Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

Posts

segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#1

segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

Chip in Plano

>A buddy sent me this youtube link to a tool that he thinks may be the 'bees knees' for doing segmented work. I dunno; I have delved into seg work. Figured you guys might have an opinion. It's also a 'green' technology. It's pricey.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ruwZdaPjbs&feature=player_embedded

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#2

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use?

Texian

>An opinion from a skeptic like me will tend to be somewhat negative. Would expect the tool to work well initially. Maybe not so well after the wear from cutting a few hundred or a few thousand segments. Then there is the question of blade life between sharpenings, and ability to resharpen. Would be good to hear from someone who has one and can give a first hand report.

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#3

Steven Antonucci

Disposable blades?

steve antonucci

>I seem to remember that it takes disposable pullsaw blades...

I drool over it every time I see it. It doesn't replace a table saw, but I could see using it if I did more flatwork...

BCT quality is very high...

Steve

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#4

ebd

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use?

ebd

>$1300 for the tool without stand and $120+ for 5 replacemrnt blades. You've got to be shitting me!

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#5

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use?

Chip in Plano

>Plus the human power....priceless!

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use?

Brad Vietje

>Hmmmm....no motor is cool...

I don't do segmented work, but as a solar guy, I'm interested in any tools that allow us to work with less power, or with hand power. If our electric grid becomes unstable at times, you can still do work.

As a tool user, I'm interested in the accuracy and repeatability of the cuts. It looks like gravity and elbow grease keep the tool firmly in contact with the slides or bearings, and that the table top or work surface could lift up and get off track -- and screw up the results. It does seem critical to make sure the sliding table stays firmly in contact with the bearing rods (or whatever they are). maybe the guides are captured in a way that eliminates this risk.

Neat idea, nicely designed... Interesting, Captain Kirk.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#7

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

Dick Coers

>I used that saw for about 5 minutes at the IWF in Atlanta last year. I was very, very impressed, but still couldn't justify the expense. For cutting 3/4" material in hard woods, you have to raise the blade after each stroke. It wasn't a big deal, but a little like patting you head, rubbing your tummy. 3/8" softwood stock could be done in one stroke. The fence has a slight forward angle to it so the stock is naturally pushed downward to the table as it is pushed through. The "bearings" for the tables slide are a dovetail. No lift off table. The cut quality was spectacular. No chip out what so ever. You could make the cut, then slide the parts back together, and barely see the line. It was almost like a knife cut, maybe cleaner! It is also very safe. You can feel comfortable cutting an 1/8" off an 1/8" square piece, 3/8" long. The cutting forces are very slight, and your fingers can "almost" ride against the side of the blade if you wanted to. It sure isn't going to kick back. But when you consider that some laminated vessels have a 300 pieces (many of those pieces are exotics), I think I would like a motorized something.

If I was younger, and wasn't saving for retirement............... (fill in your own reason), I would get one in an instant.


dovetail sliding bearings

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#8

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use?

robo hippy

>Why, why, why did you have to show me this????? Now I will be dreaming of it for weeks as I go to sleep at night. While I don't have any of their tools, they are of the highest quality, and you get what you pay for. It may not be as fast as a Festool chop saw (which Malcolm Tibbets uses, but cost is about the same.

robo hippy

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#9

Dick Hines

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use?

Dick Hines

>Now that is cool. I don't do segmented turnings though. I did get cold chills up my back when he was cutting the small pieces.

If there is a way for someone's hand to get in the wrong place at the wrong time it would be mine. I tend to bleed enough with out thet tool.

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#10

Festool, yes

john lucas

>I've played with the Festool sliding miter saw and If I had the money, and maybe even if I don't, I want one and will some day get it. I think it's much more versatile than the Bridge City saw. Sometimes I do 1 3/4" miters and I can't imagine doing them by hand if in fact that saw will work for that depth.

On the manual side I am in the process of building a shooting board to true up cuts with my hand plane.

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#11

Better than Festool?

David Walser

>I saw this thing before it was officially released to the public (I think that puts me in a not-very-select group of thousands). I was very impressed and thought it would be great for segmented turning. I'm still impressed and still think it would be great for segmented turnings. I think it would prove better than Festool's power miter saw in two ways: First, it wastes far less material. The saw saves material because the saw kerf is thinner than that of a power saw. It also saves material because you can safely use smaller pieces. With rare exotics, the better use of material might be worthwhile. Second, the saw may save time. Even though the saw is powered by hand, it leaves such a clean surface that no sanding should be required between cutting and glue up. (Rumor has it that Malcolm Tibbets seldom needs to sand when using his Festool miter saw -- but he still needs to sand where lighter colored woods abut darker colored woods.) To the extent the saw reduces sanding, it might save time when compared to a power saw.

On the other hand, most segmented pieces are made up from stock at least 3/4" thick. Is it really faster if you need to raise the blade each time you cut something thicker than 3/8"?

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#12

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use?

charlie belden

>A woodworking friend I turned on to the Festool DOMINO (the "package" has a $1,000 price tag)is trying to return the favor by showing me some of the slick things he's doing with the JointMaker Pro and suggesting I get one (we're both tool phreaks - and he's a precision PHREAK).

For ply cabinet and solid wood furniture making it doesn't replace a decent cabinet saw though it does a very nice job on some of the smaller joinery. For cross cutting stock up to about 1" thick and maybe up to about 8" wide the precisionand repeatability is there - and easy to get to.

As for replacement blade cost - $25 each is a decent price for a good to probably very good japanese type thin kerf pull saw, which, if you don't abuse it, will hold up well for quite a while. I've got a dozuki I've used, and on occassion abused, for years and it still cuts petty well. And with a such a thin kerf, it also cuts with less effort - and no flying sawdust cloud to deal with.

One of the things I really like about this thing is that you can work really close to the blade - without pegging the Sphincter Pucker Meter. I HATE usng the slidiing compound miter saw to cut miters and waste a bit of wood in order to keep body parts away from the spinning carbide teeth. And when it comes to cutting thin stock - 1/4" or thinner . . . AND - there's no possibility of a part becoming a ballistic missile - again - no reading at all on the Sphincter Pucker Meter.

With somewhat revoutionary tools like this one, or the DOMINO, which look familiar, it's easy to assume that it only does what an existing and less expensive tool CAN do. But if you study the manual a bit - and better yet, play with one AFTER you really understand how the thing works - AND - what you CAN do with it that you CAN'T (or can't safely do without a lot of jigs and clamps, etc.) with any existing tool - as quicly, easily and accurately - THEN the price tag's significance drops down to quite reasonable.

I saw the DOMINO at several woodworking shows - and kissed it off as a VERY EXPENSIVE dowel hole driller or biscuit joiner. But when I got to actually play with one I saw its value for quick, accurate, repeatable and accurate loose tenon joinery. Bought one with just 10 minutes of Hands On Time. And I've shown a half dozen woodworkers what it can do and how it does it - and they've ALL got one now.

So far, the JointPro isn't on my wish list - but mainly because I've been turning and not doing any flatwork. But . . .

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#13

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use?

Ralph

>As soon as I saw it was from Bridge City.... Spendy, always spendy

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#14

For $1300, I'd buy the Festool Kapex

Scott Hurley in N VA

>

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#15

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use?

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>I do segmented work and have been lusting for a Festool slider. I would be more inclined to spend the $$$ on the power-saw over any hand tool. But. . . I haven't seen or used the Bridge city tool yet!

Re: segmented work....this tool of any use? *LINK*

#16

Re: For $1300, I'd buy the Festool Kapex

JohnKyler

>For that money I would buy the Makita LS1016, and pocket the change.