Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

Posts

Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#1

Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

Thad

>I currently turn on an old J.A. Fay & Egan model 400. The lathe came to me via my FIL, and to him via his FIL by way of an auction after serving time in prison after time in the army (the lathe, not my wife's grandfather). The lathe dates back to the 40's, if not earlier.

I'm wanting to install a drum switch (reversing switch) between the phase converter & the lathe.

My FIL has cautioned me against this, claiming that it can burn up the windings in the motor. If the motor goes, it's a major problem b/c apparently Fay & Egan contracted to Howell Electric for custom-sized motors to align with the belt, so replacing the motor could prove quite difficult.

Is that a valid caution? Would there be anything I could do as a precaution? How much would it cost to have the motor rewound (approx)?

Any thoughts or accounts of past experience with this would be greatly appreciated.

~ Thad

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#2

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

Rick_Allen

>Hi Thad,

Are you saying that you want to "improve" a lathe that has survived for 70 years?

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#3

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

Bob Lemon , Sacramento CA.

>Thad, Sounds like you have a 3 phase motor. If so, reversing any 2 leads will reverse direction on the motor. A drum switch should work. There may be instructions under the cover of the drum switch.

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#4

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

Thad

>Rick, I suppose I have to say "yes," I want to improve the lathe. I think, however, a better improvement would be changing the spindle from 1-1/4x 10 to something standard...but the drum switch is within my means of doing.

Bob, I have actually switched two leads myself when the mood struck to reverse a piece for sanding. This is not something I want to have to do every time I want to reverse the lathe though.

So does using a drum switch pose a potential problem to the motor?

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#5

Re: Listen to the old man. Leave it alone.

Russ Fairfield

>He may know somethinmg we don't.

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#6

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

Bob Lemon , Sacramento CA.

>Thad, I would worry more about the phase converter. It is always good practice to go to the off position and let the motor stop before going to the reverse position. I have a couple of machines with drum switches on them and I've never tried to speed shift them. In industry, they use special circuitry on 'reversing starters' that prevents speed shifting.

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#7

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

E. Tabachek

>As we know, with new motors the direction of rotation can be chosen by re-connecting the wires in the motor, as per the little diagram on the side of the motor. The motors are content to operate in either direction and suffer no ill consequences from either direction. Therefore, I suppose if the manufacturer of your motor allows the leads to be interchanged with the resulting operation of the motor in the reverse direction, it must be safe to do so. If it were not safe for the motor, the leads would be permanently fixed in place.

ET

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#8

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

Rick_Allen

>You can get a spindle adaptor from 1 1/4 x 10 to most any size and thread pitch you like.

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#9

Steven Antonucci

Why do you need it to reverse?

steve antonucci

>I have turned for 12 years and never had a lathe that reverses. Not sure that it's a required feature...

s

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#10

mainly for sanding/finishing

Thad

>

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#11

Brad Vietje

Nuther Idea... Don't Reverse The Motor...

Brad Vietje

>...Reverse the lathe.

I haven't taken the time to read all the other responses yet, so please forgive me if someone else already mentioned this.

How difficult is it to remove/change the belt? Howz about keeping a second, longer belt on hand that's long enough to be twisted 1/2 turn?

Presto! Lathe reverses, motor still goes forward, and no damage done.

Those old farmers and millwrights with one-lungers, overhead shafts and flat belts had some pretty sharp ideas, no?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#12

Re: Nuther Idea... Don't Reverse The Motor...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Brad, I did exactly that on an old Delta lathe that I had many years ago. The pulleys were open on the end, so to put the lathe in reverse for sanding I did a figure 8 with the belt, dropping it down to the next pulley on the lathe. Worked very well.

Wally

Re: Reversing an old lathe (kinda long)

#13

Re: Nuther Idea... Don't Reverse The Motor...

Thad

>the belt is very difficult to get to, as noted from my FIL. He had been unable to actually get to it himself when working on it, and he's more mechanically inclined than most. It the belt goes, or the motor goes, who knows what I'll do.

It would be a good idea if accessible though.

Thanks

~ Thad