucci

Set screw if the shaft is big enough to drill

steve antonucci

>CA glue otherwise. Never had one come out?

Steve

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#5

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

john lucas

>Ed PC-7 is a very stiff clay like adhesive. You could put the adhesive in the hole first and then insert the adhesive. JB Weld gets thinner as it starts to set so it will tend to run around the cutter and I think, but don't know, that it would give a better bond.

I've tested the 2 against each other on some projects and the PC-7 bonds better but, and this is a big but, I've never tested it on smooth metal.

Both will release with heat. Will they release with less or more than CA I don't know. Of course if you use High heat JB-Weld it won't release until 600 degrees. You probably will never reach that.

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#6

Re: "For a # of yrs..." ??? If it ain't broke...

Ed Moore of SW VA

>Obviously I feel that improvement is important. Heat is generated when you hollow an ornament and cutters can break loose from the 1/4" shaft. I plan to make these tools for use in my class at John C Campbell Folk School in November. I want the cutters to stay in place and do their job when students use the tools to hollow out globes for ornaments.

As a former mathematics professor, I like to optimize a process when it is feasible. ;^)

Ed

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#7

Steve, getting a perfect fit for ...

Ed Moore of SW VA

>cutter's tenon is very difficult. The shaft is 1/4" drill rod, so a set screw is not feasible. CA glue works, but I have to assume that either of the two products that I mentioned, including regular epoxy, would give a stronger bond.

Ed

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#8

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

Ed Moore of SW VA

>John, I have used PC-7 a lot over the years and it does bond to smooth metal. Your idea of putting a little adhesive in the hole and then allowing the cutter to extrude the excess may be a very good one, provided the air is allowed to escape. I have had situations with tools being inserted into handles and then the air forces them back out when one's back is turned. Fortunately I caught it and got the tool back in place before the glue set.

I am not familiar with JB Weld, but sort of feel like I should be. What is the set-time for JBW?

Thanks,

Ed

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#9

I just use drill rod

john lucas

>Ed When I do ornament classes I just make a pair of hollowing tools out of Drill rod. I heat treat the end to make it tougher. I make a straight tool and a bent tip tool. I made 14 tools in about 2 hours not counting handles. I give them the option of purchasing the tools if they want or they can return them after the class.

I have been using the drill rod tools for many many years. They do need to be sharpened occasionally but it only takes about 15 seconds to sharpen. The bent tool gradually gets shorter and shorter until it gets grabby because the cutting tip is to right of the center line. When that happens I just heat it up and rebend the tool, then heat trip the tip and I'm ready to go.

I've made several tool by silver soldering HSS tool tips. They do hold an edge well but I'm not sure it was worth the trouble. I also have a hollowing tool I made from a small Hunter #1 cutter. It holds an edge forever but is kind of directional on the cut. By that I mean I cut in the proper direction or it gets grabby. I use it mostly when I'm doing an ornament with holes and you can see inside. The Hunter tool leaves a better quality of finish.

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#10

JB Weld is a better choice *LINK*

Curly Smith

>PC-7 may not be much more heat tolerant than CA. I included the link for one line: Not for soft plastic or heat over 230 deg.F but PC-7 will start to weaken in prolonged use at 200 degrees.


"PC-7" EPOXY

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#11

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

Thad

>What I've read indicates the following:

CA heat tolerance up to 120F & it begins to loosen

PC-7 " " ~200F

JB Weld holds at a constant 500F & fails at 600 / cures in 15 hrs

JB Weld Kwik holds at temps up up 300F / cures in 4 hrs

I also came across a few write-ups indicating that when CA glue is heated it releases cyanide gas. Curious how true this is.

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#12

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

john lucas

>Ed I didn't catch one that squirted most of the way and dried. I started drilling tiny holes in the side of my tool handles near the bottom of the drilled hole. Any excess epoxy simply squirts through the hole and fills it up.

I think a good clamp to push the tip in place and hold it until the epoxy hardens would stop that problem.

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#13

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

Russ Fairfield

>CA wins this argument for me. Others may have a different opinion, but here is mine.

I have tried both CA glue, JB Weld, and industrial epoxies similar to PC-7. While the epoxies have a higher heat tolerance and are stronger than CA, there is a problem with them turning into a granular form with little to no strength after they have been heated to a high enough temperature to loosen the cutting tool. That means drilling out the hole in the shaft, or otherwise removing all of the epoxy before reinserting the cutting tool.

They also take a longer time to cure to full strength, where a CA joint only takes 2 minutes. There is no accelerator for the epoxies.

CA on the other hand, can be heated until it is soft, but will go back to its original strength after it has cooled and given a couple drops of the thin CA to fill in any cracks that may have formed in the joint.

There is always a safety issue because it will take the heat from a propane torch to loosen the high temperature expoxy, and there is enough heat in a soldering iron to melt the CA glue.

Yes, CA glue can get hot and melt in use, but since it is easier to remove and sharpen, I will be doing that more often, and the cutting tool will generally be cooler because it is sharper. Blowing on it with an air hose will keep it cool in most cases, and a squirt of water will cool it down quickly if it gets really hot.

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#14

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

Ed Moore of SW VA

>Thad,

Thanks for the specs. I'm beginning to think that JBW Kwik might be a good compromise. Or, regular epoxy.

Ed

Re: JB Weld versus PC-7 for cementing ...

#15

Steven Antonucci

For anything that small, I just use the rod

steve antonucci

>1/4" is only good for a small tool, so I just bend the rod in a vise and grind the end to my cutting profile. Fast and easy- nothing to fail. I only heat treat the very tip, so it might take 3 minutes...

Steve