Rick, there is no simple answer ...
Ed Moore of SW VA
>to your question. Consider:
1. Was the club started by and fed by the professional turners in the club who give lessons for a fee?
If so, maybe some consideration of them is appropriate.
2. Do the professional turners demo for the club? And if so, do they charge for this demo?
If they charge the club for their demo and other members who demo receive no compensation, then IN MY OPINION, the club has no reason to "protect" their income and the club should do what it wants relative to mentoring sessions and sawdust sessions.
If they do NOT charge for their demo and are supportive of the club in other ways, then have some club mentoring for newbies and try to turn them over to the pros for lessons once they are ready for lessons. In other words, try to find a middle ground and make it a win-win situation for everyone.
3. I used to hold "skill enhancement sessions" for newbies on a regular basis and these sessions were sanctioned by the club. After a successful run of a year or two I found that folks would say they would be there and then one or two instead of five or six would show up and these guys had no real questions but were there for the camaraderie. I discontinued the practice and after a year or two others have picked up the slack due to the arrival of more newbies. I am pleased that many solid members of the club attribute their woodturning improvement to those old skill enhancement sessions. At this point I prefer to limit my teaching to the John C Campbell Folk School, unless of course someone shows up waving money. [grin] I belong to a second club which held a sawdust sessions a few weeks ago and over twenty showed up for help at the club president's shop. I took a lathe and helped all day for free and felt that it was one of the most productive sessions I have been involved with. About five advanced turners manned stations and taught tool use and sharpening.
4. Here is an idea for sharpening sessions. After you sharpen the tool for someone, take them to a lathe and make them make some cuts on some scrap wood with the newly sharpened tool. Maybe you demonstrate the cut first and then they try it. At the aforementioned sawdust session guys were almost speechless after making a successful cut on the outside of a bowl correctly with a sharpened tool. It was like they had had an epiphany.
I guess my thought about teaching pros in the club comes down to how they handle things. If they seem to be at the meetings to poach new students, then you have a problem. However, most I know are helpful, kind, thoughtful, and help old ladies across the street. The latter group would probably be supportive of a mentoring program.
Good luck,
Ed