Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?
Doc Green
>I believe I recognize an unstable situation associated with a sharpening jig that could possibly be dangerous. The type of jig I'm thinking about is that where the end of the handle is placed in a seat and the metal tool then is laid over against the stone.
Here's the instability: The wheel tends to push the handle toward the seat, and if the bevel being ground is rather steep, the wheel will tend to pull the tool downward at the same time. The more it pulls downward, the more force is applied to the tool and the seat, and the more the downward pull becomes, and so on and on.
If the seat happens to slip back, the forces will multiply quickly and the end of the tool could be pulled all the way past the midpoint of the wheel, in which case, it would be flung out the bottom.
What brings this to mind is a photo in the current issue of "Woodturning Design." On page 76, Figure 7, a tool with a large bevel is being sharpened at an angle that puts the point of contact very low on the wheel. That scares the heck out of me!
The following photo, Figure 8, shows the tool badly burned, in my opinion. This indicates that large forces were in effect, which scares me even more.
I have no quarrel with the article. The author surely has forgotten more about turning and making tools and stuff than I'll ever know.
So the point of this is to ask a question: Has anyone ever had a mishap with such a sharpening jig, where the tool "grabbed the wheel" and was pulled sharply downward?
Perhaps I sits and worries too much. Maybe I should just sits.
~Doc PS: I don't use a jig because I'm afraid of them.



