Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

What makes a quality abrasive? Long

Posts

What makes a quality abrasive? Long

#1

What makes a quality abrasive? Long

Vince Welch

>After going back and reading a thread posted a few weeks back let me answer some questions pertaining to abrasives. I use and offer discs for the woodturning market. As you talk around to other turners you will come to know the Blue Flex discs I offer are a big favorite with wood turners for a number of good reasons. More importantly let me address a recent question and share some information talking about the make up of discs and what makes a quality sanding disc!

There are basically three components making up a sanding disc. They are the backing, glue, and the abrasive itself. There are also coatings but we will not get into that at this time. Generally it is these components that make up a sanding abrasive.

The backing generally is made up of 3 different materials�Paper, Cloth, and Film. Wood turners have been use to mostly paper over the years but that has changed over the last few years with the introduction of technology to the abrasive industry.

Paper can provide a very good backing when given the correct thickness of paper. It can allow sanding to a fairly high grit range with even grit consistency such as 800-1000 grit. The issue with paper backing is when the paper backing begins to wear it begins to tear. When the disc begins to tear the abrasive begins to separate from the disc and you have a break down in the disc itself.

Cloth backing offers a more durable backing not tearing up quite as easily. However, because of the crisscross mesh in the cloth backing you will find that you are not able to find cloth backed abrasives in the higher grits. Generally you can find cloth backed products up to only grit 220. Cloth backing tends to last longer than paper backing but you sacrifice then grit range you had with the paper backing. Make Sense?

Then we have film! Film is a fairly new process that has been introduced to the abrasive market. Mylar Film offers a number of advantages:

1. Film tends not to tear! Because the backing is film is does not tear like paper you will get a longer life from a film disc over a paper or even a cloth backed disc.

2. Film backed discs tend to be more flexible and hold a shape better then paper or cloth backed discs. So for coves and other shapes this can be very useful.

3. While there is not much talk these days of people wet sanding film backed discs allow you to wet sand your project if you care too. You can place these discs directly in water breakdown to the discs.

4. Film backed discs when manufactured correctly offer a superior grit consistency allow you to sand to a very high grit range. Understand this� abrasive used to be applied to the backing simply by gravity. Manufactures would simply dump abrasive grit on the backing as it rolled underneath it. The focus was trying to control grit particle size. However with the introduction of technology to the industry most quality products are no longer use simple gravity dumping techniques but rather a process involving electro statically charging the abrasive backing so as the grit is applied to the surface the abrasive grits stand straight up. Imagine footballs all standing on their ends standing straight up.

Before using the gravity system there was less control and the grits fell and lay where they will. You did not get a tight grit pattern lay out. Remember the idea of taking your disc and running it over an edge to knock off the high edges??? No more! Quality manufacturing allows for this process to be controlled and the user benefits by having even grit consistency and a tighter grit pattern lay out. As a result with my Blue Flex discs the range of grits I offer are: 80,120,150,180,220,280,320,400,600,800,1200,1500,and 2000!

Hopefully that clears up some abrasive questions but contact me if you have more questions.

Adhesion process is a topic I save for another time.

While I am here let me take a moment or two to touch on postings I have recently read. When I first introduced myself to this market I brought with me products that most everyone had not seen or heard of. Specifically a back up pad that offered Micro Hook rather then J hook Velcro as we as turners had been using. My SIA Soft products are great for spindle work is another example. These products are not proprietary but rather unique. I offered my inner face pads that are unique as well as a product I labeled Blue Flex discs and the response was more than well received! I brought and have the ability to create, laser cut, any disc any shape and size I wish. Because of this I am not someone who is just buying and reselling products at a higher cost. I am able to make and cut unique products that nobody else offers. I have respected others in this market by not offering products that others offer such as 3M and Norton products. I did not dip into there product line and try to undercut them. I respected them but unfortunately they have not extended that same respect to me.

Recently, others have begun offering the products that I first introduced to this market. They have lifted my product name Blue Flex and labeled these blue discs as �Inexpensive� and �Economy Line�. A recent posting states these discs are a �Korean Import with a primary use to be in the automotive market.� What I derive from reading this post is these discs are an inferior product with poor quality because they are�..Korean made and the design is not to be used in the woodturning market!

Well guess what� many of the discs we use today in woodturning are designed for other applications. Simply put manufactures are generally trying to get the highest yield out of their manufacturing process and it only makes sense!!!

Here is a quote from 3M site:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

3M� Microfinishing Film PSA 268L Disc

Fast cutting abrasive for precise, uniform, close-tolerance finish. High-strength. For metal, plastic, paint spot repair, automotive power train components, roll superfinishing.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I do NOT see any reference to wood, woodworking, or woodturning. I DO see reference to the automotive market just as another quality abrasive product has been referenced to the automotive market in a previous post. Because these products do not list wood, woodworking, or woodturning in their application listing are they not fit for a wood turner�s application� not necessarily? It simply was not recognized in the application listing. As wood turners we are always trying and creating new things to find something that works for our applications.

I have yet to find one product or one manufacture stating that their one product can only be used for the wood market and never have I seen an abrasive product stating it is specifically/only for the woodturning market. This is a niche market and manufactures want to maximize their production efforts. To make statements like what has been stated in previous thread �primary use to be in the automotive market� inferring the blue discs I originally introduced to this market are a wrong discs, incorrect disc, economy discs or whatever bull one wishes to label it with� is to try to plant seeds to say these discs less then what is needed. Well here is a thought� if these discs are �Inexpensive� being offered as �Economy Line� Imported discs not even designed for this market but rather for the automotive market� then why would the individual who has made these statements offer them to one�s customers? It is obvious after making such statements that one does not believe or stand behind this product but yet are will to sell it directly to their customers because why� a convenience? I believe people can see this for exactly what it is! The only thing that is �economy line� is the inference in the posting these statements were made trying to lead one to believe these discs are of poor quality and not long lasting and simply put it is a bunch of crap!!!

The good news is the merits of all my product speaks for themselves including my Blue Flex discs as people from around the world have used these discs along with my sanding system and my other quality products and have found their sanding process has improved and continue to use my discs and products! In addition, I introduced my new GOLD LINE discs at the AAW Symposium. These discs offer the same great grit consistency, superior bonding adhesive, as my blue discs only with a paper backing. The grit range is 60,80,100,120,150,180,220,280,320,400,600,800 I am offering a promotional 25 PK bag of each grit list (12 Bags Total) for $42.00 including S&H just for reading this post and as always your satisfaction is guaranteed!!! You try my product� you be the judge!!! When you go to my site www.VincesWoodNWonders.com you read my mission statement list on the very front page of my website which states clearly my focus is offering superior customer service, personalized education, quality sanding abrasives and accessories to not only meet but exceed your sanding abrasives needs! Then go to other sites and see if they even offer a mission statement stating what there purpose is.

I offer free samples to anyone wishing to try most any of my products with a satisfaction guarantee by simply calling me toll free at 1-877-284-8969.

In conclusion, stepping back and looking at the big picture what one needs to realize is chances are nobody offering products to this niche market whether it is: Tools, Lathes, Sanding Abrasive or whatever is going to find their picture on the cover of a Fortune 500 magazine. Lifting someone�s product name, offering someone else�s product that they have originally introduced to the market then trying to undercut them by .50 cents or a dollar here or there� I mean to say pull your head out man!!! People need to be respectful of others and play nice! GET OVER IT! There is no Godly reason why people offering products to this market should not and can not work together to offer the very best of everything to the customers they serve!

Vince

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

#2

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I use Vince's products and have always been more than pleased with the results. Thanks for the information Vince.

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

#3

Vince's sanding disks, mandrels, ...

Ed Moore of SW VA

>and service have always been exceptional.

Thanks for shedding some light on the sanding disk arena.

Ed

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

#4

Ditto what the other 2 have said. ...

john lucas

>I do purchase special products from the other abrasive dealers but I'm very happy with Vince's interface pads and his Blue discs.

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

#5

Dick Hines

Re: Ditto what the other 2 have said. ...

Dick Hines

>Add me to the list with Barbara, Ed and John. I have been useing it for a couple of years and love it.

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

#6

Re: Ditto what the other 2 have said. ...

Donna Banfield

>Vince's abrasives, sanding mandrels and innerface pads are the ONLY ones that I use on my woodturnings. Everything he sells is good quality for a reasonable price.

I've done the cheap sandpaper route, and found out the hard way that you "get what you pay for." Before I tried Vince's blue ceramic discs, I was spending 3-4 times longer sanding compared to the amount of time I spent finish turning, and still had poor results. (Don't get me wrong -- I'll spend extra time sanding a piece, but I expect my time to result in a superior finish). I was absolutely frustrated! I had purchased some micro-hook sanding mandrels from Vince a couple of months earlier, and Vince (just like he says) had thrown in a few of his blue ceramic discs. I grabbed one, stuck it on the mandrel, and started re-sanding the turning. When I was done, I had a surface without scratches.

But the true test was when the finish was applied -- you all know what I'm talking about -- those scratches that somehow were invisible before, show up like graffiti on the highway overpass after a coat of finish! ARRGH!! Not with Vince's discs -- Vince's discs left none. I tossed the rest of my old sandpaper, and called Vince the next day. Had my new blue ceramic abrasive 2 days later, and have been thrilled ever since.

By the way, he has a new 1" mandrell and 1" blue ceramic discs; if you turn open-vessels that narrow down to a V-shape at the interior bottom, these are great for being able to power sand those smaller areas.

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

#7

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

robo hippy

>It was after the Louisville Symposium (was that 4 years ago?) and a bunch of people were raving about his discs. Well, I needes some more discs, and got some. Best stuff I have used. About the only thing that might compare are the purple ceramic discs from 3M, but they are only available in PSA, and grits up to 220. I did try a 5 inch one on some flat work, and it did work really well. However, I want hook and loop, and higher grits. The firm interface pad from Vince that has the rounded edge is excellent for bowls, far better than the ones that have the square edge. Really has saved me a lot of time sanding.

robo hippy

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

#8

Re: What makes quality

Frank C Joseph

>Vince:

After reading your posting I was impressed.. and you have a new customer. order will be placed Monday

Just the fact that Ellis has allowed you to make this posting says a lot about you and the way you conduct your business.

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

#9

Changed the way I sand !

Don Orr

>I use Vince's system and love it. The system makes the difference-mandrels, interface pads, discs and process all taken together is what makes it work and work very well.

I met Vince at the Derry, NH symposium.

Great guy, great system-nuff said,

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

#10

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I believe it was 4 years ago at Indyfest that I first met Vince and bought a trial pack of his Blue Flex disks. I've been using them ever since and only use them for powersanding. I also bought the same abrasive in 1" strips that I use for sanding pens.

I doubt there is a better abrasive out there. Some might be close or comparible, but not better.

keithz

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

#11

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

Jimmy Tolly

>I was among the first to use Vince's Blue Flex and was pleased enough to help introudece them to our CTWA club. I have never heard a bad word about them!

Keep doing what is RIGHT Vince.

Jimmy

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long

#12

Re: What makes a quality abrasive? Long------WebKi

Mike from St. Clair Shores------WebKitFormBoundary

>I really liked Vince's explanation and description of sanding discs. I feel even more confidant now that the choice I made 4 years ago to use Vince's blue ceramic discs was a good one. He is an honest, hard working individual who runs a great business. Not using his sanding discs yet? You are missing out, I love going thru the grits with my Grex random orbit sander.

Thanks again Vince,

MIke

------WebKitFormBoundaryv5n0o5+uzjfzQiAR