Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

club mentoring programs

Posts

club mentoring programs

#1

club mentoring programs

rick pixley

>I was at a meting last evening and posed a question based on the needs of a member.The member stated he did not know how to turn the bottom(he's fairly new). I asked him where he lived and invited him over for some basic lessons.This was past practice of other clubs I belonged to in a different state. In a later discussion with our president and the president of another club I asked about starting a "mentoring" program to aid new turners with basic turning and safety,to include open workshops on weekends. It seems we have a few professional turners in our area and the outside president said we had to be careful not to infringe on these folks as they charge for this service. I then said that in my opinion most professional instructors tend to be very specific in their classes offered and that a workshop sponsored by the club should not be considered taking food from the mouths of these professionals. Anyway it was not resolved and was just a topic of discussion. My dilemma is, what exactly is the function of a club other than to recruit and teach new members and old in different techniques. Comments pls and I don't mean to offend anyone pls...

Re: club mentoring programs

#2

Steven Antonucci

Mentoring works both ways

steve antonucci

>Mentoring is not only a good thing for the new turner, but the mentor as well. It teaches him/her how to teach. Just because we kow how to do something doesn't alwys make us the best person to explain it. When I started mentoring, I realized that different people learn at different paces, via different mechanisms, and for different reasons.

As an example, I am a knowledge gatherer. I need to know how to do things, even if I will never do them myself. Other people are "project learners", or folks who want to learn how to make a specific item (with no regard to how to get there). Mentors need to be able to evaluate their students to figure out why they turn, or the results can be very unsatisfying for both people.

As far as the infringing on the commercial instruction market, i think that's just too bad. If someone makes a living teaching turning, they best be driving their own demand vs. worrying about other people "giving away" what they sell. If they can't explain the difference between a day in their shop and a day with a mentor, then they probably need to worry about marketing more than competition.

I remember the first time one of the guys from one of my clubs came over to my shop. We did a bunch of things and when he was ready to leave, he offered me money for the day. I've never been in a more awkward position in my life, but he explained that other guys in the club did charge for "lessons" and that he had paid in the past. I am not suggesting that my time has no value or that I couldn't charge for it (I know that I could), but I am not looking at my club's members as a source of income.

Interesting topic.

Steve

Re: club mentoring programs

#3

Dick Hines

Re: club mentoring programs

Dick Hines

>Va has a turning symposium ever two years and mentoring is what it is all about. Last year we had turners from all over the state helping other turners with subjects from how to use a chain saw to turning bottle stoppers. I think mentoring is a great way for new turners to learn about turning.

When people become new turners they may need all the help they can get. As they get more experance they may want to take a class from a pro on just one subject like bowls or hollow froms. Haveing someone close by to help out is what clubs are really good for.

Re: club mentoring programs

#4

Re: club mentoring programs

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>The Carolina Mountain Woodturners officially supports mentoring. Forty-one club members have their contact information listed on the website as mentors. This is about 10% of the club's members. Several of these are full-time professional turners who share willingly. Here are the guidelines for the program:

Carolina Mountain Woodturners Mentor Program Guidelines

The Mentor program has been established for the purpose of bringing together the experienced and the novice for the sharing and expansion of woodturning knowledge within and between the Carolina Mountain Woodturner (CMW) members. CMW�s role is purely to facilitate the meeting of the members willing to share their knowledge and

experience with members wanting help in learning the art of woodturning. Even the mentors can learn something from helping others. By teaching others, the knowledge you have is recognized by you and by others. It is also a way to reinforce what you know

and that mentoring experience will help you consistently apply what you are teaching.

1. The program is strictly voluntary between both members.

2. You may have more than one mentor.

3. There is no cost associated with the sharing of knowledge under this program.

4. The amount of time spent will be determined by the parties.

5. The number of meetings will be determined by the parties.

6. The meeting locations will be determined by the parties.

7. If feasible, it is recommended that the mentor visit the member�s studio.

8. The mentor should establish a baseline of knowledge that the member possesses.

9. Mentoring can take several paths in assisting and needs to be determined between the parties.

� Informal may be just telephone calls when assistance is needed, or

� Semi-formal may include meeting to watch, assist, and answer questions, or

� Formal may include a written outline with scheduled meetings, projects, etc. as determined by the parties.

Re: club mentoring programs

#5

Rick, there is no simple answer ...

Ed Moore of SW VA

>to your question. Consider:

1. Was the club started by and fed by the professional turners in the club who give lessons for a fee?

If so, maybe some consideration of them is appropriate.

2. Do the professional turners demo for the club? And if so, do they charge for this demo?

If they charge the club for their demo and other members who demo receive no compensation, then IN MY OPINION, the club has no reason to "protect" their income and the club should do what it wants relative to mentoring sessions and sawdust sessions.

If they do NOT charge for their demo and are supportive of the club in other ways, then have some club mentoring for newbies and try to turn them over to the pros for lessons once they are ready for lessons. In other words, try to find a middle ground and make it a win-win situation for everyone.

3. I used to hold "skill enhancement sessions" for newbies on a regular basis and these sessions were sanctioned by the club. After a successful run of a year or two I found that folks would say they would be there and then one or two instead of five or six would show up and these guys had no real questions but were there for the camaraderie. I discontinued the practice and after a year or two others have picked up the slack due to the arrival of more newbies. I am pleased that many solid members of the club attribute their woodturning improvement to those old skill enhancement sessions. At this point I prefer to limit my teaching to the John C Campbell Folk School, unless of course someone shows up waving money. [grin] I belong to a second club which held a sawdust sessions a few weeks ago and over twenty showed up for help at the club president's shop. I took a lathe and helped all day for free and felt that it was one of the most productive sessions I have been involved with. About five advanced turners manned stations and taught tool use and sharpening.

4. Here is an idea for sharpening sessions. After you sharpen the tool for someone, take them to a lathe and make them make some cuts on some scrap wood with the newly sharpened tool. Maybe you demonstrate the cut first and then they try it. At the aforementioned sawdust session guys were almost speechless after making a successful cut on the outside of a bowl correctly with a sharpened tool. It was like they had had an epiphany.

I guess my thought about teaching pros in the club comes down to how they handle things. If they seem to be at the meetings to poach new students, then you have a problem. However, most I know are helpful, kind, thoughtful, and help old ladies across the street. The latter group would probably be supportive of a mentoring program.

Good luck,

Ed

Re: club mentoring programs

#6

Re: club mentoring programs

mark wollschlager

>Our club has several avenues for training and mentoring.

We are lucky enough to have the use of a shop in a public school ( which we maintain ).

The club offers two 'skill enhancement' days a month, during the week.

Its an open shop day with experienced turners available for assistance and kibitzing.

We also offer mentoring matchups with members who have offered their services. Details are worked out between the student and mentor.

We give the mentors a red hat to wear at meetings , so they are readily visible to prospective students.

We have also had monthly meetings with a theme of skill enhancement.

An open shop day on a weekend for folks who can't make the weekday open shops.

The County has adult education classes in the evening in the same shop. The teachers have tended to be club members.

Several levels of Woodturning classes have been taught for almost 10 years.

Very economical, and and fits the folks who can't do day classes.

On top of that, the local Woodcraft still has a full schedule of turning classes at their prices, as well as private classes by local turners.

We all seem to get along just fine.

I would bring the mentoring program up for a vote at your next club meeting.

Even if it is not put through at that time, you will have planted the seed for future consideration.

Most of the time, all it takes is an organizer and a few motivated individuals to make it all happen.

Good luck,

Mark.

Re: club mentoring programs

#7

Re: club mentoring programs

robo hippy

>When I mentor, it is usually one or two turners coming over to see me turn bowls, which is my speciaty. This usually involves an hour at most of my time, and I am producing product during the session, but not at the rate I do when I am alone. Some times they will bring a piece of wood. This is more than I would charge. I love mentoring as much as I do turning.

If it was going to be a half or full day with me doing a lot of hands on type work, and supplying materials, then it would be a workshop, and I would probably charge. Haven't done that yet.

Two different levels of teaching.

As a side note, you should have liability insurance.

robo hippy

Re: club mentoring programs

#8

Re: club mentoring programs

Greg Haugen

>Our club has mentors and they are used often depending on close they are and the "specialty" of choice.

I do mentor quite a bit. It's not uncommon for someone to call with a specific question or to come over and practice a technique. I don't charge usually, especially if it's club members. With the exception of a couple of people saying they want to do a day of bowl turning. Even then, it's a small fee to cover prep time, etc. That's different than someone saying "I can't get this __?__ gouge to cut and I can't sharpen it either." One thing that's great about turning is the willingness of others to help one another.

As far as "pro's" in the area, I don't really see a conflict there. Mostly because everyone does it differently. I have taken 1 on 1 classes with a regional "pro" and it's worth every penny-I'd highly recommend it. I first started though, I have also been in a jam and someone stopped over to help me out which was greatly appreciated. I wasn't told, "I'd love to help you but you need to pay $____ and go to see "so and so".

I'll often times also go to the "mentee's" house. It won't do them any good to learn how to do something with my set up if they have a different set-up.

Re: club mentoring programs

#9

Two-sides alright but....

Bill Howatt

>I can see both sides of this question but isn't the idea of a turning club to learn about turning through other members of the club? Or is it just a "look at what I can make" venue?

Aren't the demos or bringing in professional turners to give seminars also a way to undermine the local pros who give lessons? Also, many clubs themseleves have a course for new turners. You could say that these activities will get a new turner interested which would feed the local professional's business.

Like I said, I can see the "business" aspect but it goes against what I see as the purpose of a good turning club.

Bill