Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

bowl disaster, could have been worse

Posts

bowl disaster, could have been worse

#1

bowl disaster, could have been worse

john lucas

>Well so much for trying to get rid of the tearout in this bowl. I was actually doing pretty well. I soaked the tearout prone area with thinned lacquer. Then used my sharpest gouge, a higher speed on the lathe and slow feeding to reduce it to a couple of small 1" or so patches. I soaked these with thin CA and still didn't get rid of every last one but had it down to sanding with 80 or 100 grit. Shear scraping on this one didn't improve the finish quality any over the sharp gouge and may have even added a little bit of tearout.

I worked on the inside and had still had the same 2 areas but is seemed a little less prone to tearout using the 40 degree gouge. I had thinned it all down to the last 4 inches when I heard a funny noise. I shut the lathe off immediately. The bowl had cracked almost 6 inches down the side right through the tearout prone area. Fortunately I wasn't running the lathe very fast. I opened the crack and poured thin CA in and then closed the crack.

I'm not going to sand waste time sanding this one. I'll just put it on the shelf and watch it for the next 2 or 3 years and see how the glue holds. I don't dare sell something like this. If the glue does hold up over time I might sand it down and keep it for myself.

Bummer. It started out as an 18" bowl and by the time I got rid of the bad areas it was down to 15 1/2 about 6" deep. It would have been a nice piece. Fortunately I cored out the inside so I will get another stab at turning a piece from this. Needless to say I will stay well out of the line of fire.

By the way Keith's Gage'T bowl measuring device works great. I've used it a lot lately and it's really fast. It easily measured to the bottom of this piece. It is 1/2" thick.


img

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#2

Dick Hines

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

Dick Hines

>Great bowl John. I hope it works out for you. PS my wife loves your dog.

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#3

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

Sean Troy

>I have always had good luck sanding problem areas out with citrus wax. When the paper loads up with a paste, start using a new piece until the tear out is gone. Smells good also while sanding. I sand at 200 rpm with the wax and don't be afraid of applying some pressue at first.

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#4

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

Bill Crommett

>Nice photo tent, John . Why did you use thin CA instead of medium or thick ?

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#5

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

john lucas

>The Thin penetrates better. I want to cut away the tearout and punky areas not fill them. To fix the crack I find thin better if the crack still has all of it's original parts and goes back together with no gap. If I think there is a gap at all I will use medium.

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#6

Her name is Lacey and she's my bud.

john lucas

>

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#7

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

john lucas

>Sean These areas were too deep and too soft. If you sanded them you would have a lump. I have used hard backed sandpaper to sand areas like that but in this case I thought I could just turn it away if I could stiffen up the fibers.

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#8

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

Sean Troy

>That is a soft wood. I have had some luck rubbing the area with Acetone to stand up the fibers without staining the wood.

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#9

Steve Kubien

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

Steve Kubien

>Yup, could have been worse. That's really too bad as it looks like it would've been a really nice piece. If the crack does open up, perhaps it will be a candidate for some stitching with biscuits or leather string or something like that?

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#10

butterfly patch

john lucas

>Steve I decided this afternoon that I would put a couple of butterfly patches in the crack. That would guarantee that it won't open and it will add some visual interest as well.

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#11

Re: butterfly patch

WayneLeach - NW Ont

>John,

The bowl sure looked like it would be a winner if it had not cracked.

How do you go about cutting into the bowl for the butterfly patch(s)? Do you outline using an exacto knife and then route using a dremel or something like it? Never tried anything like that.

I think that woulkd be a great way to save the bowl!

Good luck.

Wayne

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#12

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

Ken

>John,I keep looking at the pic an can't find anything wrong with it.Sorry,but it sure looks like a beautifull piece to me.Oh well beings its 11:45 and the painpills (hydrocodozone)are kickin in an my eyes ain't workin to good,so I'll take another look in the morn.

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#13

Re: butterfly patch

john lucas

>I'll have to figure out how to do it on a bowl. Probably as you described but cleaning up with a sharp chisel after the router. I want them to go all the way through. Since you can't see the crack right now they will look like a decoration but I may explain to the customer what happened. It will add a little story to go with the piece.

On flat work I simply build a butterfly jig, clamp it to the work and route it using a 1/8" bit and a special bushing for the router that has a 1/8" extra bushing on it. You remove the extra bushing and then route throught the same pattern to make your patch. They match perfectly.

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#14

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

john lucas

>Ken I was able to glue it back together with no visible line, or at least barely visible to me. Since I used thin CA I don't trust the joint. It was wet wood so I couldn't use yellow glue and in my experience polyeurethane will show as a dark line. CA will often close this type of crack (if you hold it together long enough) but CA does not have a good track record for longevity.

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#15

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

Don wilcut

>I'm glad you explained that, I was wondering about my eyes also.

Keep it with the coring system, you're getting good. Can't justify one for this household, yet.

Re: bowl disaster, could have been worse

#16

Re: butterfly patch

Keoni

>Here is a bowl that had a crack in it.I used the Pewa patch( thats what it is refered to in Hawaii). I used an Xacto knife to cut it in. You could also use a router with a template. There is a company that sell them in different sizes and a template to go with it.


img