Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

Posts

Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#1

Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Why do we call the newer abrasives "ceramic" when all abrasives are ceramic? Ceramic is defined as: "an inorganic, non-metallic solid prepared by the action of heat and subsequent cooling." God gave us the natural abrasives: sand, flint, garnet, diamond, and corundum (ruby, sapphire, or aluminum oxide). We have added silicon carbide-coke and silica sand heated together; alumina from heated bauxite ore; zirconium oxides, boron nitride, and many others. These are all made with fire, reaction, and cooling!

I asked Bruce Hoover this question at Turning Southern Style, and he had no answer. When people say that, "I use ceramic paper". All that they have really informed us is that they sanded.

I drank a "Coke" today. But was it really a Pepsi or a Diet Rite?

This is really not a big thing, I just want this industry/hobby to clean up its language a little. Maybe we could say the "new ceramic".

Bill in WNC mountains

who worked in a ceramic plant for 20 years


Definition

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#2

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"?

john lucas

>Bill Every time I go to lunch with my French friend he tell the waitress, "he'll have a coke" knowing that I call everything carbonated a "coke"

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#3

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"?

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>Good question, Bill. Sandpaper companies (all of them) are less than forthcoming with information and I have had a terrible time even trying to find out what materials some of the sandpapers are made from -- let alone how they compare. Of course, they all say that whatever they have is "the best". Hope somebody has some answers.

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#4

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"?

wilbur

>Not to nitpick, but Merriam-Webster defines ceramic a little differently:

"of or relating to the manufacture of any product (as earthenware, porcelain, or brick) made essentially from a nonmetallic mineral (as clay) by firing at a high temperature ; also : of or relating to such a product"

The key difference between the Merriam-Webster definition and your Wikipedia entry is the phrase "made essentially from a nonmetallic mineral (as clay). Otherwise, metals and metallic compounds, including aluminum oxide, would be defined as ceramics, when clearly they are not.

Beware Wikipedia! :@)

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#5

Steve Kubien

Because "Eddie" just doesn't make sense.

Steve Kubien

>Sorry, couldn't resist.

Oh and BTW, I wouldn't trust wikipedia for much. Remember, it is us non-edumacated folks that make it the reality it has become. My older brother is a professor of botany out east and he actually refuses to mark anything which sights wikipedia as a reference. But then again, at 39 he is already an old crumudgeon (sp).

Steve

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#6

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"?

Carole Valentine

>Good question Bill. From what I can find the term "ceramic" is more to distinguish between lower grades of aluminum oxide paper than anything else.

"Ceramic abrasives typically consist of aluminum oxide with or without additional modifiers produced using a sol-gel and sintering process. The ceramic processing route results in a hard, dense abrasive with an extremely fine crystal size and outstanding grinding performance on a variety of workpiece materials. Norton SG� and Norton Quantum� are examples of ceramic alumina grain manufactured by the Saint-Gobain Group. The patented alumina seeding process used in manufacturing Norton SG� abrasive grain produces a sub-micron crystal structure resulting in superior performance.

Sol-gel aluminum oxide is produced in using chemical ceramic technology, but this abrasive has very high performance and is usually referred to as Ceramic abrasive grain to distinguish the grain from lower-performing fused aluminum oxide."

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#7

Thanks Carole

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Your are a person with real information.

Wilbur: You confuse me with your answer. I used wiki because it was the easiest to get to. All the dictionaries define ceramic basically the same. All red clay (worldwide) containes aluminum. Bauxite, a rock, contains AL in a much higher % and is the current favorite source. The "CERAMIC" abrasives contain aluminum oxide with usually zirconiom oxide added. Therefore since this mixture is metallic, it can not be a ceramic, by your definition. Silicon carbide is made from coke(heated coal) and sand, which are both minerals and non-metallic.

All that I was really trying to say was: Ceramic is NOT a special term. The manufacturers should have used something more special or propriatary.

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#8

Re: Which would just confuse

Donna Banfield

>the heck out of one of my dogs, whose name is Eddie. :^)

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#9

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"?

Jeff Willaford

>Maybe 'Ceramic' is an abrasives industry term for 'new and improved'. Simply a label that distinguishes the most recent products from the others on the market.

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#10

Re: Thanks Carole

wilbur

>Hi Bill,

I think we are thinking along the same lines for the most part. I agree that the use of the term "ceramic" to describe abrasives is probably not the best use of the term.

After doing some more reading, I stand corrected in that aluminum oxide, zirconiom oxide, and silicon carbide are defined as ceramics. This was a surprise to me, and a bit embarrassing as I was a chemistry major at one point in my life, although it's been a long time since I have used that knowledge directly.

I had thought that ceramics were typically more complex materials, such as in pottery and china, and that the term would not be used in reference to crystals of Al2O3. Clearly, I was wrong on that point.

The other line of thinking that I had was that incorporation of such compounds into another substance might not automatically transform that substance into a ceramic. For example, tool steel contains carbides, which are ceramics, but tool steel is still considered metallic. Conversely, colored ceramics and glass often contain metal compounds that provide the color, but those are not considered to be metals.

My guess is that the issue of describing what is in sandpaper is similar to the issue of trying to figure out what is in finishes. The finishing companies seem to go out of their way to not tell us what is actually in their products. The term "Danish Oil" seems to describe oil-varnish blends, or thinned varnish. This puts us in the dark as to what we are buying, and makes it more difficult to know what product truly may advantageous for our particular needs.

Anyway, you learn something new everyday. And, yes, the manufacturers should stop using "ceramic" in describing sandpaper.

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#11

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"?

mike in vt

>More likely it's just a marketing ploy. I have been happy with Vince's discs, but have to say that Bill and others have me interested in trying some of the newer products.

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#12

Re: Amen Wilbur!

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>I personally think of "ceramics" as more of a process than what are the actual ingrediants. I think that this will explain some of my original comments. This has been an interesting thread. Too bad that Norton and others will probably never see it.

Bill

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#13

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"?

Barry Elder

>It's called "marketing". Any time you see or hear a new "catchphrase" be leary! They are there to separate you from your money.

Re: Why do we call abrasives "ceramic"? *LINK*

#14

Process or Better yet, Performance

RJ

>Yes, the processing is as important as the chemical composition. As a chemical engineer, we were concerned about the process as much as the chemistry. You can get the chemical composition to an extent from the MSDS, but it is not any more helpful for coated abrasives than it is for finishes. The processing along with the composition determine the performance.

Performance is the key to choosing abrasives. Performance, and value, are in the eye of the beholder. We offer a variety of coated abrasive products so you can choose which ones to use. When you find your favorite product, you will know it and have enough experience with it to use it well in your workshop.