I am making some (4) new chairs for my 5th wheel using poplar. The spindles for the legs are 2-1/2" diameter. I sand diligently thru the grits ending with 400 but when LOML applies the finish - boy do the scratches stand out like a sore thumb.
What can I put on to detect the scratches prior to the final finish? The finish is so tough to sand out and gums up the sand paper so quickly that it is not fun!!
>I always try to sand with the grain to take out the circular sanding marks on every grit before going to the next grit. I turn off the lathe and sand with the grain. It does not take very long. I even do this on other turnings as well and not just spindle work.
>I, too, was having trouble seeing fine scratches on my turnings so I replaced the 'soft white' (frosted) incandescent bulb in the light over the lathe with a clear glass bulb. It helped to eliminate the diffusion the frosted bulb provides and provides a harsher, sharper image.
>Wayne, try burnishing the wood with a hand full of shavings. Then, with dim ambient light, shine a bright flashlight across the surface at a very low angle. Any scratches present should pop right out.
To go one step farther, once you think you have removed all the scratches and its ready for the finish, wet the surface with mineral spirits, or, give it a thin coat of lacquer sanding sealer (cut 50/50 with lacquer thinner). Look for scratches while the surface is still wet.
The mineral spirits will evaporate and be gone. Most of the sanding sealer will soak into the wood so it's not a big issue. And if you have to sand it off, it will come off a lot easier than polyurethane, for example. But, let the sealer dry completely before you try to sand it.
You can apply polyurethane over the sealer with no problems. (I don't know how a water-based finish would behave over the sanding sealer. I've never used water-based finishes.)
>Go look at similar chairs in the highest priced furniture store you can find. If you look at them with the same critical eye, you will find they aren't close to being perfect either.
Doing this won't make the scratches go away, but you will be more accepting of them when you realize how much money you saved.
The furniture maker always sees the mistakes and flaws that nobody else does. Nobody else looks at your work from less than a foot away. They look at it in dimmer light from at least 5' away, and things look a lot different from there.
>For spindles I usually sand in the opposite direction that I cut, Small diameter to large diameter.
Clean the spindle between grits.
Sand with the lathe off, with the grain between the higher grits (180 and above).
Wet the surface with a solvent to intensify the view of scratches. Remove those scratches by sanding with the grain.
Magnification can help in detecting scratches.
Russ is of course correct. Sanding scratches in furniture parts is normal. But just because sanding scratches are normal doesn't mean that your extraordinary work can have sanding scratches.
>Because my hand mirrors and ornaments have spindles I turn a lot of these things. There's no need to have scratches. 2 things that work. After you sand with each grit, sand again only with a lighter touch. Concentrate on areas that can't be hand sanded like beads coves. Then sand with the grain with the lathe off. Beads are by far the trickiest area but patience and a good light helps. If I'm having problems I wipe down the piece with a cotton rag between each grit.
I was sanding an Osage Orange bowl last night and no matter how hard I tried I could not sand it under power an not get scratches. I had to hand sand with the grain (and the grain ran in every direction) through each grit to get rid of any scratches. Good light and wiping it down with the cotton rag did the trick.
>I know this is not the question you asked, but it sounds like you could be skipping grits on the lower end of you sanding process. Each successive grit should be just fine enough to remove the scratches left by the previous grit. Wetting the wood with water ought to reveal any scratches. Sanding again, after the wood dries, should also help to remove any leftover scratches. "Raising the grain" is a step that is often overlooked, but one that can be very helpful. With that said, poplar is a wood that is very difficult to remove sanding scratches from. I'm not really sure why this is, because poplar is relatively soft and sands rather easily.
>A turner on this site once said, " sand your pieces like you didn't have to pay for the paper!" Thats what I try to do, using a piece of 400 over and over 'causes scratches that can send you right back to step 2 or even 1.
I agree that no one else will know but me and LOML-she is the one I have to satisfy if I want her help finishing!!!
Since I trashed the cheap paper and sanded as instructed, then checked with minersl spirits- I and wife are pleased with the results and she is back to finishing the legs.
Thanks for the help everyone-knew I could depend on you.