Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Seeing Very Subtle Curves In Shiny Objects

Posts

Seeing Very Subtle Curves In Shiny Objects

#1

Brad Vietje

Seeing Very Subtle Curves In Shiny Objects

Brad Vietje

>Hi All,

I wasn't quick enough to respond to John's post about seeing very slight curves in turned work after finishing, so I'll start a new thread. At last -- something I have some expertise in!

I've spent many years making reflector telescopes, and teaching the sport to others. This involves grinding very subtle and very precise curves in glass or ceramic discs, and evaluating the curves with light reflections. Techie stuff aside, this involves lots and lots of measuring extremely subtle curves in shiny objects -- where a telescope's objective mirror has a lot in common with a gloss finish on wood. Its purely coincidental that John was talking about mirrors -- the turning could be bowls or buttons just as well.

With a little practice, we can learn a lot about a surface by bouncing light off it. Curves in the reflection, as well as thickness of reflected lines, and light and dark areas in the reflection of a uniformly shaded object (or of reflected light itself) can reveal features too small to be seen or felt otherwise. Simple optical tests can reveal flaws of a few millionths of an inch, a few nanometers, or a few dozen Angstroms.

In the mirror photo John posted, there appears to be a slight dip at the center, but a little more going on there. It looks to me like there are two small darker areas, so probably two small dips, or even a slight depressed ring, like a moat, surrounding a central hill. I'd have to tip the piece and watch how the reflection moved about, or know better where the light was coming from to tell for sure. In this sort of photo, a flat surface would be evenly shiny all over if the tilt was correct. That means that a wider reflection is flatter, while a narrow band of light is more curved. Thus, a relatively flat round area at center, and if you want to chase down really subtle details, you can look at the width of the reflection from center to edge to see any other curves.

Part of the problem is good lighting. Most turners strive for bright, even shop lighting so they can really see what they're doing. That's usually a good thing, but sometimes really lousy, uni-directional light is more useful for seeing subtle curves. For anyone trying to achieve subtle, even curves, you might consider turning off all lights except a single, un-frosted bulb, and moving it about so you can see subtle curves and scratches that would otherwise escape detection -- until the gloss finish is applied. The lower the angle of the illumination, the larger the flaws or ripples appear, like shadows at sunrise or sunset. The sharper the transition from light to dark, the larger the surface feature.

I'll post two ideas for seeing these issues more easily in a moment.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


img

Re: Seeing Very Subtle Curves In Shiny Objects

#2

Ellis Walentine

Oblique lighting

Ellis Walentine

>Good thread, Brad. Your insights are in line with my experience of the value of low oblique lighting for observing the true quality of a surface. The cheap way to do this is with a clip-on light of some description.

Ellis

Re: Seeing Very Subtle Curves In Shiny Objects

#3

Brad Vietje

Two Simple Methods

Brad Vietje

>Following up on the long blurb about reflections, one problem is using any sort of reflection while we're still in the fine sanding stage, so the wood surface is not very shiny yet. Sometimes we're finishing with something like a Danish oil, that allows us to use a little bit of the finishing oil while sanding, or rub in a little to create a more reflective surface before finishing the finishing, as it were... Here are two ideas for seeing these things before the finish is applied:

1. Scotch Tape Test. Applying clear (shiny) Scotch tape to a surface will make it shiny enough to see a lot of good detail in the reflected light. Unfortunately, you'll also get some tape residue, or "glue-gunk", so this won't work in all situations. However, for slight concave curves, you may be able to tell if there are humps or bumps, or flat areas or dips. It should be easy enough to get rid of the residue with a little more fine sanding.

2. Saran Wrap Test: For flats or convex surfaces, a tight wrap in cling film plastic wrap should be instructive, and may help you see slight imperfections in the desired curve. It works on glass, so why not on wood? I'll have to try this myself, but I'll bet it would reveal flaws most of the time. For slight dips, or low spots, the test may fail, as it could create a tight drum that looks perfectly flat, but unless a flat area is what you wanted, it should be an indicator of something amiss.

In optics, we also use the "Spit Test", which usually involves no actual spitting, but just spraying the surface with water to make it reflective. I'm betting that would not be helpful for most people sanding dry wood, though I often wet the wood to raise the grain.

Image shows a shape with a number of ring defects and a central hole. It's actually a telescope mirror that needs a lot of work, but shows the sort of defects we can see with reflected light, even in wood.

Have fun, and safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


img

Re: Seeing Very Subtle Curves In Shiny Objects

#4

Re: Two Simple Methods

Scott in Socal

>I often use mineral spirits to see fine scratches as well as to see what bare wood is going to look like with a "wet look" finish on it. It dries off in a matter of minutes and I've had no problems with finishing afterwards. The fumes are not healthy, so protect yourself.

Re: Seeing Very Subtle Curves In Shiny Objects

#5

Steven Antonucci

How do you make a mirror?

steve antonucci

>As a scope geek too, I quickly backed down from making mine and just bought it. I couldn't think of any accurate way to make a mirror of a light bucket...

I watched Harvey Fein use a router to get a perfect semi-circular section in wood, but how do you do it in glass?

S

Re: Seeing Very Subtle Curves In Shiny Objects

#6

Re: Two Simple Methods

Alex Yeilding

>I use alcohol for the same purpose. Faster drying, and I prefer the odor, although still try to avoid concentrated fumes.

Re: Seeing Very Subtle Curves In Shiny Objects

#7

Re: How do you make a mirror? *LINK*

Doc Green

>Search with "telescope mirror grinding" and you will find a ton of stuff re making telescope mirrors.


Mirror Grinding

Re: Seeing Very Subtle Curves In Shiny Objects

#8

Steven Antonucci

Thanks, I've googled it before

steve antonucci

>I was more interested in seeing Brad's method, knowing that he has access to a lathe. I just wondered if he'd ever taken the plunge and "turned" a mirror :-)

Steve

Re: Seeing Very Subtle Curves In Shiny Objects

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: How do you make a mirror? *LINK*

Brad Vietje

>Folks -- sorry I didn't respond sooner. For some reason that has to do with Fairpoint Communications, I can't post or reply from home anymore -- seems my ISP has gotten so slow that I can't get through.

Anyway -- check out the ATM Pages of the Stellafane web site for more info than you'll ever need to know. Interested parties can also contact me off-list if they prefer. Photo is me teaching our ATM class that runs each year from October through May.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


img

Stellafane Amateur Telescope Making Pages