Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

pecan too brittle?

Posts

pecan too brittle?

#1

pecan too brittle?

Thad

>I am struggling with successfully turning a goblet from pecan.

I've gotten bowls and a lidded box out of wood from this same tree, but wonder if pecan may be to brittle to handle intricacies of a goblet.

Any thoughts on this wood for this application?

~ Thad

Re: pecan too brittle?

#2

Re: pecan too brittle?

john lucas

>I don't remember Pecan being brittle at all however all I have turned from it were bowls. It was just slower cutting because it's hard but not any worse than locust and osage orange which I've turned a lot of.

Re: pecan too brittle?

#3

Re: pecan too brittle?

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca.

>These goblets are of pecan...just a small limb...but it did not seem brittle and did not move when turned directly with pith on the center axis. They are about 12" tall and 3" dia. at the extremes


img

Re: pecan too brittle?

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: pecan too brittle?

Brad Vietje

>Thad,

Turned green, it should be fine. My first natural edge goblet was made from some Pecan that a friend sent from Texas -- doesn't grow around here. It looked sorta like the one at left in the photo Mike posted, but as a first, not so refined as his!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: pecan too brittle?

#5

Re: pecan too brittle?

mike Nelson

>John is right, if you get a catch on somthing big from pecan..duck!

Re: pecan too brittle?

#6

Re: pecan too brittle?

Fog Tanner

>I have never heard of Pecan being brittle, hard yes (Pecancrete as it is called here). We get a lot of it (along with Mesquite)here in Texas. I make boxes with it that have very small bead details and never had any issues. I would have no hesitation in using Pecan for a goblet, as I have one with a captured ring sitting on a table.

I rough turn green pecan and then finish turn when dry, with some occasional bowls finished turned when green. When finish turning, I am glad that I have Thompson tools.

To me brittle is Aromatic Cedar, I will never make another facegrain bowl from that after the last one exploded twice.

Fog

Re: pecan too brittle?

#7

Re: pecan too brittle? Definitely not.

Russ Fairfield

>It may be harder than the hubs of Hell, and you may think you are turning concrete; but it is definitely not brittle.

Sharp tools are a must. That means sharper than you have ever before honed the edge of a gouge, and you will have to sharpen often.

Scrapers may work better, but sharpen or reroll the burr often. Take light cuts, and don't expect the burr to last more than 30-seconds.

Other than that, Pecan is a fine turning wood that has beautiful grain and spalting as it ages. Treated right, waxed and wrapped, it can be stored for longer than any other wood I know.

Re: pecan too brittle?

#8

Steven Antonucci

great, now I want pecan brittle...

steve antonucci

>

Re: pecan too brittle?

#9

Maybe if I had known...

Thad Parker

>...this would be a goblet 18 months ago, I could have started the goblet from green wood.

I suppose I'm just going too long without sharpening; that's why the goblet has been shortened 3 times already now.

Also probably did not help that it was nearing 2 AM when I finally decided enough was enough.

~ Thad

Re: pecan too brittle?

#10

Re: pecan too brittle?

jim miles - Charlote NC

>I would'nt call Pecan brittle. Tough, hard, stringy, hard to split when dry. It is kin to Hickory which is used a lot for tool handles

Re: pecan too brittle?

#11

Mike Stafford

Love pecan and hickory....

Mike Stafford

>I love to turn both of these woods. They are great woods for boxes and I don't find them to be all that hard really. I turn them bone dry and find them to be very stable. Both take a wonderful polish and a nice piece of hickory makes a beautiful turning. Pecan does also and sometimes they are mistaken for each other.