Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

I know I can do better

Posts

I know I can do better

#1

I know I can do better

Stuart Johnson

>The "when to start selling" thread got me to thinking about my turnings. Other than a few pens, rug hooks, seam rippers and presses I have not sold anything. I have turned some boxes and bowls for others and have asked that a donation to the Susan G. Komen fund be made as payment.

I think my biggest problem is I know I can do better. I don't think I have every given someone a gift that I haven't thought about tossing because of some flaw I could see after it was complete and ready to go. In every case the recipient has raved about the item and has placed it in prominent place. Now this makes me feel good but I do know the quality of my work and while it isn't junk it could be better. My next step is to start keeping everything for at least six months. After that length of time if I think it is still acceptable then it can go into the gift stack. If not, well I can always use wood for the smoker.

Re: I know I can do better

#2

How can I do better?

Ed Moore of SW VA

>Stuart,

You made it clear that while you are pleased with some of your work you see room for improvement. Have you analyzed what you don't like about some of your work? What phase of your work don't you like? Please understand that my response is generic and is in no way directed to your specific work.

In order to make the leap to the next level you need to know how your work differs from that next level and figure out what you need to do to improve.

1. Design. If you aren't pleased with the design of your pieces then I suggest that you take a course with an established turner and work on improving the design aspects of what you are doing. I took a week with Ray Key at Arrowmont in 2000 and my work improved as a result. If for some reason a course at Arrowmont, John C Campbell Folk School, Marc Adams, or other good craft schools is not feasible, then find someone who knows design and ask them to give you a no holds barred critique of your work. Tell them to be brutal if necessary. Don't argue with them, just soak up what they tell you and ponder it for a week or two.

2. Sanding. If you can see sanding or tool marks on your work, then you need to understand that a potential buyer can also see them and they will be turned off. Recently a gallery owner was asked why my pieces were more expensive than those of turner B. The owner asked them to pick up the bowl made by turner B and feel it. Then they said to pick up my bowl and do the same thing. The owner told me later that you could see the light bulb go on and that the buyer understood when he told them that I spend more time on finishing than turner B and consequently charge more. Mark Kauder is an accomplished segmented turner who says "I love to sand. It makes me money." He puts exquisite finishes on his turnings and they sell accordingly.

3. Knuckles. If you don't understand this term, then you need to learn about it. A curve should be continuous and should not look like two curves that have been joined. Such a join is a "knuckle". If you are mathematically inclined, the derivative of the curve should also be continuous. At the Yankee Symposium a couple of years ago Michael Hosaluk and Jimmy Clewes were critiquing the Instant Gallery. To my surprise, when Michael reached the table where my zebrawood platter was located he picked it up and started looking at the profile of the top and running his fingers over it. I assume that he was looking for a knuckle or dip, but when he didn't find any he started to make very positive comments about that profile. I was rewarded for the time I spent "getting it right".

Critique your own work and don't be afraid to have another turner critique it. It's the only way that you will grow. If you don't make constructive changes, then your work will remain the same and you won't reach that next level.

Ed

Re: I know I can do better

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: I know I can do better *LINK*

Rob Wallace

>Well said Ed!!

Stuart, if you can ever get the chance to see the demonstration on "design" done by Keith Tompkins, this would also add to your knowledge base regarding critiquing your own work, and understanding some basic underlying principles of proportion and form. I was Keith's demo assistant a few years ago at one of the AAW Symposia, and his talk is one of the most applicable demonstrations in helping me achieve that "next step" that I've yet to experience. Although I'm not sure if I'm 'there' yet, I do now routinely pay attention to subtle yet important details about proportion, form, and finish that Keith first made me aware of, and that I have subsequently done more reading about.

The link below is Keith's handout that is posted to the AAW 'Resources' page - give it a read and think about how your work relates to some of the basic design elements he discusses, and also consider the "fairness' of your curves (...that is, the curves on your turned work; your personal curves may be of no interest!) and the lack of "visible [hard] transitions" in the piece's curves (the 'knuckles' that Ed talks about). Take the time to refine your piece's proportions (including the size of the foot/base relative to the piece in general) as well as making sure the curves are faired, and that the finish is done well, both in sanding and in final finishing, and your pieces will improve dramatically. It worked for me (...at least I think it did!) and for other turners I know who really thought about what they were doing beyond the actual turning of the work.

Good luck!

Rob Wallace


Keith Tompkins - Woodturning Form and Design - AAW

Re: I know I can do better

#4

Amen Ed!

Molly Winton

>Especially about the willingness to take a critique. Ask for one from someone you respect and you admire their work. It doesn't have to be someone that does the same work as you do, just someone you believe has the skills and knowledge you admire. Then LISTEN. Don't be afraid to hear critical remarks. Realize they are meant to get you thinking, and are not an attack on your identity or ego. Analyze what you've heard. Use what you hear that has value to you, and discard what you believe does not apply.

Be flexible.

Listen!

Don't dismiss anything without indepth thought.

Check your ego at the door.

Apply suggestions on your next project and compare the results to the first one.

Ask someone to critique that doesn't have an emotional investment in you (i.e. skip the spouse, Mom, your children, and siblings).

Re: I know I can do better

#5

ask a non woodturner artist for a critique

john lucas

>I am lucky enough to belong to the local branch of the furniture society. I also have several artist friends here on campus who paint or do glass, ceramics, etc. They will give you an honest critique on the object itself. not how hard it was to do or how pretty the wood it. They look at the overall impression it leaves on the senses. This is really helpful.

One thing I've noticed when going the national symposium is the extra little something that the top turners do that seperates them from the average good turner. It's a hard thing to explain because it's a little bit of everything, form, finish, wood selection,and theme. I told myself that I have to figure out how to get to that next level and I think it's paying attention to the slightest detail.

Re: I know I can do better

#6

Better Than What?

charlie belden

>Have you tried to focus on WHAT you feel needs to be better?

Is it the form / shape that needs to be better?

Is it the wood selection for a given piece that needs to be better?

Is it the gouge/chisel work that needs to be better?

Is it the sanding that needs to be better?

Is it the finish selection and/or application that needs to be better?

Is it the presentation of the finished piece that needs to be better?

It can be pretty overwhelming to look at a finished piece and try to see ALL that might be done to make it better. But if you focus on one thing at a time - and figure out what specifically could've been done better, then work on THAT with the next piece . . .

If you want to learn to juggle, don't start with a dozen balls.

Re: I know I can do better

#7

Excellent Advice

Texian

>You have received excellent advice. One more simple detail. Try harder. That's it, try harder. You must have the will to do the extra work required to achieve the better result. You know you can do better if you try harder.

Re: I know I can do better

#8

More generic advice

Ed Moore in SW VA

>Stuart,

We have all addressed the final product, but there is another aspect to consider. It is capsuled in this question: How do I make that cut?

When I do a personal evaluation of a demonstrator I am very conscious of whether they always show the audience how they are presenting the tool to the wood. That is what a newbie needs to know.

Consider two students who came to my shop for help turning a bowl. Each was instructed to use the 45 - 45 - 45 approach to the outside cuts. I demonstrated the cut and then adjusted the tool for Student A and he began the cut. Within two seconds he had rotated the tool 30 or 40 degrees and soon had a catch. This was repeated several times. Nothing I said penetrated. He told a colleague that I was an awful teacher and that he was going to look elsewhere.

Student B was a surgeon and was very bright. I demonstrated the cut and handed him the bowl gouge. He did exactly what I asked. After he had shaped the bowl we learned the shear scrape and that was done very well. Inside the bowl he recognized when using a traditional bowl grind might be necessary. We transitioned to that tool and he continued. I realized after he left happily with a completed sanded bowl that he had not had a significant catch at any time.

As I am sure that you realize, there are those who know how to make the cuts and there are those who poke the tool in and hope for the best. To improve your turning, learn how to make the cuts.

Bill Grumbine's DVDs show how to make the cuts. Jimmy Clewes has a series of DVDs and I strongly recommend the single and the first two trilogies, especially the second set. I personally benefitted greatly from them.

My personal recommendation for improving is this: Learn how to turn delicate finials and icicles. I am talking about Cindy Drozda style finials and Bob Rosand style icicles. I think that Bob teaches these skills better than anyone else. He is to teach at Arrowmont in October - take his course if it is feasible.

The reason for my recommendation is that if you learn to turn a good icicle then you have learned tool control and how to make a cut. These skills will translate to other areas of woodturning very nicely. My point is that if you learn to make the icicles, then your bowl-turning will also improve. IMHO.

Charlie's point about not tossing too many balls in the air is an excellent one. And I think that starting here is a good idea.

Ed

Re: I know I can do better

#9

Re: I know I can do better..thanks all

Stuart Johnson

>Thanks to all that responded. I don't have any problem with critiques and hope to continue improving. Form, cutting, finish and in most of my pieces tight joints all go into the final piece. Miss any one by just a bit and the end product just isn't what I want. I just finished a segmented HF with a pleasing form, good finish (not compared to Mark's)and nice tight joints. Once again I learned or relearned a lesson about tight joints not being enough. When I was cleaning up the final ring I was a little aggressive with the sander and burned two segments. They fit together nice and tight and without thinking about the burn I glued them together. The Maple ring was added and turned with a dark seam from the burn. I was out of time and had to go ahead with a gift that I will always know has a flaw. This is what I mean by I know I can do better.

My biggest mistake was not starting the project early enough. This caused me to rush and make a mistake. Once the mistake was made I didn't have time to correct it.

Re: I know I can do better

#10

Steven Antonucci

First step is admitting you have a problem

steve antonucci

>If you are aware that you have the problem, everything after that is simple. Most people don't know that they have the problems...

11 steps to go...

Steve

Re: I know I can do better

#11

Re: More generic advice

charlie belden

>Ed suggested doing delicate finials and icicles to learn how to make various cuts and tool control. I think a lot of turners jump from turning pens to turning bowls - and skip over that part of the learning curve which deals with how to make the basic cuts - and do them crisply and cleanly. It's far less traumatic when you get a catch on something that's under one inch in diameter than it is when you get a catch on something that's 4 to 12" in diameter. The causes will be the same - but the former size usually doesn't require a change of underwear ;)