Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Sanding epiphany

Posts

Sanding epiphany

#1

Sanding epiphany

wilbur

>On the bowls I've made so far I've had some problems with swirl and scratch marks, but this week I figured out a sanding routine that eliminated that issue for me. For sandpaper, I'm using Norton 3X, cut into suitable sizes. What I had been doing is starting at 80 grit, working my way up through each grit to 400. All the sanding was done by hand, and I tried to keep my hand moving back and forth as fast as possible.

This time, I cranked up the lathe speed and went at it with 100 grit paper. (Why 100 grit? I was out of 80 grit.) I know that this is counter to the usual advice to slow down the lathe speed, but I was looking for speed to get rid of my tool marks, and time was more important to me than scratch marks. I went through quite a bit of 100 grit, and probably didn't do my sandpaper any favors, but over all the time spent on this stage was less than what I had been doing before. I just went through more 100 grit sandpaper than I had before.

Next, I sanded the bowl with some more 100 grit with the lathe stopped, mainly along the grain lines in the bowl. This took out most of the circular scratches.

Then I turned the lathe on at a slower speed, and worked my way up through 400 grit. Going from grit to grit was relatively fast here.

Next, I used some sanding sealer on the bowl, I was still able to see a few fine scratches here and there, mainly due to my not moving my hand back and forth fast enough, especially near the rim and near the center of the inside of the bowl.

Then I sanded the sanding sealer with 400 grit, and then applied another coat of sanding sealer. I followed that with wax and buffing on the lathe with a paper towel.

This is the best finish I have gotten yet, and I can't see any scratches at all.

I think that what had stopped me from figuring this out before is that somehow I had the idea that I should spend more or less equal amounts time sanding with each grit, so I was probably not spending as much time on the low grits as I should have. My epiphany came when I realized that when I sharpen my plane blades and chisels, I spend the majority of my sharpening time on my coarse grit waterstone, and relatively little time on the higher grits. So it seemed to me that the same should apply to sanding a bowl on a lathe.

From here on out, I plan to be using about 3-4 times the amount of 80 or 100 grit sandpaper compared to the higher grits. After all, I've heard that turners should use sandpaper like someone else is buying it, so why not?

Of course, I figured this out just after I decided to give power sanding a try, and placed orders to get myself an angle drill and some 2" and 3" sanding discs and holders. :@)

Re: Sanding epiphany

#2

Re: Sanding epiphany

Skip Beardsley------WebKitFormBoundarylsHY4+4w161B

>Wilber,

Been there, done that, got the tee shirt. I will predict that your next epiphany will be when you realize that you can cut a bowl and have it come off the chisel needing only to start with 150 or 220 grit. Suggest you spend more time gaining chisel control and then you will need less time sanding.

Skip

Re: Sanding epiphany

#3

Re: Perfecting your power sanding.....

Jamie Donaldson

>....will be the solution to many of your problems, including cooking your fingers!

Re: Sanding epiphany

#4

Re: Sanding epiphany

Scott in Socal

>The best way I have heard it phrased is that you do all of you sanding with your heaviest grit. Get out every imperfection, do all your shaping with heavy. Then each grit after that only sands long enough to remove the scratches from the grit before. Work your way up until the scratch pattern is as fine as you want (micro mesh advertises it can make a scratch pattern finer than the naked eye can see, which is what polishing in any manner does) and then finish. .

Re: Sanding epiphany

#5

Steven Antonucci

They make 80 grit paper? :-)

steve antonucci

>Like Skip said, spend time with tool control and 80 grit never happens... It's 80 grit lines that you're still sanding out at 400 grit, not 220 grit lines...

Be diligent about one honing a finishing cut. When I present sharpening, the mantra is an 80 grit wheel leaves an 80 grit edge on your tool, which you then transfer to the wood. If you hone the edge with a fine diamond hone and take a finishing cut, you'll be starting at 220 only to level the surface...

Steve

Re: Sanding epiphany

#6

Re: Sanding epiphany

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>You have got some good advice here, especially from Scott.

You are working with really good sandpaper when you are using 3X. As Bruce Hoover (The Sanding Glove) said in an earlier post, he hopes to have it available in disks for power sanding later this year. Don't be afraid to start with 80 grit. It is better to spend a few minutes sanding with 80 grit than many minutes and much sandpaper sanding at 100 grit to get rid of tool marks. It saves time in the end to start at the lower grit.

As Scott said, get out all the problem areas with the first grit you use -- spend your time there. This is where you do your sanding. Working your way up through the grit is simply a way of removing the scratches from the previous grit.

Almost everybody will tell you to sand at the slowest speed possible. But, as you have found, high speed works -- and it cuts down the amount of time you spend sanding. The trick is to not put too much pressure on the sanding pad. Kiss the wood. The pressure from a 240 pound beer belly leaning against the sanding disk is enough to heat up anything. Heat is bad. Also, putting too much pressure forces the grit in up to its maximum depth, giving you Grand Canyons to sand out with the next grit.

Another trick you have already discovered -- use good sandpaper. It is less expensive in the end. Part of the reason people advocate slow speed sanding is that their sandpaper disintegrates if you crank up the speed. This will not happen with 3X. Besides that, the grit size is more consistent with the better sandpaper, so you do not have that one piece of 80 grit on the 220 grit sheet, as you do with the cheap stuff. That causes a lot of the sanding swirls.

Sounds like you are well on your way to a successful sanding career.

Re: Sanding epiphany

#7

Re: Sanding epiphany

David Belser

>Bill, I'm glad you finally said it. Whenever sanding comes up here, the advice to sand at slow speed is usually given.

What is often missed is that it is heat that is the bane of sanding. Heat will cause the paper to wear out quickly, your sanding pads to de-laminate. It can also cause the wood to harden dramatically, making sanding that much more difficult.

Slow speed sanding can easily cause you to sand much more of the soft part of the wood (side grain) than the hard part (end grain) leading to a very bumpy surface.

The heat is generated by friction with is the combination of speed and pressure, reduce either and you will get better results.

You can use a hard pad with the work spinning relatively fast as a shaping tool - with a moderate to light touch.

The best thing of course is to get good clean final cuts with sharp tools.

There are as many different sanding techniques as there are sharpening methods :)

Re: Sanding epiphany

#8

Shaping????

Carole Valentine

>I thought that was what your tools were for. When I start sanding, if I realize that some shaping needs to be done, I am going back to my cutting tools (the steel ones!)

Re: Sanding epiphany

#9

Re: Shaping????

Scott in Socal

>For breaking corners, removing subtle tools ridges and the like, sandpaper is often much faster for me, and time is scarce for me. 100 grit will take out the ridges in seconds, while I may have to take one or two minutes to scrape it perfect. It's also much faster and works better on work that is going out of round as you work (green wood turning to finish), and you don't end up messing up your wall thickness as much. Obviously if you can do it faster with a tool, then do that, I just often find the small detail stuff is faster to sand out than trying do another scraping pass.

Re: Sanding epiphany

#10

Re: Sanding epiphany

Texian

>Yeah, I always start sanding with 600 or 800 paper. Only takes about two months to sand each bowl.

Re: Sanding epiphany

#11

yes!

Rick Davenport

>Sandpaper is just another cutting tool; just more subtle.

Re: Sanding epiphany

#12

LOL

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>

Re: Sanding epiphany

#13

Shaping vs. sanding

wilbur

>Can you help me understand what shaping is as opposed to removing surface imperfections? The issues I have with tool marks is not in the overall shape of the bowl, inside or outside, but in little shallow grooves that I can feel with my hand but are hard to see by eye, even with raking light. This is what I'm taking out with the coarse grit sandpaper.

I'm pretty comfortable with my ability to sharpen and hone turning tools, but at this point of making my bowl, these grooves seem to be shallow enough that I can't clear them out with a finishing pass with a gouge without thinning out my bowl wall more than I want to. I could use a scraper, but the walls of my bowls tend to be pretty thin, and sanding seems to be just as easy for this purpose without the vibration issues I get with a scraper due to the thinness of the wall of the bowl.

Re: Sanding epiphany

#14

Re: It's a matter of personal choice

Russ Fairfield

>Just as what grit we start with, whether we sand fast or slow is a matter of personal choice and technique. Do whatever works best for you, and don't pay any attention to what others say is the "only way" to do it. The end result is what matters, not the path we took to get there.

The real problem is heat. Heat destroys sanding discs and mandrels, melts that adhesive from sandpaper, case hardens the wood surface, and in the worst case heat can cause surface checking in the wood.

If we can sand at high speeds without generating too much heat, so much the better, and we can get it done faster. Most people can't. I always recommend slowing down because that solves most peoples sanding problems that are the result of the heat from their sanding too fast.

Most sanding scratches in the final finish are left over from the coarsest grit we used. It doesn't matter whether we start at 60 or 150 grit, if we don't get all of the coarser scratches out with the next finer grit, they will still be there after we finish with the 600; and they will be more visible than ever. The hardest thing to do is to go back and start over when we see those scratches appear; but that is the only thing we can do if we want to get rid of them. If we don't want to start over, we will have to learn to live with sanding scratches.

Re: Sanding epiphany

#15

Re: Shaping vs. sanding

Russ Fairfield

>My definition of "shaping" is refining the form to remove that hump, hollow, or flat spot in the curve that we can feel, but often can't see, because it is only a few 1/1000ths of an inch difference. It is also removing the wave pattern we can both see and feel in the bottom of a platter or shallow bowl.

Whether we use the turning tool or sandpaper depends on the magnitude of the imprefection in the curve of the form, the thickness of the wood, and our skills with the tools.

Re: Sanding epiphany

#16

Ditto Russ' definition of shaping

Carole Valentine

>

Re: Sanding epiphany

#17

Excellent conclusion, Russ

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>A really superb summation of practical advice non a topic that can stir endless debate.

Re: Sanding epiphany

#18

Burned Fingers..........

Barry Turner

>Try using a non-woven sanding pad between your fingers and your sandpaper..........it's a good insulator and helps to even out the pressure of your fingers on the sandpaper.

Re: Sanding epiphany

#19

Re: Shaping????

Barry Turner

>I agree. I think we are talking 60-grit gouge here.

Re: Sanding epiphany

#20

Wonderful summation, Russ

Bill Neddow

>