Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

Posts

New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#1

New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

wilbur

>I made this bowl for some friends of ours out of a tree that fell over in their yard. They asked me to help chop it up to get it out of there, and I would up with some ambrosia maple log segments.


I was going to just give this bowl to them as a souvenir, but the Middlesex County Fair was just a week away, and my wife told me that I should enter this bowl in the Home Arts competition.

Somehow, I wound up with a first place ribbon!


I have no idea how I won, as there was another NJ turner that entered a lot of stuff, and it was clear to me that he was much better and more experienced at turning than I was. He got second place in the bowl category. But I have some theories:

1. The other turner took first place in every other category that he entered, including getting a Best of Show award, so my blue ribbon was a pity award.

2. The other turner is from northern New Jersey, and I'm an actual resident of Middlesex County, so I got home court advantage.

3. The other turner's entry into the bowl category was a large natural edged hollow form, made of walnut, I think. His piece came in near the top and then flared out again, and the judges figured that it was more of a vase, not a bowl, so he got docked points for his piece not really being a bowl. Besides, he had entered something else in the vase category.

Still, a blue ribbon is a blue ribbon, according to my wife.

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#2

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

Texian

>Accept the award graciously and appreciate it. Your entry was very nice work.

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#3

Steve Kubien

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

Steve Kubien

>Dont' analyze it. Enjoy it. Congratulations.

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#4

Great bowl Wilbur

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Wilbur,

I think it is very deserving of the ribbon. The shape looks terrific to me.

I would say that your wife is a very wise women for prompting you to enter.

Well done!!

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#5

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Congratulations Wilbur! Unless you grabbed the ribbon off someone else's bowl, it matters not what the process is that the judges used to arrive at their conclusion. Besides that, it is a nice looking piece, with clean simple lines that show off the patterns in the wood.

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#6

Wilbur, you won the Blue Ribbon......

Ruth Niles

>You won the Blue Ribbon simply because your bowl was the best one there! It's beatifully done.

Congratulations.

Where in Middlesex was this fair? My Mom lives in that area and she would have loved to have seen woodturning other than mine. : )

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#7

Steven Antonucci

It looks like a winner to me!

steve antonucci

>I was supposed to put something into the show with out club, but I just forgot to do it! Most of the turning was probably from NJ Woodturners, and this looks as good as anything most of the guys will bring to a meeting!

You've snatched the pebble, Grasshopper!

S

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#8

Your bowl has ...

Ed Moore of SW VA

>an excellent shape and is deserving of recognition.

People assume that the judging process is an absolute and that perfection occurs. This leads to the following question: What may you conclude from your bowl receiving the blue ribbon?

Answer: You may conclude that on that day the judge(s) decided that your bowl was deserving of recognition and it was awarded the blue ribbon because they thought that it was the best in its category.

Anything else you read into the situation is a waste of time. Accept that your work has been honored and don't undermine that honor. Analyzing how they reached that decision is about as useful as putting airbrakes on a turtle.

Somehow your comments remind me of a lady who was a dental receptionist. She had a hearing deficiency and did not understand what was being said when there was an obscene phone call. She asked that he repeat what he said, so he did. She still didn't understand, so she asked again and he repeated it. This time she understood and she immediately hung up.

It is as if you don't understand that your bowl was honored and you seem to want a recount or re-judging. ;^D

Congratulations!

Ed

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#9

Waddaya Mean ?

Don Orr

>You don't know how you won ???

That's a great bowl and deserves it !

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#10

And maybe you won because it was the best bowl

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#11

Congrats on the accomplishment

Thad

>

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#12

Re: So you won't be giving it away?

Bill Gasper

>You can always make another - obviously you know how. Congrats!

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#13

Re: Wilbur, you won the Blue Ribbon......

wilbur

>Hi Ruth,

The Middlesex County Fair is at the county fairgrounds here in East Brunswick, NJ. It's always a lot of fun. If you don't want to look at the Home Arts competition, there's always the pig races. :@)

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#14

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

wilbur

>Thanks for all the compliments! I realized that after reading all of your responses, I forgot to put in a bunch of smiley faces in my original post. So here they are:

:@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@) :@)

I am really happy with how things worked out. And back when I made this bowl, after putting the finish on, I looked at it and thought it was one of the better bowls I've made.

I still wouldn't have entered it into the competition if it wasn't for my wife, though.

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

#15

Re: New personal milestone in bowl making *PICS*

Barry Turner

>Without the benefit of seeing the other guy's work, I suspect your bowl won on it's totally on it's own merits. It's a very beautiful bowl that anyone would be proud of.