>I would like to start a couple threads about private turning lessons. This thread is aimed at WHAT you expect from an instructor if you get private instruction from them. This should also include small group instruction. Please offer your opinions.
>I would want to take a lesson from someone who knew substantially more about turning than I do. I would also expect that the person was not only a capable turner, but also a capable teacher. The two are not necessarily always joined at the hip.
>Ed, I would expect a private instructor to teach me how to turn, how to use the tools effectively, how to use the tools safely, how to sharpen the tools, how to know when the tools needed sharpening, how to use alternative tools (not just the ones the instructor favors).
The first order of business would be safety including the lathe, tools, grinders, band saws, dust and finishing. Each of these subjects could be discussed at the appropriate time.
I hope the instructor would teach me about the equipment e.g. the lathe, chucks, live centers, drive centers, screw chucks and face plates.
I think it is important to address wood preparation and selection. Wood allergies must be discussed. The difference between dry and wet wood and how best to use the two certainly must be discussed..
I would hope that the teacher would guide me through repetitive exercises that enabled me to turn some simple projects that I could take home to the spouse. I think if all you do is practice rolling beads, cutting coves etc. with no project is sight people can get bored. It has to be interesting.
Sanding and finishing are important parts of the curriculum also. After all the goal here is for the student to be able to end up with finished products.
Teaching all of this in a professional and useful way also depends on the amount of time you have with the student.
>Ed, some time ago my wife expressed an interest in learning to turn. I was delighted and began showing her how to turn a bowl. Wrong approach. I didn't even ask if she was interested in turning bowls. She said she wanted to start by turning pens. Well she liked pen turning but having RA in her hands kept her from spending much time at the lathe. Intimidated by my PM3520 I bought her a Jet VS Mini which she really likes. Now, I have much experience as an instructor but husbands teaching wives simply ain't the best way to go so I got her to ask a friend from our club for help. Now Rob has the skills of a master and the patience of Job as well as being detail oriented and somewhat fussy so the two personalities meshed like smooth fitting gears. He started her with simple spindle exercises and gave her something akin to homework when he left. As time permitted they had a weekly two hour session with a "work on this and show me what you did next week" at the end of the lesson. Each weeks lesson reviewed the previous lesson and introduced new skills. I stayed out of the way till the end of the lessons and offered my opinions only when asked and while we worked together in the shop often I waited till she asked for help or an explanation.
Before long Rob introduced bowl turning and soon Carol turned a very nice bowl that was well received by the person who conducts our club's gallery.
This may not answer your question directly but it's what has worked for Carol. Oh, and now I have to deal with "honey can you get me this tool? I think I want to have one of these...and how about a..."
>I "re-educated" my wife's cousin a while back. He visited us one Thanksgiving.
He selected the project, I helped him select the wood. He ended up catching the bug big time.
Personally I prefer semi-private for myself. If the instructor has his or her own projects to work on (or other students in a small class - say 4 people max), that works well for me. I can apply what the instructor teaches.