Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Unrant: Price Info Not Available

Posts

Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#1

Unrant: Price Info Not Available

Doc Green

>Over the past couple of years, I'll bet I've read a dozen articles on how to determine the price of a turned piece. One thing all the articles had in common: no real price information was given. None.

The writers go on at length about all sorts of things, like overhead, cost of tools, time spent, electricity to run the lathe, geographic location, and so forth. Fills a column and sounds good, but in my mind, it's worthless unless some hard numbers are provided at the end.

Here's my point: if you are a new turner and you make a bowl, how can you determine the price that should be asked for the bowl? Where are the guidelines that give numerical dollar amounts for various pieces? Why is meaningful pricing information so hard to find?

I know the price will depend on a lot of things. I got that from reading the articles. But somewhere, sometime, someone needs to put a dollar amount on it. Until that is done, any discussion of pricing is a vague, nebulous waste.

It seems to me that it would be beneficial for everyone if professional turners and serious sellers would get together in some fashion and develop a set of guidelines and suggested prices for various objects. At least, this would be something concrete that you could refer to. Perhaps the AAW or some other group could address this matter.

Meanwhile, I have this bowl ...walnut with contrasting sapwood, about 8" in diameter and 3" tall. Turned green, allowed to warp. Good finish--no tool marks or scratches. Plus, it sits flat; no rocking or wobble. And I have no idea what price I should place on it.

~Doc

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#2

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Doc, you wrote in your post, "The writers go on at length about all sorts of things, like overhead, cost of tools, time spent, electricity to run the lathe, geographic location, and so forth."

There you have it, right there. Yeah, it isn't hard numbers, but hard numbers can't be had. Several years ago I built a table for a customer, and I gave him a price. In the course of building it, I corresponded and spoke on the phone with the author of a book on making tables. He informed me that I had undercharged for my table to the tune of about $1600 or so. He then sent me a spreadsheet of all the things that would go into his pricing of the table. After I read it, the two of us went over it together, and deleted all the things that he charged for, being in Manhattan, that I did not charge for. He had charges in there for things like a truck rental, parking space costs, disposal of scraps, etc. I already own a truck, parking in my space is free, and I burn my scraps in my wood furnace. There were more, but you get the point. By the time we backed out all the costs of doing business in Manhattan that do not occur in Kutztown, I was actually charging $50 more for my table than he would have, even though it was $1600 cheaper!

The end result is that you have to do some work on your own to get to hard numbers. There are too many variables to make a formula for everyone. A good friend of mine, whose name a lot of people here would recognize, used to price his bowls at $10.00 per inch of diameter. A lady asked him to make a 30" diameter bowl, and before he knew it, he had agreed to do it for $300. He stuck by his word, but he told me he had learned his lesson and would never do that again. You need to decide what your time is worth. For some it is worth more to them than others. Some people have more time in a piece. Some have more invested in education, equipment. Some have more name recognition. If you take a well made bowl and put three different names on it, you are going to get three different prices just for that!

So that is why people don't give out hard numbers. It is too hard to number these things.

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#3

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Offer it for sale at a price you think is correct. If it sells right away it might have been too inexpensive. If it sits on the shelf for several months, maybe the price is too high.

What I can sell for $200 may not sell in your area for that. Taking time , etc. into consideration is so dependent upon many factors that change from person to person.

There is not an easy way to determine the price at which the piece will sell.

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#4

How high is up?

Barry Irby

>You have asked the $64,000 question.

In some sense, there is no answer. What you are looking at is Cost VS. Value. As an appraiser of houses and Real estate, I suppose we could draw some comparisons. The answer is, What a willing buyer is willing to pay and what a willing seller is willing to take. Or what the market will bear.

Cost has very little to do with it. You might have gotten your walnut for free. Or you might have paid a premium for it. The buyer does not care if you paid a dollar to run your lathe or you used a spring pole lathe and used no electricity. It doesn't matter whether you bought your finish by the drum and used a nickel's worth or you bought a sample sized bottle and paid a dollar. Where all this does matter, is to you, the seller. If you discover that after all your cost analysis you can not sell your work for enough to satisfy your needs for money, you will not be a willing seller at whatever that price is.

There is a lot of discussion here and in other sites about price and what some sellers are able to get. There are a few among us that command remarkable prices. Many of those people have sent a lifetime or at least a career developing their skills, inventing tools and techniques and marketing themselves and their wares. There are some of them that I can imitate quite nicely and sometimes I am baffled by the fact that they can get perhaps $1,000 for a piece that I can't sell for $100.

Does having the right signature on the bottom of a piece increase the value by ten or twenty fold? Apparently so. It was ever thus. A Picasso painting sells for more than one of mine. So, apparently some buyers are willing to pay more for pieces that have the "right" signature on them. Some pieces are more collectible than others.

OTOH, there is treen. Working bowls. Wooden wear. Stuff you actually use. You can get the price of this stuff by going to any store that sells it. Hard to compete with it. Cranked out by the thousands in production mills.

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#5

Re: How high is up?

Sean Troy

>Look at other turners websites and see what kind of area they live in, type of turning they do and average it out for a ball park starting place.

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#6

Re: How high is up?

Bill Crommett

>This reminds me of Willard Baxter telling of the time he was turning with Rude Osolnik and Willard asked Rude how much the piece should sell for. Rude said : "Who's going to sign it, you or me?".

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#7

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available *LINK*

Fred W Holder

>When I retired in 1993, I decided to suppliment my income by selling some of my work at craft shows. I never did extremely well, but it did supply some income. As a former business man, I kept detailed records of costs and sales. After three years, I found that I had averaged about 25 cents per hour, including production and selling. I learned a few things that made me decide to quit selling my work.

Number One: small local craft shows are a nice place to go, but don�t

plan to make any money. That�s where I had been going. I was told that you can only make money at craft shows if they are large national affairs where people come to buy and expect to pay well for the artists work.

Number Two: You really don�t do too well, until you become well known.

Your name begins to sell your products, not just your quality. A great deal of woodturning is purchased by collectors or by people who are going to display the item on a shelf, table, etc. Only a small amount is bought to use. If you�re well known, it increases your chance of

a sale. Remember, Richard Raffan said that today he can charge much more for his work than a beginner can, even if the quality of work is the same. The Raffan name helps sell the product.

This is excerpted from an article I wrote for the first issue of More Woodturning, which was published in October 1996. I realize that prices may have increased from that time to now, but the size of the show and name on the bottom of the piece has a significant impact on what people will be willing to pay.


More Woodturning website

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#8

Steve Kubien

I'll give a pretty direct answer...LONG

Steve Kubien

>I am trying to make a living as a turner. I am a stay-at-home dad and my wife has a great job that pays well, has good benefits and she really likes it. I do not have a separate shop that I have to rent out. I do not have a way to seperate my hydro into shop-use vs domestic use so I do not try. If I knew how to do that kind of math accurately, Stephen Hawkings would be working for me.

Pricing a bowl is really very simple.... Width x height x a variable. The variable includes things like the wood (super curly or a bit plain), emblishments like burning, carving, colouring etc, size and, most importantly, how good a job did you do. Add the cost of the wood if you bought it on top. Don't try to figure out the cost of sanding and finishing. See the previous paragraph.

So, what's the variable? Most folks I have run into put it somewhere in the neighbourhood of 2.5 to 5. So, your 10" x 4" salad bowl ought to be somewhere between $100 and 200 RETAIL. That is not wholesale or a price you expect to get from a gallery or store. How do you determine where you ought to be? Well, how good are you? Really. Are you better than the next guy or unique in some way? These are the things you need to ask yourself.

So, does that help at all or have I just p*ssed off a bunch of others?

As for pens, peppermills and other things... I know what I figure I am worth per hour. This is determined simply by what I made in my last couple of real jobs and what I realistically think I could earn in the real world based on my job-experience and education. This figure per hour, plus actual cost of kits, mechanisms etc is what I charge. I may add a little extra for a dye job or carving or whatever but that ought to give you an idea. Will I say what my rate per hour is? No I won't but I can tell you it is no where near the $50-$70 per hour I have heard from others.

Think I am opinionated? Let's talk politics or religion or something really serious.

Take care!

Steve

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#9

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

robo hippy

>I had a nice Madrone burl bowl that was large, about 8 inches high and about 14 diameter, nicely warped, and the prime purple/maroon color that Madrone can get. I sold it for $300 which I thought was overpriced. I happened to have another turner in my booth, who told me after the sale, it would have gone for $2000 easy in any gallery on Long Island. Your walnut bowl I would price from a minimum of $30 or so up to about $60, or maybe more, depending on where I am, if I like it more than other pieces I have, and how long it has been on the shelf. The only rule I can think of is to find another turner in the area where you are showing and see what they charge. Compare your work, and price accordingly.

robo hippy

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#10

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

Russ Fairfield

>Pricing woodturnings is like pricing horses. If it has a bloodline, the price starts at $1000 and goes up from there. If it hasn't, it starts at $Zero. After that it's all about appearance and whatever the buyer is willing to pay.

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#11

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

Bob Macgregor

>Actually, not zero; I think the cull (horsemeat) market sets the floor. Plus, I know from sad experience that a horse can go from $50k to horsemeat in value overnight.

The bowl pricing question is really a bit like asking what a house should sell for, without telling what market, location, features, etc.

BOB

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#12

A way to price it?

Jack Savona

>Doc, I would suggest taking your bowl to a gift shop or two that you think would carry items of comparable quality to your bowl. Ask the owner/buyer for help. Explain your situation and ask for a range that they think would be a fair market price for it.

You'll still have the subjective element present, but perhaps this can begin to help you narrow down the parameters.

Another factor to consider is the uniqueness of the wood and any embellishments like a filler, burned lines, beads or other special treatments. Two 8" bowls, one with plain wood, another with a lot of figure, will not sell for the same price.

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#13

Steven Antonucci

Your work is priced by you alone

steve antonucci

>Forget about what other people would charge.

Forget about what a bowl sells for at WalMart.

Foget about accounting for your time in $$$/inch or hour.

Make up a number and put it on the bowl. If you get it, be happy. The only reason that some turners make more than other turners is that they ask for more. Nobody will ever give you $50 for a bowl with a $20 sticker. Anyone that would pay $50 for a bowl would probably also think about paying $100...

Steve

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#14

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

Rick Allen

>You asked for a method so here it is.

A production turner should be able to make a bowl in the number of minutes equal to the diameter times the height. So a production turner should be able to make the bowl you have described in 8x3=24 minutes. A production turner will spend about 50% of his (or her) time working at activities supporting bowl production other than by making the bowl (collecting and buying wood and supplies...). So how much do you think a production woodturner should earn? $40/hour sounds good to me. That means 48/60 times 40 = 32 (round up to the nearest $5) => $35

The value of the wood should be added to this. Walnut goes fro about $6/bf

8x8x3 = 192

144 into 192 = 1 1/3BF

Walnut at $6/bf

1.33 x 6 = 8 round = to the nearest 5 so 8 becomes 10

10 + 35 = $45

This pricing method is adapted from the method which Richard Raffan describes on page 4 and 5 of his book "Turned-Bowl Design".

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#15

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

Texian

>The owner of my small local gallery has been helpful with pricing. While not a turner, she is an artist as well as business owner and has a feel for what her customers would be willing to pay for a given piece of work.

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#16

Also

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Barbara gives you good advice.

To set my prices, first, how much I paid for the wood, second, how much time I have invested on it, third, overhead. Then I watch what happens in the market, if it sells right away, the price is low, if it doe not sell, the price is high; I should mention that are pieces that just do not sell, I still have 3 pieces from the year before last! all three are beautiful, good finish and knock out figured wood, their partners, (the other side of the same chunk of tree) are long gone and these are still here...

Go figure

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

#17

Re: Unrant: Price Info Not Available

arkie

>The bowl should be priced at the most you think you can persuade someone to pay for it. Forget the formulas - you've already made this bowl.

Once you've sold it, run the formulas, figure your costs, and decide if you want to make another like it. Once it's made, forget the costs again.

Do you see a picture emerging? Once a piece is made, costs no longer matter, only market value. If you can sell a story with the bowl - the sizzle with the steak - that adds to the market value.

If you can get commissions, use cost estimates to price them, then again, toss them once you get the commission.