>So can anyone who owns a Sorby Patriot chuck tell me what's different about it (other than using a ball-end hex wrench) that doesn't make it a direct knock-off of a Vicmarc chuck (e.g. the VM-100)? We now (apparently) have three incarnations of the same thing - the original Vicmarc made in Australia, a lower quality and less expensive knock-off of the VM-100 sold by Grizzly, and now the British-made 'Patriot' by Sorby. Imitation is one of the most sincere forms of flattery, except in the business world where it results in having to share the market!
Is there anything really different on the Patriot that makes it distinct from the Vicmarc?
>Rob I've wondered the same thing. I have 2 Vicmarc's and on Grizzly. You can swap inserts and jaws between the 2. The Grizzly isn't as accurate or as smooth but for most purposes works quite well. It does rust easier and had some sharp edges. My next chuck will be a Vicmarc without a doubt. They are just well made, accurate chucks.
What's the price on the Sorby? I have two of the $99 Griz chucks and consider them good value for the price. No doubt some others are better, but mine grip the wood securely and cause it to rotate when the lathe is turned on. If this were metal turning I would be more concerned about minor differences in accuracy and precision.
>the axminster chuck is one of the best,all the jaws from any make can be put on it,even the grizzly aldo metal jaws will fit even there is a kit that brings wood and metal jaws my2cents
The Patriot sells for $215 plus a $ 25 insert (unless you buy the M33-3.5 version for $ 220 without the need for an insert - Catering to the Oneway market?). See the link to Packard's page on this chuck below. This is directly comparable in price with the Vicmarc VM-100 with an insert (ca. $ 240).
John:
I'm also a Vicmarc guy - I have two VM-100's, one VM-120, and one of the Grizzly VM-100 knock-offs (the 1-1/4"-8tpi version), with about 6 Vicmarc jaw sets. It just seems that the size, use of a hex key (the "new" ball end key is the "feature"), and price of the Patriot seem to indicate that Sorby is trying to hone in on the market with another Vicmarc clone - whether or not it can exchange jaws with them (or the Nova) is almost moot. It just appears that the basic design is the same.
>I believe that it is a knock off of the Nova chuck. I bought the 1" pin jaws for use on the Nova because they have two screws for each section of jaw and I wanted to use them in compression mode. Well they must be made of tin because they will bend while tightening on a piece such as a pen blank that is not square or tapered. Very disappointing. Will the Vicmarc jaws fit the Nova chucks(if it fits one it will fit all)? If so VM100 or VM120? They have a sturdy looking set of 1-3/8 pin jaws.
>I'm not sure that using the "new ball-end hex key" is a feature. I scrapped mine and now use a regular straight hex key with my SuperNova II. A friend of mine had excessive and premature wear using the the ball-end hex key. He had to send his SuperNova II in for replacement of the hex-key sockets after on ly a few weeks of usage.