Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

OT: laptop battery question

Posts

OT: laptop battery question

#1

Steve Kubien

OT: laptop battery question

Steve Kubien

>Howdy folks,

I had a minor technical issue with my laptop today. Called HP and sorted it all out, no problem. The tech noticed through the serial # that I still have about 8 months warranty. He hinted that the battery is the first thing to go and that to extend battery life, I ought to use the laptop without the power cord, just battery power and allow the battery to drain completely a few times per week. (WOW, that's a long sentence!)

Make any sense to you?

Steve

Re: OT: laptop battery question

#2

JL

Re: OT: laptop battery question

JL

>Yes. If you leave it plugged in all the time, it is not good for the battery. I've had several HP people tell me that (including my wife, who used to work for them).

Re: OT: laptop battery question

#3

Re: OT: laptop battery question

Ed Heuslein

>Woah! This is interesting. My understanding is that the old nickle-cadium batteries did retain a memory and had to be discharged/charged regularly. I just checked my Dell battery and it is Lithium-Ion which I understood did not have the memory problem and therefor did not need regular discharge/charge cycles. Any real-o-life experts out there know the answer?

Re: OT: laptop battery question

#4

Re: OT: laptop battery question

Scott Hurley in N VA

>I bought a laptop a few months ago, and that's what the salesman told me. He said that if you leave it plugged in with the battery in it, the battery gets overcharged and results in premature battery death. I use my laptop as a desktop replacement most of the time, so I pull the battery out when I'm plugged in to the wall power.

Scott

Re: OT: laptop battery question

#5

Steve Kubien

Re: OT: laptop battery question

Steve Kubien

>Thanks for the info/confirmation everyone. I appreciate it. Too bad when I am working cordless the screen isn't as bright as when I am plugged in (|I know that is wide open but please try to keep your smart-a**ed comments to yourselves!).

Cheers everyone,

Steve

Re: OT: laptop battery question

#6

From Battery University *LINK*

Bill Howatt

>This is one of the best sites on batteries, IMO.

Bill


Battery University

Re: OT: laptop battery question

#7

Nope

Tony - Memphis

>That pretty much goes against everything we have learned. We have oh, around 100,000 + Li batteries in our delivery force. Lithium likes to be be kept charged. We determined we could get around 30% longer life from a battery simply by charging them in our courier vehicles between stops. The biggest issue with Li cells is heat (and cold). Don't leave them in a warm place, especially a car. Ours are outdoors a lot and it hurts them. The cold issue is different. Li doesn't like to work in the cold, so your capacity will actually show lower when the cell gets cold. 400 charge cycles is about the average and that is about what we are getting. You can still milk them after that if you are patient, btu we can't afford to loose power midway through a shift. Witha laptop, heat is an issue, but I'm not sure if removing the battery will make that much difference in the overall life of the battery. Storing the cells at 40% and in the cold definitely helps. Storing them fully charged accelerates their march towards death! Anway, I HATE batteries!

Tony

Re: OT: laptop battery question

#8

Re: Nope

Bill Howatt

>I also hate batteries and if it wasn't for their great convenience, I wouldn't have a single one. Us older people can remember when the battery industry seemed to be a dead-end and then the portable electronics industry exploded into life!

I also don't see any reason to unplug a laptop battery when the charger is left plugged in since the charging circuit in the laptop seems quite clever and the charge current drops to a low value.

What concerns me is that the instructions that come with many laptops and other devices seem to have been written in the Ni-Cad days and have not been adjusted to reflect Li-ion batteries.

Bill

Re: OT: laptop battery question

#9

Re: Nope

Don Evans

>There is a lot of confusion with this issue.

The first post is general and is partly correct DEPENDING on whether you have NiCad or Lith battery.

Disregarding the post on use in vehicles (because that is not the environment that most use a laptop)and that environment and usage will affect ALL batteries Cads and Lith:

With NiCad's you'll get best use from them if you only drain them to 10 percent and then recharge. That is general no matter what they are used in. You should never drain them down too low as they will not fully charge up with just one charge and can reverse polarity but that was a bigger problem in the early years of their existance than in the latter due to improvements.

Lith is another story:

Lith's will tend to hold a charge for much longer but when they begin to show power loss they will dump much faster. Unlike NiCad's you can recharge Lith's when they have little power used up and not harm them.

No matter whether it is Cad or Lith there is only so many times it can be charged.

So, on Laptop use: it is best to remove Lith's when you are only using a power cord. Unlike Nicads they don't drain fast setting on the shelf. NiCads loss at least 1 percent per day just sitting idle. I've run test on my (Dell, it's Lith) and find that with it on the shelf, I only need to check it in the computer about every 6 months and recharge it.

So the answer depends on type of battery but with Liths you'll make it last much longer by keeping the cycles low by removing it an leaving it out as long as you are using AC power.

Just in case I didn't make it clear, if you leave it in the computer and are running it mostly with AC you are using up your recycle times rapidly.

Don

Re: OT: laptop battery question

#10

Steve Kubien

Hey everyone

Steve Kubien

>Thanks for all of the responses. I just checked and mine is a Lith-ion battery. I will take the advice offered here and remove it when it is charged and I am using AC power (which is most of the time).

Cheers,

Steve