>Thanks to everyone for your comments on the "Unrant" thread below. A lot of good information and sound advice came forth, which is not unusual for this group.
I gather from the private emails I received that this topic, namely how to arrive at an appropriate price for a turning, is one of considerable interest. It is unfortunate, perhaps, that so many variables come into play and complicate the issue.
As a curiosity, I have included a photo of the walnut bowl I used as an example for my question. I have concluded that a reasonable price for the bowl is $50. Factors considered: size is 6" x 3". The warping makes the piece unique. Figure of wood is a plus. Finish is good. No cracks or splits. Name on the bottom is not a plus. Aiming for a low-end market. I like it.
>My not so serious response - based on the replies to your original post I guess $1.35 would be a fair price for me to charge for a nice 9 inch cherry bowl. I don�t live in Manhattan so my location carries no overhead. I�m retired so my time does not count. I�m new at turning so I have no reputation to count. I bought my lathe, tools, sanding and finishing supplies and other accessories without intent to profit so they don�t count. The wood was free and I�ve had the chainsaw and band saw for 20 years or more so they don�t count. The only thing left is the electricity used and I can only guess at that�.$1.35. The fact that I can turn a nice small bowl with a fair curve and no tool marks or sanding scratches and sell it for that price makes me very proud. Especially when I know that other turners will understand these factors and will not complain that I am undercutting them. NOT!
I hope all read this with the humor that�s intended. I thought it helps illustrate the plight of many amateur turners where price determination is concerned. I do absolutely agree with the previous postings concerning how someone new to selling could go about setting a price and have called on the knowledge and experience of others myself.
In my market(Kansas City area) for my work , your price of $50 for this piece is about right. I don't sell a lot of work, but sales are steady at the one gallery I work with. Price is a real conundrum isn't it.
>I'm with Steve. In my area prices are usually low unless sold in a gallery. At one of the local art shows it would probably move at about $35 and maybe$40. At $50 it might sell but would sit there longer. In a couple of the local galleries it would move at a reasonable time frame for the $50 price.
Thanks for all this discussion. I think people have seen how pricing can vary so much depending on a wide mix of variables.
>In my earlier posts on this subject, I have mentioned RETAIL pricing. I look at that as a gallery price. The reason is simple...you can't undercut your galleries and other retailers for similar work. John makes the distinction between gallery pricing and art/craft show pricing. For myself, if I am in the neighbourhood of one of my retailers or galleries, I will NOT undercut them. Doing so may see me sleeping with the fishes.
Perhaps that was obvious to everyone and I have merely wasted space.
>Neither would I Steve. When I set a price on a piece it is the selling price to the customer. I have a wholesale price to the gallery. The reason I was saying there are two different prices is simply what price would sell in my gallery. If I was to sell the same work in both places the price to the customer would be the same. What I do in my area is simply to sell 2 different types of work. The low end stuff I sell at special shows in the area. Mostly to help out the people in the show because it's a charity event or they simply want bodies there and I get rid of stuff that I normally would not sell in a gallery.
I make work just for my galleries after discussing with the owners about what they want and the prices they think will sell.
>Steve I know what you mean. Many years ago I was at a lecture by one of the art organizations and they had a long debate about gallery sales vs craft show and out of your house sales. It was pretty well explained how you would be cutting your own throat for future sales if you sell work and undercut your galleries.
I've found the best thing to do in situations where you are selling to friends of coworkers out of your house is not to cut the price but to give them somethings else, either free or at reduced cost. This makes them happy and you haven't undercut your gallery.
This is often done in business when you buy in volume. You buy 50 cameras and we give you 50 lenses free. That way you can tell other dealers you give them the same prices on cameras they have to pay but your giving your volume dealer effectively a discount. We found that out when investigating why the New York Camera dealers could sell a camera below out cost.
I didn't catch this discussion until now, but I did go back and read the responses to your original Unrant... nice green-turned bowl, BTW...
I think you got some very good responses. I especially like Jack Savona's response, about showing your work to a gallery or craft shop manager in your area, and asking them for their opinion. This is doubly important, in my view. First, you need to select a shop that has the right sort of customer base and price range -- it needs to be a gallery that's good enough for your work -- and you need to be certain your work is good enough for their gallery. Second, with good advice from a craft shop or gallery manager, you'll be able to factor in the local area, the economic climate you're in and the tourist factor, among others.
There are so many factors to pricing, but the three that seem to matter most are the quality of your work, the quality of your name, and the quality of your market. A bowl that would have a hard time selling for $25 in one place might easily sell for $125 in Aspen, and might not get into a gallery in New York selling $12,000 pieces from the masters. Then there's pricing and factoring in the commission to the gallery. Around here, most are commission shops that keep 40% and give the maker 60%. So if a bowl sells for $100 in a gallery, you would only get $60 for it. If you sell it at a craft show in your own booth, you still sell it for $100, but you hopefully get to keep more than $60 after meeting your expenses. On the flip side, if you're not willing to take less than $100, and the shop takes 40%, you have to price it at $167 to take home $100, and you'd better be selling that same piece for about the same price when selling from home or your other area venues if you want that gallery to keep selling your work.
You asked: "...if you are a new turner and you make a bowl, how can you determine the price that should be asked for the bowl?"
First response: if you're new at *pricing* your work, look at other work of similar quality and design (very subjective), and see where your work would fit in. Or, do as Jack S. said, and ask the experts.
Here's another, more hard-ass answer to your question: If you're a *new turner*, you shouldn't be selling your work. If you look at the stuff being sold at galleries, and your work is not as good or better, keep giving away gifts and turning tops for kids until your work is at least on par with other "good quality" work that you admire. From what I see in your photo, you've done a nice job, and have produced a fine bowl. However, I have seen some beginners who want to start selling their treasures in gift shops, and sometimes I'm under-impressed, and go away convinced they need more practice, better design skills, or a more discriminating eye. All of these are entirely subjective, but I have a pretty good feel for the workmanship and artistry of turned wood. The craftsmanship can be much more objective, but a flawless finish on a badly-shaped piece still falls short in my book. This is the subjective and unpredictable stuff.
When my dad was alive, he used to make some really cool burl bowls that sold very well -- probably because he had exposed and presented the raw beauty of a highly unusual piece wood. He also made some high-gloss pieces with shapes I didn't like at all, but in one gift shop in a tourist town, those sold pretty well, too. For some people shiny finishes on wood make 'em happy -- even if the shape is a real dog. This rarely -- if ever -- works in the higher-priced galleries that handle the work of the best-known artists in the area.
So, like Bill G and others replied, pricing is highly subjective, regionally specific, and often depends more on who you are and where you are than what you make.
You made the "hard-assed" statement: "If you're a *new turner*, you shouldn't be selling your work."
I believe this is the first time I've seen or heard this, and it makes a good bit of sense. I've been turning almost five years now, and have sold only a few pieces. Many more have gone away as gifts, but most of what I've done is stashed around the house. At least I did something right!
When I sort through "my work," I can recognize several stages or generations that I've passed through. At the time, I thought they were "pretty good," but now I'm glad I didn't try to sell them.
Now I sit and wonder how many more stages I should go through before I should seriously begin to peddle my wares. I'm constantly amazed at how much there is to know and learn about this game of making round things out of wood. ~Doc
>Yes and no. As you know I make a very wide range of work. I know what kind of work and the quality that will sell at my local galleries. I've also known one of the managers for a very long time and she knows what all I make. Since she has a revolving array of artists her products change a little from time to time. I simply ask her what she needs and she will say, how about some of your boxes, or I need more mirrors. I might bring a selection of hollow vessels and ask she would like to try those. It works well for both of us. This gallery is owned by the University and can't under law buy from me so everything is consignment. It opens up a lot of experimentation in what will sell because she doesn't have money involved.
One other gallery is a sort of medium to high end gift shop. I usually bring a selection of items and let them pick although I've learned what she likes and will sort of cater to that. It's silly to bring things like my cupcake boxes to her because I know she won't sell them. A well done spalted bowl or exotic wood boxes are more to her taste.
Hopefully in the long run when I have some serious time to turn I will develop a style and pick up galleries that will buy my style.
A lot of the work I do is experimental in technique or simply made just for the fun of it. These probably won't sell in my galleries or are simply too few to put there. This is what I take to the local shows but you can't guess what will sell at those anyway. What usually sells at those is anything cute or inexpensive so I price things accordingly and clean out my storage cabinet. I haven't done any of these in about 2 years now so my cabinet if quite full right now.
>1.) If you stick a price on something, you just might get it.
2.) You still need to market.
A lot of the work on Etsy is very good. Some of it is overpriced. Some of it is very amateur. The venue is like a bazaar- just because you have a cart in the market, it doesn't mean you will have sales. You have to get out there and let people know about your product to attract a buyer. As you can see, some people have also "made up" their prices...
>After looking at the things on Etsy, I have a few comments. Some of it was pretty nice, most of it was ho hum, and a fair amount looked pretty clunky to me. My opinions have nothing to do with 'will it sell?' People will buy just about anything if the price is right. If you are just starting and some one wants to buy it, go right ahead. I had to start selling before my stuff was of really high quality just to support my habbit. You will get better and faster. I can finish turn a bowl that used to take me 45 minutes to an hour in 5 minutes now. The sanding time has followed suit. The best way to find out what people like is to sell face to face, but even then, you never know what will sell from one day or show to the next.