Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

power honing

Posts

power honing

#1

power honing

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I have a felt wheel that I use under power to hone tools after they are sharpened on a wheel. I use that stainless steel stuff for the polishing compound. Is that the best stuff for this purpose.?

Re: power honing

#2

Re: power honing

Rick Allen

>Hi Ellot,

Use some magnification to inspect the edge and the polished surfaces to see if you are getting the results from the power honing you are hoping for.

I would suspect that you want an edge which is without grinder marks and which has an even sharp edge. The edge off the grinder is most often a saw tooth looking thing when observed under magnification.

How much magnification? 100X is likely more than you would need to make an evaluation. Radio Shack sells a "pocket scope" with 60 - 100X magnification.

BTW the inside of the flute, if not polished, can contribute to a less refined edge.

Re: power honing

#3

Re: power honing

Don Evans

>What type of tools are you talking about? If it is turning tools then I don't see any need to hone them, they do what is needed right off the grinder just fine. In turning, no matter how sharp the tool is you still will need to sand, in other words you cannot attain a sharpness that will eliminate sanding.

In carving it is another story. You not only can but should attain a sharpness that don't require sanding generally speaking.

Honing in carving tools is very necessary. I posted in an earlier post how I power hone with a wheel turned from balsa (could use MDF)

that is flocked and then use the green oxide compound for carving tools.

There is a carver from Germany named Nora Hall, she is in her 80's now and has probably forgotten more than I will ever know about carving. Do google search of her and check out her web site. On there you can learn how to hone as I am talking about. I learned it from her.

Pay attention to the video on this to learn how to curl the compound over the edge of the tool.

I don't know what you are referring too with the stainless steel stuff but if you are talking about the stick type compound for SS then that is too course and will over heat the tool.

Don

Re: power honing

#4

Re: power honing

john lucas

>I agree with Don although I do hone my skews. You want a hard edge for honing otherwise you can round over the edge very slightly. The edge will still be very sharp but you lose some control over the cutting action. I use leather bonded to a wheel for my power hone. For my carving chisels I'm going to experiment with MDF shaped like I want and coated with green honing compound. MDF is stiff but not brutally hard so maybe it will work.

Re: power honing

#5

Re: power honing

Scott in Socal

>I recently made an MDF hone and was impressed by how well it worked. I got an arbor at woodcraft that let me just drill a hole in a piece of 3/4" mdf and then turn it to true, it just chucks up into my jacobs chuck. I made it the same diameter as my grinding wheels.

I also made a small round edged wheel that fits into a dremel for honing and polishing the inside of flutes, it works well also.

Re: power honing

#6

Re: power honing------WebKitFormBoundaryUa9ACXMWzM

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>In my original post I mentioned that I use a (hard) felt wheel. Perhaps I should rephrase my question to be, ... on a hard felt wheel, what is the best honing compound? I use it mostly to hone my skew chisels. I suppose I could simply take Rick's advise and try several to see which one seems to work best. I thought I would ask around first to find out other's experience.

------WebKitFormBoundaryUa9ACXMWzMgNlB+Q

Re: power honing

#7

Re: power honing

Rick Allen

>Sorry Ellot, I thought it was some sort of academic exersize.

The skew. The SS stuff you have will develop a terrific edge. The green studd works fine and black emory also will improve the edge of a skew.

I use a 6" Cratex medium and fine abrasive impregnated ruber wheels (rotating away from the cutting edge) which I find less messy and the results on a skew is a terrific edge.

The refinement you will get vs the dry grinder is quite noticable. The differneces between the compound you have, the green stuff, the black stuff or the ruber abrasive wheel is very small and likely not to be noticed in the cutting action of the skew.

Re: power honing

#8

Re: power honing

john lucas

>I have 5 different buffing sticks of different compounds and have played with them all but I stick with the Green compound I get from Lee Valley. It seems to work as well or better than any of the others.