Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

I'm not into segmenting

Posts

I'm not into segmenting

#1

I'm not into segmenting

Paul Zerjay

>But I broke the neck off a real nice HF quite some time ago. It's maple with some really wild figure in it, and it's just too nice to burn. So I want to try to put a staved style "dome" on it. It's turned end grain, and I think I should put a ring around it first before I start the staves. This way I would have the end grain of the vessel glued to the face grain of the ring. Then the ring glued to the end grain of the stave. I think this would be much better than the end grain of the vessel glued straight to the end grain of the stave. Am I making myself clear? And is my thinking correct? Thanks

Re: I'm not into segmenting

#2

Sounds good to me .

Bill Crommett

>

Re: I'm not into segmenting

#3

Re: I'm not into segmenting

john lucas

>Well maybe. You'll have side grain glued to end grain so you could have some movement problems. End grain to end grain you won't have movement problems but you are correct in that you will have a weaker joint. I've done it both ways before I knew better and I've seen a few of those pieces and they are still together so if your vessel is fairly thin I think you'll be OK.

Re: I'm not into segmenting

#4

Re: I'm not into segmenting

Texian

>Paul,

Depends upon the diameter (maybe up to 3" ok), and thickness of the proposed ring. If the ring is essentially veneer, it will stay with the end grain on either side of it. If much thicker, could have movement problem if the diameter is large.

Re: I'm not into segmenting

#5

Re: I'm not into segmenting

Rick Allen

>Have you considered putting a small tenon on the end of the stave section to help with the end grain to end grain glue joint?

I would be concerned about the face grain ring movement with regard to the two end grain pieces.

There is an end grain glue trick that involves a 50-50 mixture of water and glue and a twisting and pressure motion.

"The strength of end grain joints can be improved if the "open" end grain is first sized. A sizing mixture may be made by mixing one part to two parts water to one part glue. Place the sizing mixture on the end grain. Let it soak in for no more than two minutes, and then continue with a regular application of glue."

Then mate the two end grain pieces together and twist the to pieces together back and forth. Keep doing this until the glue grabs. Twist to alignment and you are done.

How or why it works? Not really sure. I do know that it works and I know the glue joint is strong and long lasting.

Size the endgrain

Glue and twist the pieces to setup the glue.

Re: I'm not into segmenting

#6

Re: "Design opportunity!"

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: I'm not into segmenting

#7

Re: I'm not into segmenting

Paul Zerjay

>So end grain glued to end grain is not such a no-no after all? I think I'll forget the ring and try Ricks suggestion.

Re: I'm not into segmenting

#8

Re: I'm not into segmenting

Rick Allen

>Hi Paul,

If you haven't tried this technique I suggest that try gluing a couple of end grain hollow pieces together. Turn a 2" diameter piece, hollow to a wall thickness or 3/8" or less and try the technique. You will learn a LOT from that "test" which will help make your hollow form/stave thing a whole lot more predictable.

When you have difficulty with the test you can ask us what went wrong(;->)

Good Luck

Re: I'm not into segmenting

#9

Re: I'm not into segmenting

Paul Zerjay

>Hi Rick,

Good idea! Thanks

Re: I'm not into segmenting

#10

Re: I'm not into segmenting

john lucas

>Paul A couple of things. Endgrain joints are amazingly week by them selves but you can enhance the joint in several ways. A bunch of years ago I did a test where I glued 3/4" square pieces of maple end grain to end grain and the broke the joint. I tried several glues. Polyeurethane was the weakest followed by CA. I broke the joint with my hands. Yellow and white glue took only a little more force but were greatly increased by the use of the thin sizing technique mentioned above. Still It was so weak I would not trust the joint for a structural piece. Epoxy was a lot better but still pretty weak.

What works for turned pieces is to make a shallow rabbit joint. Turn a tenon on one piece and a rebate for it on the other. This gives you some structural strength, more glue surface and most of all a small amount of side grain to side grain glue joint.

Re: I'm not into segmenting

#11

Re: I'm not into segmenting

Paul Zerjay

>Thanks John. This sounds like a good way to go. Now if I can just figure out the math.

Re: I'm not into segmenting

#12

Re: I'm not into segmenting

john lucas

>There isn't any math, trust me, I'm math illiterate. I cut a rabbit on one piece so it produces a tenon or sort of L shape. Then I measure this and cut an upside down L shape on the other one. If you don't have a way to measure something this large accurately just sneak up on it. Turn a little and then test fit. Kind of like make a lidded box with a press fit lid.

Re: I'm not into segmenting

#13

Re: I'm not into segmenting

Paul Zerjay

>No I meant for the staves