Private turning lessons 4. TOPICS/SKILLS
Ed Moore in SW VA
>WHAT SKILLS would you most want to learn in a private lesson?
Ed
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Private turning lessons 4. TOPICS/SKILLS
Ed Moore in SW VA
>WHAT SKILLS would you most want to learn in a private lesson?
Ed
Only the basics-
steve antonucci
>I think it's really hard to teach anything but "basic" skills- cutting, sharpening, hollowing...
As far as "project" lessons go, it makes no sense to me to take a class to learn how to make a bowl WITH THE GOAL BEING TO MAKE A BOWL. I'd rather know more about how to make the bowl than make the bowl, if that makes sense...?
Steve
Re: Private turning lessons 4. TOPICS/SKILLS
Mike Stafford
>I guess I broached this subject when I responded to your first question.
I suppose what you teach will be based upon what the student requests and needs. As the student progresses an assessment of skill can be made and the lessons modified accordingly.
If they want to learn basics then basics is what you teach. If they want to learn to turn hollow forms and have never turned before an instructor will have to be up front and explain that the student is not ready to broach that subject without basic skills and some turning experience.
Re: Private turning lessons 4. TOPICS/SKILLS
Cyril Griesbach
>Both Steve and Mike have addressed the beginner angle on this one and maybe that's what you're looking for. A good instructor has to first evaluate the student(s)for their skill level and expectations. Then he must deal with the realities of the situation.
In my case if I wanted to learn a new skill or technique I would seek someone that specializes in that skill/technique. For example, if I want to learn to turn off center spindle and/or face plate work I would seek someone who does that as the body of his/her work. If it were painting, piercing, carving then there are those who would be best for that but they would not necessarily be the same instructors.
Re: Only the basics-
Mike Peace
>Sharpening is essential. As we all know, if you cannot sharpen you cannot turn.
Re: Only the basics-
robo hippy
>I think you have to be able to adapt to the needs of the individual turners. From total rookie to seasoned turner who wants to see how some one else turns. Not always easy. Or you could specify skill levels or instructors consent.
It is easier with a demo that with a class. If you haven't covered some thing, some one will ask.
robo hippy
Re: Private turning lessons 4. TOPICS/SKILLS
Fog Tanner
>I would want to learn those things which I can't already do. Along with that would be those areas where I could improve. For me this would be some use of a tool which I haven't used, and basicly new knowledge. If in the process, I find that I have been doing something wrong, then that is still learning about something I didn't already know.
These days I am more selective on the classes I take. The first criteria is whether I am knowledgable on the subject matter, and it has to fall into the not known area.
Fog
Re: Private turning lessons 4. TOPICS/SKILLS
john lucas
>Private lessons are probably better than group lessons because you can gear the class to exactly what the student needs. Obviously sharpening, safely mounting work and discussion of lathe speeds, and then how each tool works and what it's used for.
I think a serious discussion about the safety of the wood itself. I know most beginners will try to use wood that has check, defects, or other problems than can be dangerous. I try to suggest using the best wood you can for learning.
Harvesting and gather wood should be included unless they are there to learn segmented or spindle turning and even then you might discuss drying wood.
Re: Private turning lessons 4. TOPICS/SKILLS
Tony - Memphis
>I'm with Steve - I need to learn basics. I'm probably a good example for you as I have never had any formal turning lessons and it shows! I am primarily a spindle turner (for furniture projects), but the basics apply to all. Something I would suggest is to give your student a list of things to try before they come to class. I think that helps know what questions to ask. I have taken several ww classes and I would get a lot more out of them if I could take them again, now that I have tried a lot of the techniques covered. For example, cabriole legs. Learning the technique to cut one is pretty straightforward, but learning how to clean it up, turn the foot, make the knee/post intersection crisp are things you learn in class. I guess details is what I'm trying to say here.
I can hack out some things, but I'm still not a confident turner. I'd like for someone who is to work with me to learn what I am doing wrong. I'd like to learn how to cut coves, beads, etc., face turning for rosettes and such, and a bowl turning techniques to make pedestals and the like. One big thing that has helped me via DVD's is when the instructor shows the mistakes and explains why/how. Then I know why my gouge travels backwards when I try to cut a cove and why my skew cuts really nice spirals. What's the relationhip to turning speed, tool rest height, etc. etc. People like me tend to use a lot of sandpaper! I get something close enough that I'm afraid to mess it up, so I sand it the rest of the way. Tool grinds, angles, how to sharpen, WHEN to sharpen, etc. I'm thinking out loud here....
Well, there are a few things from my perspective (a rookie furniture maker who turns a few legs, finials, etc.). Not sure it will help as we all have unique needs.
Tony