>Anybody want to trade a Thompson 1/2" detail gouge for a Thompson 1/2" shallow detail gouge?
Nothing wrong with the tool it just did not perform as I expected for hollowing boxes; the flute is too shallow. I believe the regular detail gouge would better serve my purposes.
Hardly driven, extremely low mileage, original paint, still under manufacturer's warranty, never mounted in a handle....permanently.
Since I am new to turning I want to learn what I can from Wood Central experience turners. I have been interested in the various shapes of boxes you turn. They are GREAT! Wonder why you feel the shallow detail gouge is not up to what you expected. Does not remove wood fast enough or work well on hard woods?
I bought the 3/8 detail spindle gouge and for lack of experience have used it to hollow two dozen boxes so far. Actually surprised at the depth of box I could do for reach over tool rest. INEXPERIENCE true!
What I miss on your box picture posting is a look inside! Not sure how you handle each shape inside and lips verses what I have seen. Maybe it would tell me what I need to be doing. Are your boxes real thin wall?
Sorry no trade so far of any Thompson tools. Learning that much.
>The shallow flute does not permit rapid enough stock removal when I am hollowing. My hopes were that the extra steel under the flute would permit extended reach over the tool rest. It does that the small flute does not permit removal of stock as quickly as I am use to. I thought I would give one a try and see if it would work and it did not.
Like I said nothing wrong with the tool it just does not work well in the intended application.
Galen, my boxes are not uniform in thickness for a reason. The lids must be a little thicker than the body of the box because of the stress that can occur applying and removing a lid. The bottom is a little thicker to provide some heft so the box sits where you place it and it doesn't get blown over in a breeze. I learned a long time ago not to get the bottom too thin because if the box is dropped on the floor the bottom can pop right out. Generally the body of the box is 1/8" or so and the lid and bottom might be closer to 3/16-1/4".
I used to post pictures of my boxes both open and closed and continue to take pictures both ways. I will have to post some pictures occasionally of an open box. Some of the more bulbous enclosed forms are hard to photograph inside.
I'm slow, so that must be why the 3/8 shallow works for me!
I was saving your WoodCentral box pictures for inspiration then Molly Winton got me into WoW. Plenty of album pictures there of all types of turnings to refer to and dream about.
>I've seen a hollow form hollowed with a detail gouge so I assume it's the same thing on a box. Michael Hosaluk is huge fan of the shallow detail in a 1/2 and 5/8 diameters but on the outside of his turnings.
You do understand that there is not a thing wrong with your tool. It just does not have sufficient flute for the application. I am certain the regular detail gouge will be great as is the the spindle gouge I bought which I am using every day.
Ths shallow detail gouge would be an ideal tool for the outside of turnings and spindle work.
I appreciate your willingness to satisfy a customer. I am not a dissatisfied customer. I just bought the wrong tool.
>Mike I was going to offer to trade but since Doug did I'll hang on to my spindle gouge. I have been hollowing boxes with the detail gouge although I prefer to use the bowl gouge. The long wings remove wood very fast. I've been using the Thompson bowl gouge to hollow followed by the Hunter tool to clean it up and reduce the sanding necessary.
Sometimes I'll just use the detail gouge because it's already been used to do part of the outside and I've already got it in my hand.
>And now you know another reason why I own one of every gouge, spindle and bowl, that Doug produces. Great product, great price and unbelievable customer service. If everybody in this country trying to sell us something had Doug's attitude towards product qualoty coupled with customer service/satisfaction, there would be a whole lot more happy customers for everything ... and perhaps this could be extended to the various levels of government and other service related activities (healthcare, insurances of all kinds, etc.). Anyway, kudos to Doug, and, no, I have no financial bonds to Doug ... just a happy customer!
>... about Doug giving hats away. When my wife died 2 yrs. ago I walked into the funeral home and there was a wooden sun hat exactly like one that my Shan wore while working in her garden. Doug had somehow found the funeral home here in KY and the hat was atop a basket full of cut yellow iris, just as she grew and loved. I lost it right there, and Doug's hat is right here on my bookshelves where I see it every day. Thank's again Doug!
>Oh my goodness! Doug, that has to be one of the sweetest things I've every heard! What a kind, generous, and thoughtful heart you have. Jamie, what a wonderful item to gaze upon and bring good memories.