Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Redefining sharp

Posts

Redefining sharp

#1

Steven Antonucci

Redefining sharp

steve antonucci

>I bought some carving tools at the Woodcraft in RI yesterday. It was my first experience with "good' carving tools. I have some older, pitted Sorbys, some cheap tools and a couple of Flexcut knives (which I used to think were sharp)

I think the Woodcraft Swiss Made brand used to be Pfeil, but was recently renamed. The two that I bought brought a brand new meaning to the word sharp. I will be buying more soon.

Anyone here have experience with carving tools? What are the best of the best?

Steve

Re: Redefining sharp

#2

Re: Redefining sharp

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>I agree Steve. I bought a whole bunch of Pfeil carving tools when I was living in Switzerland 30 years ago. They cut most woods like butter. I don't carve much any more, but when I do, my great respect for them quickly returns. And, be careful picking them out of the drawer to use them -- or get used to counting your fingers after each use. Don't as me how I found that out!

Re: Redefining sharp

#3

Re: Redefining sharp

john lucas

>I don't have a lot but I've found that the angle you sharpen and the technique you use to sharpen is probably the most important. I have Pfiel which cuts wonderfully so I took my old General tool palm gouge and sharpened it to the same angle and used the same sharpening technique and now they both cut the same.

I have several old Greenlee gouges that never did cut well even when sharp. I decreased the cutting angle the next time I sharpened them and improved them a huge amount.

I don't think my tools are sharp enough however. I watch the pro's work and they seem to be cutting with less effort than I am. I've always heard that sharpening carving tools takes a long time to truely master. I thin that's correct.

Re: Redefining sharp

#4

Re:How you hone has a lot to do.....

Jamie Donaldson

>...with tool sharpness. I had a part time job in 1963 sharpening student scalpels in pre-med at Ohio State, and that was before disposable blades. The use of strops and crocus cloth is a key part of the process after the stones, and now a felt power wheel loaded with white diamond does a good job of renewing the edge very quickly.

Re: Redefining sharp

#5

Re:How you hone has a lot to do.....

Don Evans

>Jamie is right, I've tried every way under the sun and have finally got it.

The trick is power honing. I put together a power unit from scrap, turned a 1" x 6" wheel from balsa. Felt the wheel, use very thin coating of glue and then roll it in loose felt (flock). Use a variable speed motor from a treadmill. Some where around 1500 rpm is good speed, whats important is enough speed to melt the compound with friction.

I use green oxide compound to charge the wheel and it is all that is needed to keep the tools sharp.

Only thing I don't agree with 100 percent is using white diamond. It will polish the tool to a mirror finish but it will not cut it to a sharp edge like the green will, just my opinion, one should stick with what works for them.

You have to get the tool at just the right angle so the compound rolls over the edge and keep it at that angle. If you do this correctly you'll find that there is no bur remaining on the inside edge of the tool. Cann't get it sharper than that.

Don

Re: Redefining sharp

#6

Rob Wallace

Re: Redefining sharp

Rob Wallace

>Steve:

Several award-winning woodcarvers here in central Iowa told me that you can't do much better than Pfeil. I bought a bunch of these carving tools when attending a botanical meeting in Zuerich about 11 years ago, and they are superb (....they were sold at one of the local hardware stores; visiting the store as an adventure in itself!). Woodcraft prices are normally a bit high on these (although this may be one of the only sources in the US), so take advantage of one of their "blanket" 15% off sales if you don't need the tool(s) immediately...

As part of a woodcarving supply company inventory close-out sale I discovered through eBay a few years ago, I also bought a fairly extensive set of palm-style Flexcut carving tools (I paid just under half-price!) and they also do a fine job, but have to keep these honed a bit more frequently than I do for the Pfeil tools. I also think Flexcut tools are quite good; many carvers would agree with that...

I don't do huge amounts of carving, but it is really nice when the tools consistently perform well.

Rob Wallace