Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

need more McNaugton cutters

Posts

need more McNaugton cutters

#1

need more McNaugton cutters

john lucas

>I have the jumbo set. Works fine for the big bowls but when I get down toward the smaller of the set I feel like I need another cutter or two. Which ones would you all suggest. I really can't afford to buy all of the midi and small set. I'm hoping just one more smaller one but I don't know which curve to get. That last bowls in the set seem to be shallower so I'm thinking the less curved one but is that too much of a duplicate of the larger one.

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

#2

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

Dale Cook

>Hi John, I have the same set as you but want some smaller ones also. I was thinking about the 2 smaller ones from the standard set but haven't decided yet.Hopefully someone will suggest some. Thanks

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: need more McNaugton cutters *LINK*

Rob Wallace

>John:

You can buy the cutters one at a time (about $ 40 a click) and see what works for you. I like to two 'most curved' cutters from the standard set the best. They probably do 75% of my coring.

Rob


McNaughton Standard Cutters at Craft Supplies

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

#4

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Since you have the large jumbo size I would not get the large standard size since the curve is the same. Also, the small jumbo knife is the same curve as the medium size in the standard set, so I would not get that one either. The small knife in the standard set is much smaller curve and I would get it.

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

#5

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

Doug Turner

>John, I have the standard size set and I use the middle one almost exclusively. Mike Mahoney demonstrated for our club using the middle size and cored a bowl about 4" OD, one about 8", and the outer bowl was about 12" all with the middle size cutter.

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

#6

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

robo hippy

>I use the medium curve on the standard set for 90% of my coing. The small curve just doesn't fit most of what I do. The large/flatter curve I will use on platter type shapes, and deeper vessels.

robo hippy

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

#7

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

mark wollschlager

>Are the midi set just used for tiny cores?

I can guess the micro set is just that.

Also have you used the M8 and is the gate that much different/better?

Mark.

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

#8

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

robo hippy

>There are now 4 sets of blades for the McNaughton, the large, standard, mini and micro. The micro are designed to work on mini lathes. I do prefer the new gate. If you get it, you have to get new large blades. They are narrower/thinner than the older ones, and the old ones won't fit in the support fingers.

robo hippy

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

#9

Re: Gates

gtwilkins

>Robo,

Whats the difference in the "new" gate and the original one. Is it worth getting the new one or can you modify the old one?

Trevor

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

#10

Re: need more McNaugton cutters

john lucas

>Thanks for the tips. I've been reading these but forgot to respond. I'll be coring some more weekend after next so I'll get some better ideas of what I need. I can actually make the cutters if I'll get off my butt and finish making my bending jig or at least fire up the forge.

I worked in the shop until midnight monday night getting the metal lathe back in working order so now I should be able to build the tool bending jig. Except for upsetting the cutting end of the jig to make the metal thicker, the cutters can be made by simply bending and cutting them.