Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

White birch turns black

Posts

White birch turns black

#1

White birch turns black

mfoster

>I was working in my fields, cutting back over-growth about 30 feet to the original edge of the fields. This sounds easy, but it's really a LOT of work. I took down several smallish trees (up to about 12" diam) of species including Paper Birch, Oak, Maple, Linden and Aspen. After all that work I decided to have some fun and put a piece of the birch on the lathe to turn a natural edge bowl. My intention was to do it all in one go, and I did it rather fast and wasn't really watching what I was doing and blew through the bottom. Bet no one else has ever done that. Anyway the piece started taking on an ugly black stain soon after it was turned. I turned a bowl from a piece of birch last year that I had sealed and left sitting in the shop for about 6 months before chucking it up and had the same thing happen with it. I chalked the first bowl up to spalting because it had been sitting around. This last bowl came straight from a healthy growing tree. So what's up with the black stain? Anyone else have this happen?

Re: White birch turns black

#2

Steven Antonucci

Tanin staining in the sapwood?

steve antonucci

>Little black splotches in the sapwood is what I think you mean? Likely tanin reacting with the steel in your tool. One of the joys of wet turning (not!)

Steve

Re: White birch turns black

#3

Re: Rub the surface with a section.....

Jamie Donaldson

>....of lemon (not the fake stuff!)and I bet the stains will be gone.

Re: White birch turns black

#4

Re: Tanin staining in the sapwood?

mfoster

>Steve, I just didn't think that birch would have tanins in it. I didn't notice any rusting on the ways of the lathe from the wet shavings. However, after inspecting the piece, I noted some marks that I am certain were where I was checking the thickness of the piece near the edge with calipers.

Jamie, I wasn't aware that acids would get rid of the staining. I'll give a try with both some lemon and vinegar and see what results. Can't ruin the piece anymore than I already have.

Mike

Re: White birch turns black

#5

Steven Antonucci

Lemon is how I clean my hands

steve antonucci

>Fake stuff... takes the black off instantly, and lets me know if I have any cuts too :-)

S

Re: White birch turns black

#6

JL

Not acids particularly - there is some other stuff

JL

>going on. You have some "antioxidant" activity going on with the ascorbic acid in the lemon. You also have a limited amount of chelation taking place with the citric acid in the lemon. The low pH (acidity) also helps to dissolve any iron present.

The vinegar just has low pH going for it. The lemon (juice or whole lemon) has a bit more.

I always have to use lemon to clean my hands after some long sessions at the shaving mule working on white oak spindles.

Re: White birch turns black

#7

Re: Not acids particularly - there is some other s

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Has anyone has tried using ascorbic or citric acid instead of lemon juice? I tried lemon juice in a spray bottle, but it molds after a while in my shop...er' studio.

Re: White birch turns black

#8

Re: White birch turns black

John Jordan

>It's fungal growth, all light colored woods are very susceptible to it, and lemon juice won't remove it. Lemon juice removes tannic acid/iron staining.

The only way to prevent it is to get the free water out of the wood which is what supports the fungal growth. The quicker to dry the better, short of drying so fast it cracks. I use compressed air to blow out as much free water as I can, particularly on white sapwood, and any light colored maples. This is important to me as I depend on the bright, fresh colors.

Sealing/bagging etc just make it worse.

John