Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

Posts

How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

#1

How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

charlie belden

>I'm almost finished with The Biological Imperative piece and I'm into it for about $40 in parts and probably around 15 hours of actual time on the piece - including the scale drawings, time spent rounding up the electrical and mechanical parts, finishes etc.. The Bot Sugar Bowl was half that in dollars and at least twice that in time.

And I'm remembering a time, not long ago, when a turning project was out of free wood - and seldom took over an hour or two.

Now I've seen pieces in magazines and on web sites that took 200 or more hours. And some require thousands in special special tools and finish applicators, to say nothing of finishes that

cost a relative fortune given the amount used and their shelf lives.

So my question to those who've also lost their mind and spent a significant chunk of time and money in order to execute a concept they had - IS THERE A LIMIT TO THIS "CONCEPT THING" OBSESSION? What was the max. time and money project you've done - how much & how long?

Re: How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

#2

Re: How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

john lucas

>If you look at it from a purely artist attitude, it is the final results that count. Now what it's made from, how it's made, how much time it takes or how much money.

My Cardiac lamp took over 20 hours, cost was minimal except for making the aluminum rings and finding the touch sensor for the lamp. I don't know how much time I spend planning the project.

Most of my "art" projects I don't even count the time. You just keep plugging away until it's done. It's kind of like when I used to go in the darkroom after dinner and it would be daylight when I came out. When your having fun you just don't stop and think.

Now how much time is a problem I have. I have 3 projects that I made notes on, I would say 3 years ago at least. For various reasons I haven't finished those up. Hopefully not too long. I have found the materials and or learned the techniques to produce the work so now it's just finding the time.

Then how to you account for things like buying a metal lathe/mill and all the accessories. In my mind it would allow me to make this and that and therefore help create some imaginary conceptual piece in the future. Of course we all know that's just an excuse to buy a new tool.

Re: How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

#3

Steven Antonucci

I am willing to go as far as needed...

steve antonucci

>maybe even further?

I don't count hours on a project. I don't need to account for the time to be recovered in a "sale" or other form of remuneration. I do it for fun, much like hiking. The reward is in the doing...

S

Re: How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

#4

Steve Kubien

Not terribly far

Steve Kubien

>I gotta be honest. I have started many projects, round and flat, that I had one or two things I wanted to try. I've gotten through those steps and I lose interest.

I once started a blanket box. It was to be made 100% by hand tools. I wanted to take my boards from rough, flatten them, joint them, make the panels, resurface them and dovetail them together. I got that far. Never got the rebate for the bottom done. Never fitted the lid. I still have the parts too. The front and back panels were made into tool-hanging panels via french cleats. The top and bottom are still awaiting the same fate. -sigh- Oh well, it wass a wedding gift for my brother and he divorced less than a year later.

Now, I am working on a tribute piece right now. All I am waiting for it the finish to dry (plus another coat or two), buff and photograph. I've probably got 6 hours in this bowl. It's not huge but it is my first carved/textured piece and my first involving gesso (gee, which lady do you think I had in mind when I started this?). Now, it I had only added some burning.... Pics to follow....

Steve Kubien

Re: How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

#5

Re: How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

Texian

>Maybe 150 work hours on some segmented pieces, but very little money (none available to spend). One eventually finds that most of the fun of segmenting is in the design and planning, how to get there from here with the available resources. Much of the actual construction is simply repetitive and tedious, and/but it is driven to completion by the vision of the completed piece.

Re: How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

#6

Depends on what its worth to you

Fog Tanner

>Depends on what it is worth to you. If it is worth it then the time is of no consequence, you do what ever it takes. If it is not worth it, then you should never start as it is doomed to failure before it started. It is about commitment, desire, and working until the project is completed. Which is basicly "how bad do you want it". Even if the end result is disaster, at least it was followed through to completion.

The Mona Lisa was being worked on until Da Vinci's death. He was looking for that perfect painting and spent years on it. So what was it worth to him, a lifetime of searching and work. A project may take years to complete, but if it was worth starting counting the time is meaninless - it takes whatever it takes. "It will be finished when I am done" as I was told growing up and asking how long it would take for something.

After spending a large amount in racing over the years, I tend to disregard the money involved. You can't go racing and say you will only spend x amount, and expect to be more than a pack filler. If you want it bad enough you will spend what ever it takes. You find that the money outlay is small in comparison to the time you put in. The money is cheap, you can always get some more - but time is a different story.

When you are young, the whole road is before you - there is energy for everything. As age takes its toll and the road grows shorter, we tend to pick those near and dear projects that we have a passion for in what we have left. The desire is still there to do the 10 things at once, its just the body and clock that have given up the ghost. So it is better to leave this rock with one thing completed, than 10 that were started and never finished....looks better in the obits.

Fog

Re: How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

#7

Ellis Walentine

Fine art and design

Ellis Walentine

>I distinguish between an artistic idea and a design, which, to me, is a solution to a specific design "problem." In my mind, designs usually have a practical intent and must be completed on time and on a predictable budget.

Artistic pieces have different constraints, depending on the artist's needs and ambitions. If the work is an investigation of a new idiom or technique, the time invested might be written off as a development cost, in hopes of being reimbursed by sales of future pieces based on the development work. I suspect that some artists are willing to invest unlimited time and expense into one-off pieces, but at some point everyone reaches the limit of what they can afford to invest.

I think there is a corollary here that has to do with the elegance of an idea. A naturally successful piece succeeds because it looks good, functions well (if that is an objective), and can be made at a sustainable rate by the artist/craftsman.

I think this is a legitimate departure point for a discussion of art and design efficiencies.

Ellis

Re: How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

#8

Re: Fine art and design

Texian

>Should have included working on the "artistic idea" in the "fun" part. For me the idea and the design are parts of the same activity.

Re: How Far Are YOU Willing To Go With An Idea

#9

220 221 Whatever it takes

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>