Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Box maker's question

Posts

Box maker's question

#1

Steven Antonucci

Box maker's question

steve antonucci

>I have probably made about 10 boxes or so in my turning life, and over the weekend, I recalled why.

I was making a small mushroom box and the lid was a little bit tight. I had a 400 grit piece of sand paper and just barely touched the lip. I went from tight to loose in a second.

How the heck do you fit a lid when you have a to deal in hundredths?

S

Re: Box maker's question

#2

Re: Box maker's question

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>Hi Steve,

You can touch the end grain of the cap with a damp towel, the grain will swell a bit and tighten the fit.

I do not cut a straight edge on the fit, I cut a graduated taper and once I see a witness line for the fit I back cut from that mark but do not refine that diameter where the mark is.

Works for me.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Box maker's question

#3

Re: Box maker's question

john lucas

>I use the skew on it's side. I know, that's blasphemy but it's a really delicate cutting tool in that position. Sandpaper is the the worst possible thing to use on a box lid because it's almost impossible not to round over. If you must, glue a piece of paper to a stick and use that.

Another problem may be that your lid or the lip may not be parallel. I use a 6" ruler and gently set it on the lip. I compare this to the bed of the lathe by sighting over it. you can easily see if it tilts one way or the other. If the lip is parallel then it's easier to get the lid to fit right.

Re: Box maker's question

#4

Re: Box maker's question

Ed Moore of SW VA

>Steve,

The one place I never use sandpaper is on the tenon of a box. It does several things. It removes slightly more than you would want, it rounds over, and it generates heat. These things affect the fit. That said, I MAY touch the tenon with 600 grit, but I don't apply much pressure.

Sequence matters. As a general rule, when making a box, make the female part before the male part. So for a lid that fits over a tenon on the bottom part, make the lid first. After hollowing the base, LET IT COOL BEFORE FITTING THE TENON. Heat builds up when hollowing and tensions are released. I think Richard Raffan told me to fit the tenon after lunch. If you make the lid, then hollow the base and sand inside,and then proceed to fit the tenon immediately, what happens when the base cools off? The tenon shrinks slightly and the fit loosens.

Ed

Re: Box maker's question

#5

Re: Box maker's question

Greg Haugen

>I don't make a "piston" tenon (straight sides to straight sides). I make a "bellied" tenon, ala Raffan and Stafford. I use a 1/4" parting tool and only remove "dust" with each cut/scrape, but basically roll it (like English turners use the beading/parting tool) slightly to form the "belly". The base has the belly and the lid is straight. These have a lot more "give and take" built in to the tenon than a straight sided tenon.

As previously mentioned, never fit a "hot/warm" box. Let it cool/rest before the final fitting. Never use sandpaper to adjust the fit.

For an "ill-fitting" lid, the water trick will help a little or I've also made a snug jam chuck that the base fits over and that will "adjust" the fitting a little on softer woods as well.

When it comes to boxes, Heat/Warmth is not your friend.

Re: Box maker's question

#6

Mike Stafford

Re: Box maker's question

Mike Stafford

>I follow the advice given by Ed and Greg. A sanded tenon causes the tenon to go our of round and you get a "twist lock" fit which impresses your customers but not other turners.

Final fitting of the lid is best done long after the lid and body have cooled to room temperature. If your sanding or cutting process on the lid caused the wood to warm up and expand (and those prcesses always do) you can end up with a loose fit on your lid if you make your lid fitting adjustments while the wood is hot.

I use a skew sometimes and sometimes I use a parting tool to create the bellied tenon Greg referenced. It is a matter of how long the tenon is that determines which I use. If I have a long tenon then I will use a skew on its side to adjust the fit removing dust a little bit at a time until the lid fits as I want. If the tenon is short then a parting tool is used to remove that dust. Don't fool yourself and remove anything but dust or you will experience that "Oh shoot" moment when the too tight lid becomes the too loose lid.

A bellied tenon is one where there is a slight outward curve of the tenon to the exact diameter where the lid fits and then a slight curve back in at the bottom of the tenon. This belly makes it easier to get the lid started on and then creates a suction fit when the lid is pushed on all the way.

It is important that the lid flange is parallel so that the internal diameter of the lid does not change as you push it on. If the lid is dovetailed outwardly then the lid will not fit and stay on. If it is dovetailed inwardly then the lid will be tight as it goes on and when it passes the belly it will be loose and spin.

And to complicate things the fit of the lid changes with the humidity levels....

Re: Box maker's question

#7

Re: Box maker's question

Dick Coers

>Turners get more bothered by the fit than customers. In fact, many are concerned about having a box that requires two hands. Personally I think the fit depends on the size of the box. A 4" diameter box should have a lift off lid, a 2" requires a friction fit. I've found many customers want to just lift off the lid while the box remains on the dresser. It's rare to find a customer that likes a "pop" when they take off the lid.

Re: Box maker's question

#8

Re:I just charge an extra $10 for the "twist-lock"

Russ Fairfield

>

Re: Box maker's question

#9

Steven Antonucci

I think this was my problem

steve antonucci

>I did manage to get one right afterwards, but the main issue was hurrying through it without accomodating for the heat shrinking effect.

Steve

Re: Box maker's question

#10

Steven Antonucci

yeah, but I am a turner ;-)

steve antonucci

>

Re: Box maker's question

#11

Re: Box maker's question

Bob Rogne

>It depends on where the box is turned and where the box is used or sold. I turned 13 in Mesa Az and now back in Minn. the humidity has caused a problen in 5 of them. The type of wood I think makes a differnce.

Bob R West Mac Turning

PS If they are loose a little CA will make them tight.

Re: Box maker's question

#12

Re: Box maker's question

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I believe Jim shaver's advice is just right. If you are as methodical as I think you are, then try to use his technique to get a "snap" fit. The idea is that the cross section of the male part of the lid should look something like a shallow "V" shape. It's extremely satisfying if you can get that "snap" when you're done!

Re: Box maker's question

#13

Re: Box maker's question

robo hippy

>Sorry, I was off fishing on a conservation lake in NW Ontario, Canada.

I have only turned maybe 200 boxes. My method now is to rough turn the pieces first. No matter how 'dry' the wood is, it will adjust after removing bulk. Primary reason I don't turn them all the way in one sitting. Let the pieces sit for a week or two.

I prefer parallel fittings for the lid and body, using a 6 inch steel ruler held on each piece and sighted along the lathe bed to let me know how close I am.

I use a skew on its side as a negative rake scraper to fine tune the fit. I don't like a 'popping' lid, but one that just has a little suction to remove.

I went from spring time Oregon to Davis, CA for a show, 75 degrees, and 80% humidity to 90 degrees and 30 % humidity. Some of the boxes moved.

robo hippy

Re: Box maker's question

#14

Re: Box maker's question

john lucas

>I've always turned my boxes to completion in one sitting. The only problem I've had is the wood moving seasonally. Around here it's very humid in the summer and very dry in the winter. I should clarify these are all under 2" wide. I do use wood that is quite dry and if I'm in doubt at all I will weight it and put it in the microwave for a little zap. I have taken fruit woods and rough turned them. Then use the microwave to further dry them. I guess each person has find what works for them. Grain direction is for me is more important than how dry the wood is. Side grain boxes,which I don't turn much move more than end grain.

Re: Box maker's question

#15

Re: Box maker's question

Ron in Drums PA

>This is the way I do it also Robbo, the only difference is I use my skew instead of a rule to sight along the lathe bed.

I also make the tenon first and turn the top while it is on the base.

Wood moves, I don't care how dry it is. I always wait a few days (sometimes a few months) after roughing out the box.

Re: Box maker's question

#16

Re: Box maker's question

Barry Turner

>Doesn't everyone use the skew on it's side?