Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

NEW DESIGN BOWL

Posts

NEW DESIGN BOWL

#1

NEW DESIGN BOWL

Carl Barton

>This has to be one of my worst bowls I have turned out. But I wanted to show you what I have done and the new design.

The feature ring is from the Stockbridge-Munson branch of the Mohican tribe of which my wife is a member of. The symbol is known as "Many Trails". It represents the tribes movement from the Stockbridge, Mass across the country to WI. This was the result of the tribe having to relocate several times before the trail stopped in WI, much like the "Trail of Tears" of the Cherokee Nation but lesser known.

While on vacation to WI last month I spent most of my time sick and had allot of time to think and I decided to try and give this design a try when I got home.

I know that this bowl is a VERY poor begining to the design as many of the joints are not tight and not everything lines up. I was going to throw this ring out but my wife said to continue on so I can figure out all the flaws and that way I could do the next one better, how wise she is.

After about a week and half, allot of frustration I finshed this up this afternoon. The feature ring has 161 peices, but I now have a detailed set of instructions to go by and I am hopful the next project with this design will go much better.

Since this is a native design I will be given these away to my wife's family and the American Legion located on the Reservation so they might be able to do good with it for charity events.

Let me know what you think of the design. Of course I know the many flaws in this one, but feel free to comment. I am sure I will learn more if you point any and all the flaws


img

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#2

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

matt overton

>I like the design alot, but I love the story. Can't wait to see the next generation.

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#3

Steve Kubien

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

Steve Kubien

>I too like the design/concept. The story is great and if this series is to go to charity events, I would prepare a simple booklet with as much information about this migration as you can. It would really help boost the price.

Yup, your wife was right. Work out the flaws and learn for next time.

Great effort.

Steve

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#4

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

Texian

>Ditto what Matt and Steve said. An excellent design (and not an easy one) for a worthy cause. Best I can tell, you are a gentleman and a scholar. Press on, and good luck in this endeavor.

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#5

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

John Scheideman

>Nice bowl and nice story! This was not an easy feature ring to build. You did a great job. My suggestion would be to cut the height of the feature ring down a little on your next one. To me, it is a little tall for the shape of the bowl. You didn't mention the dimensions of the bowl but if the overall bowl is about 8-9" tall I would try to make the feature ring about 2-2 1/2" tall. Then I would place it slightly above center. I think that would help the overall proportion of the bowl. I find that when I make feature rings in excess of 2 2/2" tall they always seem out of proportion. Just my opinion.....take it for what it is worth! I hope that helps.

John

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#6

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

John Scheideman

>That should read "in excess of 2 1/2" tall" in my response. I'm sure the typo was confusing!

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#7

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

Carl Barton

>Steve,

That is a very intresting idea for the booklet. Thank you, I will keep that in that back of my head.

Carl

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#8

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

Carl Barton

>LAUGHING........ Gentelman and scholar. :) Well as I use to say while I was in the Navy for 33 years, " I am not a gentleman, my parents were married and I work for a living." It is an old joke meant, as an enlisted man I use to use when ever someone called me that of SIR. But now that I have a few miles on me it does not seem to fit. As far as the giving the bowl for charity, it just does not seem right to take advantage of someone or a group of folks when there is so much meaning in a symbol. I have always had a deep feel for Native Americans and feel it is just not to profit on something like this.

Carl

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#9

DEMINTIONS

Carl Barton

>John,

Yup I did fail to mention the size of the bowl. The feature ring is 2 3/4, a little biggier than normal. If you look at the center "bulleyes" of the symbol you will notice that there are FOUR segments alone. I started out with 3/4, 5/8, 1/2, then 3/8 forstner bits and plug cutters just to get the effect of the orignal symbol. I do not think I can go any smaller to get the effect of the symbol. I need at least four types of bits to get this effect, and I have not seen anything smaller than a 3/8's bits.

I wanted to have a larger bowl than what I ened up with, 6-1/2 dia by 5-1/2 tall. But once I cut the feature ring down it was not feasable. You are correct, the size of the feature ring does not really match the size, shape of the bowl. I had another ring at the top, but I got carried away and cut off too much and lost that ring. I was going for a vase shape but.... the best laid plans of mice and men......

Thank you for your comments they will be with me for the next round. By the way I am already working on that one. I am sure it will take me several more tried before I get it right.

Carl

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#10

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

john lucas

>Carl You've got a great feature ring idea and a great story. Why stop there. See if there's a way to somehow tell the story along with the feature ring. Could you add details to the rest of the piece. I'm not sure exactly how, perhaps a trail, maybe some other small details along the trail. It doesn't all have to be about the feature ring. Your trying to communicate.

Why not try another shape? I think a bowl shape with the feature ring being the whole side. Maybe a platter with the feature being the outer 1/3. Then you could add the story details to the inside of the platter. How about making it a wall hanging so you have more design possibilities than you would with a platter.

I'm just throwing this out there because you obviously have the wood working skills. By limiting yourself to the traditional vessel shape your running with one leg tied to the other. Let go, have fun, experiment.

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#11

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

Carl Barton

>John,

WOW, I never thought about the possibilties. Now that I think about, maybe a wall panel showing the trail the tribe took. That would be allot of work and I am not sure I have the skills for something like that, but heck I am retired and have time on my hand.

One other design element I want to put into this is a turtle. This is the animal symbol for this branch of the tribe.

Thank you for saying I have the skills, but really I have only been turning for about two years now, and only segemented stuff for about six months now. I spent allot of time reading on the subject before I started actual work.

Thank you for the ideas, it does give me food for thought.

Carl

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#12

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Carl,

You have something good in there, get help and make that small brochure of the trials and tribulations of the Mohican people. Spreading that knowledge is good, and there is nothing wrong with charging some for your time and materials.

Keep up the good work

Jorge

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#13

Bob Moffett

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

Bob Moffett

>I don't see all of those flaws you are talking about. I see an exquisite piece of work with a tremendous amount of detail.

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#14

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

Carl Barton

>Bob,

You are too kind, thank you. The picture does not show my many mistakes. But as the ole saying goes, the wife loves it, so does her sister and my mother in law. So I guess I am not doing too bad. But I know I can do much better. I spent way to much time trying to get the design right I failed to follow the basic rules of segmented turning, getting the joints clean and tight.

Carl

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#15

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

Carl Barton

>Jorge,

I was talking to my wife this morning. The museum on the reservation has a small booklet that tells the entire journey of the tribe. We will be going back to WI at the end of the month for a Pow-Wow, so I am going to pick one up. That way I might get more inspriation for the design.

By the way, I sent the picture to my sister in law and mother in law and they both loved it. So I am thinking my MIL who does allot with the tribe will be showing it around. She already has a number of my herringbone pattern bowls and cutting boards and many folks loved those as well.

Carl

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#16

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

Texian

>Carl, That will all improve with practice. With segmenting one sometimes must try to stay focused on four things at the same time, so it is easy for one thing to slip through (or become) a crack. You can get there from here.

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

#17

Re: NEW DESIGN BOWL

Mike Nelson

>The only thing I see wrong is the blue background ;)