Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

Posts

Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#1

Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

Doc Green

>I believe I recognize an unstable situation associated with a sharpening jig that could possibly be dangerous. The type of jig I'm thinking about is that where the end of the handle is placed in a seat and the metal tool then is laid over against the stone.

Here's the instability: The wheel tends to push the handle toward the seat, and if the bevel being ground is rather steep, the wheel will tend to pull the tool downward at the same time. The more it pulls downward, the more force is applied to the tool and the seat, and the more the downward pull becomes, and so on and on.

If the seat happens to slip back, the forces will multiply quickly and the end of the tool could be pulled all the way past the midpoint of the wheel, in which case, it would be flung out the bottom.

What brings this to mind is a photo in the current issue of "Woodturning Design." On page 76, Figure 7, a tool with a large bevel is being sharpened at an angle that puts the point of contact very low on the wheel. That scares the heck out of me!

The following photo, Figure 8, shows the tool badly burned, in my opinion. This indicates that large forces were in effect, which scares me even more.

I have no quarrel with the article. The author surely has forgotten more about turning and making tools and stuff than I'll ever know.

So the point of this is to ask a question: Has anyone ever had a mishap with such a sharpening jig, where the tool "grabbed the wheel" and was pulled sharply downward?

Perhaps I sits and worries too much. Maybe I should just sits.

~Doc PS: I don't use a jig because I'm afraid of them.

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#2

JL

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

JL

>I have a Wolverine with a Vari-Grind jig (and I use it). I am always fairly careful with locking the arm (and the seat) down pretty tightly. I am also careful about the positioning of the arm and seat.

The only times when I have a really "steep" angle are for my scrapers. I don't use the arm for sharpening those, I use the rest and I press the tool against the rest.

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#3

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

john lucas

>Doc The one downside to sharpening jigs is that it opens up the possibility for abuse or missuse. I use as an example, one time I was sharpening using just the V arm, probably a rough out gouge because that's just about the only time I do that. I had extended the arm and forgot to lock the arm. Fortunately I realized it before anything serious happened. I use very light pressure to sharpen and almost instantly realized that the arm was loose and slipping. It could have been pretty serious.

I often see beginners using a lot of force when grinding. This isn't necessary and opens the opportunity for things to go wrong.

You stated quite well the fact that you should be sharpening above the center of the wheel. I have read of accidents happening when people sharpen too low and it pulls the tool through the wheel and destroys the wheel, bends the tool or damages the jig.

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#4

Don't Do This!

David Belser

>I had a tool "snap" through because I was too low on the wheel and using the 'V' rest jig. I don't remember what I was trying to sharpen but I should have been using the flat rest instead.

It made a hell of a noise and scared the crap out of me. I didn't trust the wheel after that and replaced it. Fortunately it was small (6") low speed grinder and there was enough give in the mounting that it didn't turn out worse.

This should probably go into the the list of "NEVER DO THIS" along with using a roughing gouge on a bowl.

I wasn't using a lot of force to grind, just way too low on the wheel to use a jig that captured the tool.

- Dave

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#5

Re: Don't Do This! - Buffing Corallary

charlie belden

>The corallary to Stay Above Centerline When Grinding is Stay Below Centerline When Buffing/Polishing. A "catch above centerline when buffing can hurl the piece INTO YOU. Below centerline, a catch when buffing, will hurl the piece DOWN & AWAY FROM YOU.

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#6

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

Scott in Falcon

>Been there, done that...

A few years ago I had my Wolverine grinding jig set up with a 6" grinder. Was just using the V arm and sharpening a roughing gouge. No serious damage done (there was nothing under the wheel to hit, or it could have been much worse), but scared me half to death. From that point on my roughing gouges get sharpened by hand with the flat rest.

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#7

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

Jeff Willaford

>I sharpen my roughing gouge on the table and scrapers upside down on the table. Something Dick Hines showed me. The only thing I sharpen using the vee arm also uses the varigrind. Always a light touch regardless of tool or method.

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#8

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

john lucas

>A lot of newer roughing gouges come sharpened too blunt, I think. When you try to sharpen a roughing gouge that has an bevel angle of 50 to 70 degrees in the Wolverine jig the tool is too close to the center line and dangerous to sharpen.

My rough out gouges have a much more acute sharpening angle of about 35 to 45 degrees. This means they sharpen much higher on the stone.

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#9

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

Donna Banfield

>Like John suggested, a downside to using jigs is the tendency to relax, or 'let your guard down'.

I use the Wolverine jig to sharpen my spingle and detail gouges. I've found that the 'grit' that comes off the grinder/tool steel, and the abrasives off the wheel when I dress it, can collect in the smallest of places. One of those places is the arm/handle that tightens the V-arm; you apply pressure to tighten it, and it feels tight. But it's really not - the arm/handle simply found some of that debris. As soon as you begin sharpening, the slightest vibration will free up that debris, and 'WHAM', the V-arm slides out because of the downward and forward pressure of the tool.

The other area that can be problematic, is the thin slip of metal inside of the jig on your tool. That flexible slip of metal that the brass knob screws down onto, becomes slick with use. The pressure of the tool on the grinding wheel can push the tool nose and allow the jig to slide forward. If you ever discover that your bevel on your gouge is starting to look like the bevel on one of your scrapers, (i.e., a blunt bevel, instead of the 60-65 degrees), it's a safe bet that your tool slipped in the jig a few times, and you didn't even know it.

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#10

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

Rick Allen

>Curious that you said "don't let your guard down". There are effective and easy to use sharpening jigs which move away from danger when you "let your guard down". Perhaps that should be a design goal for the makers of sharpening jigs. If you let go of the tool the tool will fall away from the spinning griding wheel and hopefully be contained in a neutral position.

The tool rests, which are so common on grinders, provide that level of safety. If you let go of the tool on the grinder tool rest the most likely action is that the tool falls away from the grinder.

While it is always good and prudent to be "in the moment" when working with sharp tools and powered equipment the jigs used with those tools should not only increase the efficiency of using the equipment but also make the operation safer.

So what fingernail grinding jig is safe to use when you let go of the tool? The old Sorby fingernail grinding jig (based on the Tormek fingernail grinding jig). I have heard that the new Oneway fingernail grinding jig is safer to use.

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#11

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

john lucas

>When you let go of the Oneway Wolverine it will fall away from the wheel unless you are just sharpening the blade with no handle. Even then it might. The new oneway is only safer because it forces you to stay in the middle of the wheel so you can't drop off the right or left side. I prefer to grind on all parts of the wheel to keep it flat so that won't work for me.

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#12

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>Right on, John. I sharpen my roughing gouges to 35 degrees. And I do not EVER use the vee-arm. I install the table on the Wolverine and hold the gouge flat against it. I do prefer the new fingernail jig precisely because the tool cannot fall off the grinding wheel. I did thattoo often for ml own liking -- especially after the day the jig fell off the wheel and the gouge toom my finger with it -- taking off all one fingernail.

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#13

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

Carole Valentine

>Yep. I had it happen with a new roughing gouge shortly after I started turning. Probably was my fault because as a newbie I had never really thought about the correlation between safety and how high or low the tool was on the wheel. Boy did I learn fast!!! Scared the hell out me and took a chip out of the wheel (which I replaced)

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#14

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Don't Do This! - Buffing Corallary

Jesper, Denmark

>In a buffing set-up, it is both easier to use and safer to reverse the rotation of the wheels to the opposite direction than a grinding wheel.

On a single phase motor, you just turn the motor around, so you stand "behind" instead of in front. On my buffer, I was able to just take the motor off the base and reverse tha base, so the switch is still in front.

Any guards can usually be unscrewed and turned in 90� increments to fit the new situation.

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

#15

Re: Sharpening jig instability ? ? ?

Bob Lalonde

>WOW!! I felt really stupid when this actually happened to me earlier this week. I should have had the tool on the platform but because of laziness, I had it in the arm of the jig. This gouge has a fifty degree angle on a short 1/8 inch bevel and is not at all swept back - a perfect candidate. It was too low on the wheel and sure enough: Bang! The tool was forced down to the base with my finger under it and made a big hurt. In addition, it cracked the stone and a small shard hit my forehead just above my safety glasses. My finger has finally stopped bleeding (I take a baby aspirin every day and tend to bleed longer) but it has a big gash in it and is swollen at the middle joint. You can't see the cut on my head anymore. I don't usually post but this is an important topic and I say don't ever do it. I got off lucky but I am pretty sure it was life number eight. Bob.