Butternut shavings & mulch
Donna Parrillo
>I will be making some butternut bowls soon and am wondering if I can use the shavings as mulch for my plants or will it cause problems because it is in the same family as walnut?
Thanks,
Donna P.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Butternut shavings & mulch
Donna Parrillo
>I will be making some butternut bowls soon and am wondering if I can use the shavings as mulch for my plants or will it cause problems because it is in the same family as walnut?
Thanks,
Donna P.
Re: Butternut shavings & mulch
Steve Kubien
>Go to www.gardening-enjoyed.com and ask Ken. If it is plant/gardeing-related, he can answer it.
Hmmm, worked this time
Steve Kubien
>
Re: Butternut shavings & mulch - JUST SAY NO! *LINK*
Rob Wallace
>Donna:
You asked a very good question - although butternut DOES produce juglone, the chemical in walnut responsible for toxic effects on many plants (acts as a respiration inhibitor), it generally is not found in as high a concentration in Carya (hickory and butternut) than it is in Juglans (walnut). It is, however, present and soluble in hickory/butternut tissues!
Therefore, butternut is, none-the-less, toxic to susceptible plant species, and its use as a mulch should be considered carefully. While not all plants are sensitive to juglone (some plants are considered 'juglone tolerant' or 'juglone insensitive'), there is still the chance of having juglone leach from your shavings into the soil, and cause problems. I would not advise using butternut shavings for plant mulch.
This is a good example of where knowing the relationships between plants is an important aspect of dealing with wood! I will probably use this example in lecture this fall when I talk about the practical importance of knowing the biology and relationships of plants in the "real world" [Rhetorical question: Do turners actually live in the REAL WORLD?].
See the link below from the Univ. of Wisconsin Cooperative Extension Service.
Thanks for asking!
Rob Wallace
(Iowa State University)
Univ. Wisconsin Ext. - Walnut/Butternut Toxicity
Re: Butternut shavings & mulch
Ralph
>I give my shavings to a fabric dyeing person that uses them for natural dyes.
Re: Butternut shavings & mulch
Donna Parrillo
>Thank you for the info. It was very helpful.
-Donna
Re: Butternut shavings & mulch
Ralph
>They really liked the 30 gallons of Madrone chips and 1 gallon of Madrona "Juice" I gave them this winter (the juice came from boiling down the water I boiled the bowl blanks in)
Re: Butternut shavings & mulch
Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine
>Donna,
I don't know about butternut as mulch, I mulch a lot with red maple shavings, same with birch and ash and red oak too. The red oak turns into soil rather quick, the red maple too and makes very nice soil.
Jorge