How Much HasChanged? *LINK*
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Notice the safety glasses
1926
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
How Much HasChanged? *LINK*
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Notice the safety glasses
1926
Very nice to see it old school
Rick Allen
>
Re: How Much HasChanged?
Cyril Griesbach
>That was great video, Mark, and so was the music. Notice the slight "catch" he gets with the hook tool which also shows that not much has changed.
Not Much
Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada
>Very cool to watch, I enjoyed watching that very much. Noticed a hook tool in there as well, it shows you that much of what we know today has been around for some time. With the exception of leaving the hole on the bottom of the bowl it all seemed consistant with what most of would do.
I wonder about the sanding technique, everything seemed to be at the same speed on the lathe.
Take care,
Jim
He He
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>More than one catch there.
Nice Tormek
steve antonucci
>I like the use of only a few simple tools. Bet he'd done it before they shot the video...
S
Re: How Much HasChanged?
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
>I guess nothing much has changed. Have a look at the tool he uses for hollowing the bowl. Today we would call it a shallow spindle roughing gouge and it is now considered dangerous to use on bowls. But look at the tang on it -- over half an inch square. So it will not fold over as modern spindle roughing gouges do where the handle joins the gouge. That is why it is dangerous. There is one modern exception -- the Hannes tool that Johannes Michaelson sells. It is made by Doug Thompson. It has a huge, thick tang that you could not bend with a tractor! Now look at how the tool is sharpened in the video, and check out the Hannestool is sharpened on YouTube. Both are convex grinds. I have not seen the Hannestool in action but I bet watching Johannes hoillow a bowl would be almost the same as watching this 1926 video -- and the speed at which wood can be removed wojld be equally impressive. Bowls were being made long before the bowl goiuge was invented in the 1960s.
Re: How Much HasChanged?
Dick Hines
>This is the guy I learned how to use a skew from. I like the height he had his tool rest, way above center.
It is cool to see how bowls were turned before the invention of the bowl gouge.
Re: How Much HasChanged?
Russ Fairfield
>I learned how to turn wood with these tools in the early 50's, and yes they do have a convex bevel grind. That bevel is the secret to using the tool because it supports the tool right at the cutting edge, and not 1/4" or more behind it.
That slicing cut across the edge of the tool is the closest you can get to making a good shearing cut on the inside of a bowl, unless you use a hook tool, which he did.
He did have a couple catches, but so does every other woodturner. Sometimes I think we get so worried about being "catch free" that we use inferior tools and profiles, and miss out on a lot of better ways to do it.
Probably Just Plain Old Reading Glasses
Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.
>
Re: How Much HasChanged?
Ron Bauman
>I'm just guessing here, but I don't think that's the first time he'd done that. On the other hand I still have safety glasses like those except mine have little fold back screens on the side in case I get het' up in my eyes. They come in a steel case, too. And one of my lathes is flat belt driven modified from an over head jack shaft. The only thing that creeps me is the long sleeves. Burnishing with the shavings gives a nice warm glow to the finished product.
Re: How Much HasChanged?
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
>I just tried turning three large bowls out of spalted birch using this method. And, boy, does it work. The shearing cut that Russ mentions is the closesst thing you will ever get to a bowl skew. The finish is fabulous.
But, do NOT use just any shallow spindle roughing gouge to do this. They are dangerous because the tangs on the modern ones are so fragile that they bend or shatter! Use an antique one where the blacksmith has beefed up the tang -- or get a Hannestools one with a 3/4 inch tang. P&N also makes a spindle roughing gouge with a half inch thick tang, but the tool is a deep gouge, not the shallow one shown in the video. I use these deep spindle roughing gouges from P&N or (even better) from Doug Thompson, to turn the outsides of large bowls (14 inches or better). They are very efficient at this size or larger -- much more so than a bowl gouge. But, up to that size, a 5/8 inch bowl gouge works equally well or better. Also, you need lots of horseplower -- at least 1 1/2 hp.
Re: That big gouge was a continental....
Jamie Donaldson
>..ground gouge, a very useful spindle gouge still available today for those willing to learn how to use it. I watched Rude Osolnik do many jobs with that gouge and his variations over the years, but I was never able to feel comfortable when I had more friendly alternative tools like the deep flute gouges. And did you notice the skew was used as a negative rake scraper most of the time!
Re: How Much HasChanged?
Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA
>There are only two kinds of people who don't get catches - those who don't turn, and liars. ;-)
Re: That big gouge was a continental....
Keith Tompkins
>Thanks for posting this Mark! The continental gouge is STILL a very useful tool, it's just out of style; most people prefer the round gouges today. Many will be surprised to see how versatile the old continental gouge really is.
Re: How Much HasChanged?
Paul Zerjay
>I actually had a catch last night. First time ever. Usually they just go sailing past my head, but last night I actually caught it.
I had a catch once, but I dropped it...
steve antonucci
>