Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

Posts

Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#1

Rob Wallace

Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

Rob Wallace

>I was recently asked by a fairly new woodturner what the most common number of segments is per ring in the majority of segmented woodturnings. Since I have only done a few segmented turnings (probably less than 10), I told the guy that I'm not the person to ask, but would get some information on this, since I actually would like to know this too. For the few segmented pieces I've done, I just used my Incra miter gauge and measured segment lengths; pretty easy, but time consuming. I suppose I should build a sled too...(?)

For those "seggie" regulars, I'd like to know what you think the most common number of segments per ring is on the majority of segmented pieces. I assume this to be something like 10, 12, 16, or 18; whatever number that results from an easily obtained cutting angle.

The question came about because he wants to first build one cutting sled to get started, and wanted to know what the best 'bang for the buck' would be regarding building the sled to cut "X" segments per ring.

Does anyone have any advice on this?

Thanks,

Rob Wallace

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#2

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turning

Stuart Johnson

>I usually use 12. No reason other than that is what I first started using. I use a JoinTech Smart Miter.

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#3

JL

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turning

JL

>I don't do much segmented turning. I do make furniture pieces and frames for mirrors and pictures.

IMO - the easiest is to get easily repeated angles or angle halves. Such as 12 segments - 30 degree angle, 15 degree angle half; 15 segments - 24 degrees, 12 degree angle half; 18 segments - 20 degree angle, 10 degree angle half and 20 segments - 18 degree angle, 9 degree angle half.

That way you don't have to worry about 0.5 degree increments. Of course my segments are usually larger.

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#4

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turning

Russ Fairfield

>I use 12, unless the design dictates another number. The pieces are a reasonable size, there is less waste in making a full circle, and multiples of 15-degrees are easy to use and calculate.

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#5

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turning

john lucas

>I would say the most common for new turners is 8. 12 and 16 and 24 are also pretty common. I use either 8 or 36 on my mirror rings depending on how I want them to look.

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#6

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turning

gary clarke

>I usually use 12 for bowls, however I just finished a baseball bat that has 62 rings and used 8 seg for that, less cutting and quicker to glue together. I have one sled and I use sub sleds for each angle that I want to use (8,12,16,24). I bolt the sub sleds to the main sled. Takes a while to get the sub sleds made but now that they are finished it only takes a couple of minutes to change sleds.

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#7

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turning

Carl Barton

>Rob,

While I have done only about 30 segmented turnings and I am new at it, I find that I use 12 or 16 segments per ring. No real reason other than most of my jigs are set up for these numbers. I guess once you get used to doing something one way you keep with it.

My first couple of segmented turnings I did do 32 segments, but I found out for me that was way too many for what I was doing.

Carl

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#8

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turning

Curly Smith

>I think he'd be better off starting with either 6 or 8 segments (or maybe even 4). Later, when he gets some experience in cutting, aligning, and everything else associated with putting the rings together he can move to more segments if he wants. If he starts with a higher number of segments, simply because it's the "most common", he might get too frustrated to turn the second vessel.

It also depends on how big he wants to make his vessels. Here's a pdf Segment Size for various ring sizes that gives segment length for various ring sizes by number of segments. As an example, for a 3" ring and 6 segments you'd have 1.73" segments but for 12 segments then length would be 0.80". If you're doing something new then it seems to me that bigger pieces are easier to deal with than smaller pieces.

There are also many spreadsheets available that have the same info as the pdf. This excel file is one: Compound Miter Angle Calculator

I don't think it's a good idea to get bogged down in the tedium of building the vessel before you experience the joy of actually turning one.

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#9

Steve Kubien

Baseball bat?

Steve Kubien

>Gary, there have been a lot more bats broken in the past couple of years in MLB. Many folks say it is because of the use of maple bats. Could it be simply that you are using the wrong glue? :)

Seriously, have you got a picture you care to share with us? Sounds neat.

Steve

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#10

Re: Baseball bat?

gary clarke

>Steve, I just finished it today and I need a couple of more coats of poly on the ends and when the finish is dry I will post a picture. Our club is making bats and balls for the yearly picnic and it will be interesting to see all the different types of bats and balls we come up with.

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#11

It depends

mfoster

>I find it depends on several factors including what the intended esthetic result is to be, features of the piece, How precise your jigs are, how fast you can glue up multiple segments, and how big the piece is to be. I rarely use 8, sometimes 12, more often 16,18 or 24, and occasionally 32. I have also done pieces with 10, 20 and 40 segments. As others have stated, there are software programs for this (but not for Macs ): ). I just do a design and do the math using a spreadsheet I create for each piece. Not much help, but it's my way of doing it.

Mike

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#12

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turning

Texian

>As mf said, it depends, mostly on the size of the work (for me). Tiny segments can be difficult to handle and potentially hazardous to cut. For small stuff (2" diameter) I use 12 per ring. Everything else gets 16. Have done some with 24, which might be better for a large piece. For a beginner, start with 8, then 12 on the second piece and see how it goes.

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#13

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turning

john lucas

>One thing I suggest is doing your first rings in even number of sides that can be divided by 2 or 4. Ideally you want to be able to cut perfect pieces and joint the ring with one glue up. I could never do that at first. It was probably a lot of factors, saw, blade, feeding pressure, slop in miter gauge, etc.

By using even numbers I could glue up rings that didn't fit in sections. For example with 8 sides I would glue up the ring in halfs. Then I would have 180 degrees so I could flatten these with sandpaper on a flat surface and then glue the whole ring up.

If your way off glue them up in quarters and check for 90 degrees and true up the 1/4 sections.

Sounds extreme but using these methods I have made segmented rings with as many as 36 sides with a handsaw and a homemade miter box.

Re: Most common segment number per ring in turnings?

#14

Rob Wallace

THANKS EVERYONE!

Rob Wallace

>I have cut and pasted the contents of the entire thread into a document and have printed it to give my friend (he does not do computers or Internet). I'll see how much I can move him along. I'll also loan him my Malcolm Tibbets book on segmented turning.

Thanks for all of the advice! It looks like 12 and 16 are popular numbers, along with "8". We'll see how he does getting started!

Thanks also for taking the time to reply - very much appreciated!

Rob Wallace