Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

Posts

Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

#1

Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

Henry (Raleigh NC)

>I have been reading threads on NC WoodWorker.net about the Ci0 Easy Finisher (link below). This is a carbide insert cutting tool that at first glance looks to be a very usable tool, especially for a novice turner like myself. It ain't cheap (at $100 w/o handle, or about $135 for a kit), but that is the case for any bowl gouge I'd buy.

Given that I am also a novice sharpener, does this kind of tool make sense? It is appealing to me right now.

Is this something that I would 'grow out of' as I gain experience and hopefully develop more skill as a turner?

Does anyone have experience with this tool? How does it compare to something like the Sorby multi-tip tools? Once obvious difference is the square shaft on the Ci0 and the round one on the Sorby; as a novice I would think the square shaft would keep the cutting angle more consistent.

Thanks

Henry


Ci0 Easy finisher

Re: Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Carbide tip turning tools?

Keith Tompkins

>HI Henry,I have seen these tool is action, and they seem to work well. However, there is no substitute for learning to use spindle tools and bowl gouges. As a new turner, I recommend that you join a turning club, then find the best instructor you can afford. A few hours with a good turner is worth many times the initial cost. You can learn quickly what may take years to learn otherwise.

Re: Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

#3

Re: Carbide tip turning tools?

mike Nelson

>Couldn't agree more with Keith. For one thing people are charging way to much for these shafts with an inexpensive carbide disk screwed on the end. You can make your own for a fourth the price. Learning to use a gouge..and I have heard rumors of folks actually learning to use a skew.. and all the other traditional tools will make you a turner, won't be 'easy but once you get the hang of it you can start thinking of those special pieces. I do like the carbide for deep hollowing.

Re: Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

#4

Re: Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

Fred Holder

>Hello Henry,

I don't own the Ci0 tool as yet; however, while at the Desert Woodturning Rounup in Mesa Arizona in February, I purchased the Ci1 and Ci2 tools. I find them very useful for rough turning and expect that they would be easy for a beginner to learn to use. I use the Ci1 for a lot of roughing work. I am proficient with all of the other turning tools, even the skew, as I've been turning for 21 years and have turned virtually all sorts of things.

I did get to see the Ci0 tool work at the Utah Woodturning Symposium in the hands on/trade show area.

When I first got the Ci1, I turned a bowl with it from start to finish, except that for the final cut inside, I did use a bowl gouge. I tried it on spindle work and found that it would do most spindle cuts except coves. I also turned a goblet with it at 3000 rpm and it cut quite smooth at that speed. I had to use an Eliminator tool to turn the inside bottom of the goblet bowl. Here is where the Ci0 would have come in handy.

Whether you are an experienced turner or a beginner, I believe these tools are worth the money. They eliminate the need for sharpening often and are easy to use. They look like scrapers, but that is where the difference ends. They do not cut like a scraper.

I agree with others, joining a club if possible and getting some regular hands on woodturning training using the conventional tools is very good advise. However, these new carbide tools are a good buy and will allow you to do things that you may currently be having trouble doing.


More Woodturning Website

Re: Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

#5

Re: Carbide tip turning tools?

Steve Harder

>I really like the Ci0.

I purchased the Ci0 replacement insert and built my own tool holder out of 1/2" square steel - you just need to do a little grinding, drill a hole and tap for screw.

I find the round carbide insert to be a very forgiving tool for removing tool marks as I get ready to sand a turning.

I have practiced with a bowl gouge, and I can occasionally get very fine threads and a smooth cut, but the second cut usually isn't as good and I'm back where I started from. But the Ci0 cutter just snuggles up to that bowl and smooths everything out.

The Ci0 round cutter is now a tool that I would never give up.

Re: Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

#6

Mike Stafford

Re: Carbide tip turning tools?

Mike Stafford

>Henry, I have no experience with the Ci tools and therefore will not comment about them. The best advice given is to join a club and learn how to turn. Ultimately there is no substitute for learning how to use the tools of the trade. They were developed over many years and will perform many more jobs than any single purpose tool.

Join the Woodturning Guild of North Carolina which meets at the NC State Craft Center on the second Thursday of each month at 7 P.M. It will give you an opportunity to see many turning demonstrations, meet other turners in the area and establish contacts within the turning community in the area. There are a number of very fine instructors in the club.

If you can possibly swing it I would highly recommend a course in woodturning basics from Alan Leland who is a member of the club and teaches in his shop in Durham. He also teaches basic woodturning at Woodcraft and at John C. Campbell. You cannot go wrong with a great instructor. Properly learning to use the tools initially will help ensure your woodturning success.

Re: Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

#7

Re: Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

Don Evans

>Henry:

Here is a link to the club's web site that Mike is taken about.

Poke around and if you cannot get to names and numbers of officers email me and I will provide them to you.

I just realize that Mike is probably a member also, didn't put the name together with this sites Mike.

Don


NC Woodturners Guild

Re: Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

#8

Turner's Guild Question?

Henry (Raleigh NC)

>Thanks for the link. That looks great. I live with a few miles of NC State so the Craft Center location is about as convenient as it gets.

Am I correct in thinking that AAW membership is needed to join the NC Woodturning Guild? It is a good thing that they allowed a novice category or else I'd feel like I'd be in WAY over my head.

Henry

Re: Carbide tip turning tools? *LINK*

#9

Re: Turner's Guild Question?

Don Evans

>Just saw your message Henry.

Yes, AAW membership is required to join. You can just show up at a meeting though, find one of the officers and tell them you are interested in joining.

They will NOT mind at all that you aren't a member of either club or AAW yet. You'll be welcomed to stay and join in....

Alan Leland who you've read about here is also a member and very active so will probably be there, also look for Frank Penta who has been mentioned on this forum. You cannot meet nicer folks.

Don