Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

McNaughton coring system

Posts

McNaughton coring system

#1

McNaughton coring system

john lucas

>Well I've cored 14 bowls now. I have 2 or 3 problems. The most obvious is knowing how deep the cutting tip is. I guess the only way round that is either lots of experience of the lazar attachment. I got the parts I need for my lathe/mill so maybe I'll have time to build a nice lazar attachment.

The other problems are, I run into several times during the cut when the thing simply won't cut. You can't push the tool in any further and it simply won't cut. This often happens after I've pulled the tool out to clear the shavings. I think maybe a shaving is getting over the tip but I'm not sure. Usually I will clear it and push back in and maybe wiggle the tip and it starts again.

The other problem I'll take care of monday. The set screw that holds the two parts of the tool rest together won't stay in place. I'll just get one of the locking set screws and that should take care of the problem.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#3

Thanks paul- I'll read it in the morning

john lucas

>

Re: McNaughton coring system

#4

Re: Thanks paul- I'll read it in the morning

Texian

>The term laser is an acronym for light amplification by stimulated emission of radiation. Just a thought about spelling. How to tell an admired and respected turner, machinist, innovator, writer of excellent tutorials, and other things, that I wish he would just spell laser correctly. It is a small thing, but folks write endlessly about small differences in bowl gouge grinds, so maybe this is ok. Hope so.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#5

Re: McNaughton coring system

robo hippy

>You have to clear the cut a few times to get all the shavings out. One shaving over the tip will keep it from cutting and if you try to push through it, you can get a big catch.

I do like the laser, but some don't want to spend the money. Rather than a graph, I set the gates where I want them, and then hold the blade up over the top of the bowl in the exact place where I want it to be when I remove the perfect depth core.

robo hippy

Re: McNaughton coring system

#6

Thanks- too long a day and brain doesn't work

john lucas

>

Re: McNaughton coring system

#7

Re: McNaughton coring system

john lucas

>Robo to get the shapes I'm trying to do I seem to have to move the gate. So far except for one I'm cutting too shallow,which is better than getting funnels but of course it causes the next bowl to be smaller than you would really like. Thanks for your help. I have to do at least 2 more finished bowls in the next couple of days. After that I can just practice roughing and if I screw those up I won't be as upset.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#8

Re: McNaughton coring system

Greg Haugen

>John,

You can also widen the kerf a little just so the shavings have a little more room to get out-mainly at the start of the cut. Each time I would pull the knife out to clear shavings, I'd only pull it out once-if you need to pull it out several times per clearing you may not be clearing enough-try it more frequently. Also the inability to cut can also be that the knife is drifting or the curve isn't being followed and the knife is bottomed out on the inside or outside of the kerf. You mentioned you're moving the banjo-that will help, or a wider kerf will help to get a bottomed-out knife through the cut. Mahoney, in his DVD, talks about moving the banjo and a wider kerf at the entrance to help the tool perform better.

Good Luck and have fun.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#9

Re: McNaughton coring system

Jim Tusant

>Hey John, if you haven't done it yet, get Robo's DVD on coring. I did on the front-end of coring and it made my life a lot easier. Great material/tips and you can go back to it for help or refreshers.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#10

Re: McNaughton coring system

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Robo,

In the variety store in town, I can get a key chain with a laser on it for a whooping $0.99, it makes a crisp dot, with that and a coat hanger you can improvise an inexpensive laser rig.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#11

Re: McNaughton coring system

robo hippy

>The reason for moving the gate is that the blade tends to drift to the outside of the cut rather than following the perfect arc of the cut. This causes binding because the cut is a flatter arc/curve than the blade. Moving the gate helps. Opening up the cut some helps as well, some times on the outside, some times on the inside. I have one blade where I bent just the tip in slightly and it seems to work better than the other blades. The bends in the blades seem to be inconsistant. Figuring out how to counter the drift is the hardest part to figuring out this tool.

It wouldn't be hard to make your own laser pointer for the tool. I did hear that Randy of Monster tools made an adapter so that you can mount his pointer on the McNaughton. His is the best pointer I have seen. I took the McNaughton system and had the bracket welded to my handle. Much better than mounting it the way it comes (2 longer set screws for the blades, and nuts to hold the bracket on). It doesn't improve your aim, but it lets you know if you are off course.

I did develope the habit of aiming shallow to keep from going through the bottoms. Seems that I was either 1 inch too deep, or 1 inch too shallow.

robo hippy

Re: McNaughton coring system

#12

Dick Hines

Re: McNaughton coring system

Dick Hines

>John, if you get a chanceat a symposium check out Bill Grumbine. He is as good as they get with coreing system. The DVD by Mike Mahoney is good too.

Re: McNaughton coring system

#13

Steven Antonucci

She's a fickle mistress, no? :-)

steve antonucci

>There are times when I feel like I finally got it down, and other times when I feel like a complete moe...

The set screw thing in the gate really annoys me too, but I can't find my Loctite...

Steve

Re: McNaughton coring system

#14

Re: She's a fickle mistress, no? :-)

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Someone asked me about that set screw one time, and my response was, "What set screw?" I had actually forgotten there was one there! Mine just flops around loose, and I change the gate around between my Vega post and my Robust post that it would be a pain anyway.