>While writing my response to Wilber I thought the following might be a good general question for the forum. When making a bowl at what point do you stop cutting and start sanding? Is is 80 grit or 150 for someplace higher or lower.
I am at the point that I like to be able to start at 150 or above and will continue with the chisel until I get there. Is it realistic to keep shooting for less need to sand?
>If we limit this to just bowls I strive to get the best finish I can off the tool. I've been playing with different grinds, turning speeds, and my technique. This all started when Stuart Batty did a demo where he sanded one side of a bowl to 400 grit and then turned the other side with his 40 degree gouge and then passed it around the room. You couldn't tell the difference. That was a challenge for me.
I'm not there yet but depending on the piece I can often start with 220. Now here's the problem. It takes a freshly sharpened tool, high turning speeds and very delicate control to get that. When I'm doing a production run I find it faster to just make a quick cut as clean as I can and then start with maybe 150. If the cut is smooth (I'm talking about the shape) but has tiny tool marks, these are rapidly removed by 150 and you can go through the grits pretty quick.
This is different than a spindle. With spindles and the skew I can get a finish that in theory doesn't need sanding. The problem is the finish doesn't bond to all of the areas the same. If I sand it lightly with 400 grit, even though in some cases this actually lowers the gloss of the piece, the finish goes on smoother and the final product is better.
When I'm turning bowls I'm looking for the best possible shape off the tool. The courser you start sanding the more likely you are to get lumps from hard and soft areas of the wood. The higher you can go when you start sanding the less problems you will have on the overall smoothness of the piece.
>"With spindles and the skew I can get a finish that in theory doesn't need sanding. The problem is the finish doesn't bond to all of the areas the same. If I sand it lightly with 400 grit, even though in some cases this actually lowers the gloss of the piece, the finish goes on smoother and the final product is better. "
Logic (probably flawed!) tells me that you are never going to get a surface straight off the tool that will accept a finish evenly without at least some degree of sanding. Why do I think this? No matter how sharp your tool, after the start of the first cut, the edge is instantly dulled to some extent which means that within an inch or two it is going to start laying over some fibers rather than cutting them cleanly (some woods more so than others). And if you contact the wood with the heel of the gouge or contact the bevel on the skew, you are actually burnishing the wood behind the cut, more in some places and less in others (because we are human and our control is not perfect) which also leads to uneven absorption of a finish.
Just my musings with my morning coffee...maybe someone will convince me I am wrong and I will spend the rest of my life trying to get a tool surface on an entire piece that requires no sanding at all before applying finish! ;)
>is like John and Carole mentioned- not to clean out torn grain, but to even off the surface for finishing. I strive for no tool marks in bowl, but regardless of the cut that I get, I usually start at 150 just because it only takes a minute, and some of the marks won't show until I get out to 400. 150/220, 320/400 done
For "user" bowls, I start and finish with 220, maybe one quick pass with 320. My finish is beeswax and mineral oil, and I expect them to get used so I don't go nuts "overprocessing" the wood. Popcorn kernels would scratch a high polish anyway...
>Interesting Carole. Would sandpaper not dull as well? I do agree with you on the burnishing and I use this sometimes when demoing. I will slow the feed rate of the tool down until the bevel has time to burnish the wood. This leaves a finish appearance that is impressive. This isn't any different that burnishing the wood with shavings that old time turners did all the time.
The finish bonds quite well to this surface but if you have a cove or bead that isn't burnished to the same degree as the flatter areas the light reflected from these areas will be slightly different after you finish them. What the sandpaper does is even out the reflectivity so all the surfaces reflect the same.
>Sometimes I think good sandpaper doesn't dull as quickly as a very keen tool edge! It is also cutting in different directions as it passes over the wood, picking up and cutting fibers that have been laid down rather than cut by the tool, especially if you are power sanding and using the reverse feature of your lathe. Of course worn out sandpaper does nothing but burnish at best. It's a tool like any other cutting tool.
>What we do with sanding depends on what we are willing to accept as "good enough" when the piece is finished.
I will never be able to brag about my tool skills and how fine a grit I can start with because I always start sanding every bowl with 60 grit, and sometimes wish I had one of those 46 grit discs. There is always some flaw that is easier to remove with the coarser grit. In spite of this handicap, I always manage to get there with a pretty good finish at the end, and that finished product is more important to me than what grit I started sanding with.
>I tend to agree with Russ. With production bowls I find it easier to start with a course grit as opposed to trying to do it with gouge. You spend 50% of your sanding time on the first grit - no matter what it is-
very little on the finer grits - no matter how many there are. Turning thin and starting with a fine grit are seen as a gauge of expertise by many turners. If you are selling work ( I am ) the buying public takes little notice of thin walls and my objective is usually to turn out a number of pieces as quickly as possible with reasonable quality finish.