>Since you asked for what I really thought, I think that the scale is off in both the finial and the ovrall piece. The finial is far too large and heavy for the form under it and the elements of the finial are also out of scale with each other.
I'd recommend working on getting a picture of some finialed vessels and studying the proportion between the lid and the finial, and the elements in the finial in relation to each other. In simple terms, it's just beads and coves on a spindle, but the reality is that the design is much more important than the turning...
The mulberry is very pretty. Visualize a finial with the red section gone (which will make it shorter), and a "bulb" about 2/3 that diameter. Assume the lid/finial is not glued in place, so you could try a couple other variations and see what you think. Our first finials tend to be a bit "stocky", and we must try for slimmer and more delicate appearance. One of my early "monster" finials was decently shaped but completely overpowered the piece it was on. Made a new one for that piece, and later found a big ole HF in inventory that was the right size for that monster. Try simple design, delicate look. You can get there from here.
>Thank you, Dick and Tex. I obviously have a lot of design theory to study [anyone know where it is]. Still, I gain a considerable amount of knowledge, and personal ideas, from these generous critiques, and I thank you all for taking the time to offer them. I can see that gluing the finial in place so soon was not prudent, but I reckon that it could be removed�carefully.
>Finials are a bit trickier than they first appear.
One of the things you'll notice with Cindy Drozda's finials - and she's the best at it in my opinion - is crispness where you want crispness and smooth flowing curves where you want smooth and flowing. What popped out at me first was that any crispness that you might have tried to turn got sanded to smooth and flowing curves - where there shouldn't be smooth flowing curves.
The second thing that popped out was the abrubt transitions at the interfaces of the three parts - emphasizing that these are three parts stuck together rather than an integrated whole. The orange (padouk?) ring seems like something thrown in because you had a piece you could use.
If you're golng to put a ball on the top of a finial - make it round - or oval with the long axis vertical.
And if you're going to taper the finial, don't leave any straight sides - curve things - subtly.
I tweeked your photo in PhotoShop to refelct the type of changes I think would work better.
>Finials are like fashion models they can't be to tall or to thin. Well actualy they can be to thin and to tall but if you work toward that extreme you will discover where those limits are.
Just keep making thinner and longer finials. At some point you are going to say "that doesn't look quite right". Make the next one even longer and thinner. You should say "that, definetly is not right".
>PhotoShop, or any of the other digital image manipulation software, combined with a digital camera, can be a great design tool, especially for folks who can't draw very well. It's the Word Processor of 2D images, allowing variations and changes to be made quickly and relatively easily.
It also can be used to analyze turnings you like, but can't identify why. If you want to look at just the form you can change a color image to black and white and even adjust the image so you can focus on the shape and proportions without the distractions of grain and color. Using "guides", you can measure and calculate proportions - height to width, where curve transitions occur relative to the base or top of the piece, etc..
It's a great tool for developing "an eye" for nice shapes and forms - and identify WHY and HOW.
>Rick's nailed it. Turn a bunch, tweeking and doing variations. Chuck up a 1/2 or 3/4" dowel and start from the free end and work back to the chuck. In an hour you'll start working out which tool works for you and how to use it. Then it's just practice and variations.
I think one of the reasons some folks have trouble with finials is that they jumped into turning bowls and boxes and ring holders etc. - before they'd played with between centers spindle turning. First you learn to walk - then to run and dance.
>Most finals look thin when they are laying on their side on the lathe. It's when you get ready to mount them on the bottom part of your turning that they all turn into tree stumps.
I can't tell you haw many I have had to do over because they looked more like RoseAnn Bar then Twigie.
>is a book on Golden Proportion, or Phi. It describes how the ratio of 1:1.6 is found throughout nature and somewhat in tune with human proportion. If you google the subject, you'll start to get a "free" read of what material might be out there, and you can pick a book on your own.
There are too many to count...and too many ways to "spin it". My book ties into nature and theology. Others into art and design. Some art more mathematical. Find your own way of relating to the subject, and build your library from there.
>It's funny how a turning will look so different when horizontal on the lathe, then vertical in use. A digital camera can help. Shoot on the lathe, rotate the image to vert. and adjust as necessary.
A digital camera can be quite a useful design tool.
>Hi Dick, One trick is to use the hollow form as a jam-chuck to finish up the finial. That way, you see exactly how it will appear, then finish the base of the hollow form.
>Thanks very much to all of you fine, considerate folks for offering up such a large amount of data, thoughts, ideas, and opinions. Now I need to study it all, and plunge into more practice sessions. The thought of horizontal versus vertical in relation to visual perception is very true.
I guess the key to a good finial is to be petite cause you can make small shapely and detailed finials. Since I am chubby she must have thought the best I could do was plump and well rounded finials. So far she is right!
I could not get her to stop turning long enough for a good picture but then I had no gift to make her smile!
Cindy turned those detailed finials under poor light and while answering dumb questions. Tool control was something else to watch.
Watching her sand, wax and buff them was even more impressive. Commented many good finials are ruined by sanding off crisp details.