>I have a job involving 6''x6''x8' posts and the contractor has decided they must be doug fir or red cedar. The red cedar is a nightmare (tearout and stability issues).Any advice before investing in the doug fir?
Will the posts be painted or left natural? It might be possible to rough turn to general shape and then try to "stabilize" the wood by infiltrating with a solvent-carried acrylic (such as the Min-wax wood stabilizer sold for fixing dry-rotted wood) before you do the final shaping and sanding. This might reduce tear-out, but leave areas that don't look so good as to color of the wood, texture, etc.. If the newel is to be painted this is a non-issue. You might not want to do this if they are to be left natural, or if they will be oiled, stained, or clear-coated.
Regardless, very sharp tools will minimize tear out, as will avoiding any cuts that could be considered 'scraping' in any form.
>I don't think I've ever knowingly turned Douglas Fir. Since you are doing spindles you won't have the same end-grain issues as if you are doing traditional bowls.
As mentioned, sharp tools and avoid scraping. If the posts are for the interior acclimatizing might be a good idea but you likely don't have the time which means care in stock selection.
>I had a job calling for the same material and size. I got the doug fir and even thou it was kiln dried, it threw sap out like cotton candy and covered my lathe with a big mess. I will not do this again unless the money is there. The fir will likely split/check and cause warranty issues later... use caution.
>Ditto what John said. If it is being painted, Poplar or a glue lam would be a better choice. Douglas Fir will check and crack no matter how long it has been "dried". Expect pitch too - lots of it!
>Really sharp tools. I turned 16 large finials 5" in diameter out of DF and found that If I sharpened or honed my tools before the final cut I could do it with no tearout. Slow down the feed rate of the tool or increase the speed of the lathe. This also reduces the tearout. If your going to paint them you can apply lacquer thinned with lacquer thinner about 50percent, to the torn areas and it will solidify them. Sometimes just applying paste wax will help. That's what I do for small areas.
>Doug fir is gettng a bad rap here. I grew up in western Washington where in the old days lumber mills cut nothing but doug fir and for certain uses, western red cedar. Doug fir is used inside and outside of houses for everything but shingles gutters and siding. which were made of cedar. Doug fir, used outside and painted or varnished does not have any tendency to crack and deteriorate. Pitch is seldom a problem.
Doug fir and western red cedar are not ideal woods for turning, but with sharp tools good cutting technique should present no problems.
I made porch posts from 6x6 Doug fir two years ago, and they were a lot of work, for reasons others have mentioned: Checks are all but inevitable, as this type of stock is usually includes the pith. We filled the checks with bondo and painted over them. The pitch is a different story. They don't usually kiln dry porch post material, so the sap isn't set, and it seeps out all over the place, even under and through the paint.
All this said, cedar is a curious "or equal" spec, as it is resistant to decay, which Doug fir isn't, and it is very expensive and very soft, both deterrents to using it, not to mention the trickiness of turning it.
I'm just wondering if you could get Douglas fir and have it heated to a temperature that would set the sap.
>Ellis, these days the lumbering industry in the NW uses small trees that just a few years ago would have been burned as slash while logging. That's the kind of lumber you were dealing with. If you've never seen a virgin forest of doug fir in western Washington or Oregon you've missed something. Doug fir commonly grows to trees 10 to 12 feet and more.in dia. Doug fir is still the lumber of choice in the construction industry and is shipped from the NW all over the world.
I worked as a carpenter for a while as a young guy. Doug fir and western red cedar is just about all we used in constructing homes and buildings. Wood containing the pith and wood such as you describe was found only in the lowest grade of lumber.
>... are all we see back east here these days, Wally. One alternative that is making more sense all the time is to use recycled warehouse beams and other salvaged wood. Some of that stuff was first-growth timber and it is gorgeous, plus or minus a few bolt holes and nails.
>Keep in mind that red cedar dust is carcinogenic.... if you choose to go that route, make sure you use appropriate dust control.
I turned some doug fir the other day for a prototype and (never say never) but hopefully never again. Almost unbearable tearout and it was a spindle done with sharp tools. The skew helped but didn't solve it. If I really needed to I suppose I could have sealed it before the final cuts but it still would have taken a great deal of sanding.
>I had a job turning 8"x8" Douglas fir a couple of summers ago. I warned the customer it was going to crack something fierce, since the wood is dried to "construction" grade. He said it didn't matter. As it turned out, it did matter.
I finished the job, he came to pick the pieces up, pronounced them good, paid, and left. FIVE MONTHS LATER, he is on the phone with me telling me they are no good because the architect rejected them.
"Why did he reject them?" I asked.
"They have a lot of cracks in them."
"I told you they were going to crack."
The guy wanted me to turn them again. I refused. Part of my refusal was based on the fact that I was not allowed to have any contact with the architect. When I asked to speak with the architect, I was told that we - both the architect and I - were "resources", and as such, the contractor would not give out information on either one of us to the other. I pretty much told him to "resource this" and gave him the choice of coming to get his money back or live with the posts I turned. I even told him I didn't think he deserved his money back, but that I would refund it just so he could not claim I did a poor job for him.
THEN he wanted to know if I could recommend someone else to do the job! I plain out asked him if he was nuts. I told him there was no way I was going to inflict this kind of a job on someone else who I knew, and that he was on his own for finding someone else. I never heard from the guy again, and he never came to collect his money.
I have a new rule now. I do not deal with hidden third parties, and I do not turn Douglas fir. Good luck with your own job.
>I think both Douglas Fir and Western Red Cedar are getting a bad rap here.
The first problem is the quality of the wood and how much you are willing to pay for it. Of course construction grades of Douglas Fir will crack in large timbers 4x4 and larger. Walk through any building with exposed solid Doug Fir timbers and beams, and find on the isn't cracked. But we are not talking about construction grade here.
Doug Fir is no different from any other species. ALL wood will crack if nothing is done to prevent it, from the initial sawing of the log to how it is dried. All wood will crack if the pith is left in the center of the piece, or if it were cut for maximum yield rather than maximum value, or if there is both sap and heart in the same piece, or if is is turned while it is still half-wet, or if it is from small trees with growth rings that are 1/2" apart.
We carefully select where to make the cuts in our expensive hardwoods so we will eliminate internal stresses; and then we wory it to death as it is dried so there will be no cracking. Douglas Fir will respond the same way to the same selective sawing, a careful drying schedule, and growth rings that are 8 to 16 per inch.
Just as with the hardwoods we use, this wood is scarce, but it is available. The problem is that you will have to buy the wood somewhere besides Home Depot, and you will have to expect to pay prices that are in up there with Cherry and Walnut.
If they will be painted, you can assemble the posts from smaller pieces, cut from 2x6 construction lumber, to get the better grain and remove the knots. If they aren't painted, you will have to buy clear lumber in a higher grade and expect to pay something around $15+ per board foot.
I know the price sounds unreasonable, but you would pay that much for Walnut or Cherry if you were using that. Why not the same price for Doug Fir of the same quality. Good wood is not cheap.
There is almost an Urban Legend that has grown around how difficult Doug Fir and Cedar are to turn. The truth is that neith are difficult to turn IF you make a proper shearing cut with a sharp tool, and use the bevel to hold the fibers down behind the cutting edge. The problem is that few of us can make this perfect cut because we can get away with being sloppy with the harder species we nmormally turn.
Sanding either species can be difficult because of the sap in the Fir and the oils in the Cedar. With proper technique, and a little luck, you should be able to turn those stair parts with no sanding, or just an occasional place where it was difficult to get a detail with the turning tool.is necessary to remove a tool mark.
Yo9u have a different problem if these species are being specified because they are cheap. If they expect construction lumber material prices, you and they will have to live with cracks. Better wood will cost more.
>I don't do a lot of large spindle work, but have turned a number of 5" and 6" newel posts. I've never had a lathe that will turn an eight foot long spindle and have always specified to the customer that they will be turned in three to four pieces and glued together after turning.
I've always made the customer furnish the wood and indicated that I would like old growth fir that had been cut for many years; i.e., salvaged wood from old constructions. This wood is easier to work and is dry. With the customer furnishing the wood they can only complain about the quality of the turning not what the wood does after turning.
If you must purchase the wood, try to get salvaged old growth Fir that has been removed from early days construction that is being demolished to make room for new construction. It will be dry and will generally be a better quality of wood. I have no idea what the wood will cost, but if you let the customer purchase the wood, you do not have to worry about cost.