Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

Posts

Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#1

Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

Eric Murphy - Spring TX

>I have a couple of Hamlet tools, one ASP 2060 and one HSS, and I really like them...I like the handles, the feel of the tools, etc. I am looking at adding a couple of tools to my inventory and had initially only looked at Hamlet. Because of a comment I saw somewhere else, I have now started thinking about the Taylor Kryo tools. Other than the information I can find on Taylor's website and Hamlet's website, I can't find any information comparing the Hamlet ASP to the Taylor Kryo. Has anyone used both tools and have any thoughts comparing them? The steel, the feel of the tools (which I know is highly individual), their ability to retain an edge, their durability, etc?

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#2

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP *LINK*

john lucas

>I looked at them all about a year or more ago. I bought the Thompson tools. I think they are better tools. If your not familar with them they are state of the art Powdered metal technology and they are cryogenically treated as well.


http://www.thompsonlathetools.com/

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#3

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

Lance Kanaby

>I love my Thompson turning tools! And they really well priced.

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#4

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

Steve in NC

>Count me as another happy Thompson customer. It is where I buy as I replace my current tools.

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#5

Steve Kubien

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

Steve Kubien

>Eric, it does not directly answre your question about Taylor vs Hamlet but I will echo what others have said about the Thompson tools.

You say you really like the handles and overall feel of your current tools. Changing brands may or may not be to your liking but with the Thompson's you make your own handles as they are sold without. From what you said in your post, I think they are a viable option for you. I love mine (3 bowl gouges, 2 spindle gouges, a detail gouge and a skew at last count).

Hope this helps.

Steve Kubien

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#6

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

Gordon Seto

>Cryogenic heat treatment is not the whole story about tool steel property. As I understand, it is an expensive process that improve the tool steel quality. It has to start with good quality tool steel first. IMO, some brands just use this term as a advertising slogan; they want us to believe this cryogenic treatment is the magic. Some don't even mention what type of tool steel their tools are made out of.

Turbo charging a riding lawn mower engine will not have the same horse power as turbo charging a Dodge Viper.

As a hobbyist turner, I think my Thompson tools would be part of my kids inheritance. They are made by a wood turner for wood turners. Doug listens to the feedback. His new tool lines were mostly from requests of what turners want. Besides great steel, the flutes are efficient. They are pleasure to use, affordable and they don't clog.

For me, my search was over, I don't have a need to explore other brands.

Disclaimer: Proud to belong to the same AAW local Clubs with Doug and a happy customer. No financial relationship.

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#7

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

steve worcester

>Get the Thompson gouges and some Trent Bosch handles. You can't go wrong.

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#8

Re: There was a very good presentation during....

Jamie Donaldson

>.........the recent AAW Symposium that expanded on the recent tool and sharpening article in the Journal. I was able to finally learn more about the differences in some of these exotic alloys, such as the 2030 and 2060 are more heat resistant, while M4,A-11 and V-15 are wear resistant.

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#9

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

Eric Murphy - Spring TX

>I am familiar with Thompson tools and have heard all sorts of good things about them. However, one of the tools I would like to add is a roughing gouge.

I only got back into turning because my son showed some interest in turning pens. To get him started, since I didn't know if he would want to stick with it, I picked up the cheap $10 set of tools from Harbor Freight. Once I saw he was going to stick with it, I picked him up a nice Hamlet HSS roughing gouge. I would like to get one for myself so he can feel like it's his and not mine that I'm just letting him use.

While I can appreaciate the quality of the Thompson tools and am in no way questioning the value or the price, I just simply can't justify $170 for a roughing gouge and that's the price shown for the only roughing gouge I see on his site. I don't know if I will actually wind up getting one of the ASP or Kryo tools as they are quite pricy too compared to HSS but I thought I kick the idea around and try to figure out if anyone knows what the difference is.

Thanks for the comments so far but I hope someone can shed some more light on the ASP versus Kryo question instead of just pointing me towards something else altogether.

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#10

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>If you look just at the steel the ASP 2060 is better, now the Taylor is M2 or M4? with a cryogenic treatment, IMO ONLY the cryogenic treatment alone is not worth the extra price they want for it.

These are made from flat bar stock and the tang is cut on a press then the flute is forged. I can't even come close when the SRG starts as a round bar of stock but you could rough a giant bowl. Mark St.Leger has a 5/8 SRG if you contact him, I might have one or two around here.

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#11

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

Gordon Seto

>The manufacturing process of the Thompson SRG is totally different from a forged gouge. It has the safest construction. The chance of snapping at the tang is greatly reduced. As seen in the picture, the top one is the Thompson which has 3/4" round tang. The bottom is the 2nd best which has 1/2" round tang. The Thompson has 225% more cross section area.


img

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#12

I could never understand...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>why P&N cuts the shank down to 1/2 inch with the taper up to the 1-1/4 diameter when you need strength at the shank. I wonder how many tools are designed by non-woodturners or we have different ideas how a tool should be made.

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#13

Re: I could never understand...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Sure Doug, until very recently, lathes have been designed by non-turning engineers who thought that all turning was spindle turning. Why else would minimum speeds be 500 or 600 rpm, and bowls and especially HF's be so difficult to comfortably turn? Somebody finally saw the light and designed lathes with var. speeds and sliding headstocks.

Wally

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#14

Re: I could never understand...

Gordon Seto

>Because some consumers are not knowledgeable about wood turning before we buy the woodturning equipment and tools. We buy into the bells and whistles features in their advertising.

Unfortunately non-woodturners may think that higher speed may be desirable. A digital speed read out is useful.

In advertising, they never tell:

the cons of a gap bed;

the loss of use of the tail stock when we pivot the head stock;

why the disk sander in place of a hand wheel is actually a bad idea - loss the use of the spindle through hole.

Some of us buy our first equipment based on price, the trivial features and how they look. I learned it the hard way, after I joined our Clubs and slowly educated what the real lathes should be. I think that's why we keep upgrading.

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#15

Re: I could never understand...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Your right Wally, years ago roughing a 10 inch bowl would scare the heck out of me, thank goodness it changed.

The Taylor Kryo is a good example how advertizing works, the tool is gold plated and pushed as lasting X times longer then the price jumps $20. I love to see some of the pricing with tools, they push the handle length or type wood it's made from yet the same tool without the handle is $5 less. The new woodturner really has to watch out because there are companies that target them... if your new just be carefull.

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#16

Re: There was a very good presentation during....

Mike Brazeau

>Wish I had been there Jamie. Here is a chart I put together a couple of years ago for a presentation I made at our Golden Horseshoe Guild on Tools and Tool Making. Data was takien from various tool steel related sites including ASP and Crucible. The elements realted to wear and hardness are in blue. I have had a Hamlett 2060 5/8 bowl gouge for about 8 years and love it, especially after Steve Kubien tweaked my grind last summer when he stopped by. It looks very close to the Ellsworth grind and is my go to tool. I find it grinds to a finer edge as compared to a Oneway M4 gouge and it does have excellent life. I also have a Hamlett 1 1/4" ASP 2030 Spindle Roughing Gouge which I absolutely love. Bought it from Jacques Coulombe when he was clearing stock on 2030 tool some years ago. I wish I had need of another gouge, so I could buy one of Doug's. If I make it to Hartford next year I'll come up with a reason to come home with one. In my other life I was involved with the optical spectrometers used to measure metal alloys. Tools steels are so special we didn't run across them often, but did have an instrument with the company that pioneered the use of Cobalt Stellite alloys. Principal difference between the ASP alloys and the Crucible M series is the Cobalt in the ASP.


img

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#17

Great chart!

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Thank you Mike! Jamie, this chart shows why the ASP 2030-2060 are more heat resistant, the high cobalt content is great if your cutting metal and the chips are blue but when the chips are made of wood it doesn't do much for us. For woodturning it really comes down to one element... Vanadium for wear resistant.

Mike the chart should be corrected M2 has about 2% vanadium not 6

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#18

Here is corrected chart

Mike Brazeau

>Thanks Doug. Looked up my original notes on this and when I typed up I had missed the V number and shifted everything one column to the left.


img

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#19

Re: There was a very good presentation during....

Cindy Drozda

>Actually, I believe the most important difference between ASP (2030, 2060) and CPM10V/A11 (Thompson tools) is that 10V/A11 contains Vanadium Carbides and ASP contains Tungsten Carbides. Cobalt doesn't add any edge retention as far as I know.

Re: Henry Taylor Kryo vs Hamlet ASP

#20

Re: There was a very good presentation during....

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Cindy your right Cobalt doesn't add any edge retention, it only helps when milling steel so the cutting edge doesn't burn up to put it simply.