Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Spinning top personal preferences?

Posts

Spinning top personal preferences?

#1

Spinning top personal preferences?

Jim Stoppleworth

>I need to turn a few dozen of these simple tops for a charity. I'm looking for the best way to turn them. Turn them with the stem toward the tailstock or the stem toward the headstcok?

Jim

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

#2

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

Terry Quiram

>I always turn with the stem towards the headstock. I use only HARD MAPLE!!!! If you use walnut or cherry the stem tends not to hold the weight of the top centered as you turn the stem which results in a top that spins excentric.

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

#3

Ditto Stem toward headstock

john lucas

>

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

#4

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

David Belser

>Handle towards the tail stock, you can go crazy with impossibly thin and elaborate stems with all the meat supporting the body until you part them off. Chuck up a pen blank and make 4 tops before your skew hits the chuck jaws.

Have fun.

- Dave

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

#5

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

Greg Haugen

>I have to agree with David. I actually turn them both ways but usually prefer stem towards the tailstock for a couple of reasons. One, as David mentioned you can go crazy with the stem. It's also easiest to do something (chatter, Sorby texture, grooves, lines, etc., etc.) on the "face" of the top, which is what matters the most-you see it 99.99999999% of the time. I prefer a skew for parting off. Even a $5 top at a gallery or craft show shouldn't have tool marks-at all, so if you have to clean it up grip the stem in a jacob's chuck very lightly or use "pin" jaws. Often times I'll usually roll a bead at the joint of the top and stem to strengthen the stem.

As already mentioned, Kiln dried HARD MAPLE is wonderful for tops.

Here are some "two piece" marbled maple tops.


img

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

#6

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

Jim Stoppleworth

>The several dozen I've done so far the stem was toward the headstock. From my personal experience (albeit a relatively small sample) the tops that spin the truest and longest have a dished out top face so they look more like an upside down paper umbrella like you'd see in a kiddy cocktail. I was finding that without wasting extra wood on length of stem it was relatively hard to get a tool in that space to dish out the topface. Glad to see by the responses that like so many things in turning what works for you works!

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

#7

Steven Antonucci

Where do you want your detail?

steve antonucci

>I tend to do the handle towards the headstock because I can get a better point on the bottom of the top if I have access to the bottom. I believe that the best tops I have turned (almost imperceptible wobble) get that way from having a very refined point to spin on, which is difficult to do without access to the bottom.

Making a small wooden collet to hole the stem may give you the best of both worlds...

Steve

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

#8

Re: Where do you want your detail?

Greg Haugen

>Points are often over-rated. Japanese tops traditionally have a rather blunt or rounded point to them. Parting down with a skew will leave a very sharp point and I often do round it over slightly.

Lacer's "Son of Skew" dvd has an excellent section on a variety of tops.

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

#9

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

David Belser

>The best (as in longest) spinners are turned true out of dense wood with more mass on the outside if possible. When I turn my umbrella tops, I actually try to make them a little thicker on the rim.

As mentioned in another post, points are overrated. The wood needs an even density - you can turn a real wobbler if you find a small knot! Good true turning is the other important thing. Parting off with the base towards the headstock is pretty easy with a skew.

Do whatever works for you (but experiment), and remember to have fun!

Re: Spinning top personal preferences?

#10

Re: Spinning top personal preferences? *LINK*

Fred W Holder

>Over the years, I've turned several thousand spinner tops. My tops are not fancy or ornate, they're just good spinners. That is what is really important. I use 1" thick slices off of limbs that are 1-1/2" to 2" in diameter or scraps from turning other things. I drill a 3/8" hole as close to center as possible and insert and glue in a section of 3/8" hard maple dowel rod that has been cut to 2-1/2" long.

When the glue is dry, I generally give it 24 hours just to be on the safe side, I chuck the dowel up in my dowel chuck that I use to turn bottle stoppers (available from Craft Supplies USA) and push the dowel in as far as it will go while turning the large part of the top. First I make it round and then turn the bottom with a long slope to the point. When I'm satisfied with the shape there, I turn the top of the top to a pleasing shape and then clean up the very edge. I try to keep the edge under 0.1" and generally shoot for about 0.05" thickness.

Then and only then do I pull the dowel out further to turn the stem. I generally turn the stem to 1/8" or less in diameter by about 1" long. I then sand the whole thing and apply a coat of wax. It brings out the color in the wood and makes the top look better. Especially effective when people are watching you turn the top. I part off with a skew, leaving the top of the stem with a tapered, but slightly blunt point. This way the top can be spun either way.

I normally turn my tops with the grain running in the spindle turning direction (parallel to the axis of the lathe rotation), because when the grain runs the other direction there is a problem with the wood chipping at the point where the wood joins the dowel on the bottom. It really doesn't hurt the top, other than its looks, and that bothers me.


More Woodturning Web Site