>It looks like I'll have one free day before the steel goes to heat treatment so it's time to make some 1/4 inch spindle and detail gouges. Steve this is a good one for you...
I need to know the total length AND the flute length.
>Doug I just measured mine. It's been used a lot so I would add at least an inch to this. 7" long with 3" flute. I thing an 8" tool with about 4" of flute would be good. Normally I like the flute to go further so you can get more life out of the tool but on a 1/4" tool you need the mass to reduce chatter.
I was just thinking the other day that I was going to ask if you ever made 1/4" tools so I was surprised to see this post. I don't use the 1/4" a lot because I can do so much with the 3/8" tool I got from you. I have lately been making deeper steep sided coves and had to use the 1/4" for those.
>I've never used a 1/4" tool before so I wouldn't know what to tell you. Right now I am having tooooooo much fun with the skew and 1/2" gouge you sent me. The skew is so sweet!
>The length from the ferrule is perfect because I will make the shank 1-1/2 inches long. The 1/4 inch tool will chatter if made to long so length is important, I do make the 3/8 spindle tools about one inch to long now but chatter isn't a problem... to long is better than to short.
I finally got ahead on the standard tools and decided to make a batch of scrapers/skews, a few 1-1/4 SRG's, 5/8 SRG's for Mark St.Leger and 1/4 spindle tools for the symposium. I'll get them back next Friday then my daughter gets married on Saturday so it's pushing it on how many can be done before we leave Monday night.
Are you planning shallower spindle gouges (a la Sorby), or a beefier tool closer to a detail gouge. I'd be more likely to go for a 1/4 and 3/8 detail gouge with enough mass to be able to reach over the rest a little.
For detail work,I have a 3/8" Pro PM detail gouge, a Sorby spindle gouge (pretty lightweight, but with a long bevel), a 1/4" Shop Smith spindle gouge made before I was born, and a cheap-o 1/8" gouge with intermediate mass below the flute. When the final cut really matters, I always use the Sorby, shown in PIC. If you produce a nice, small detail gouge, I'd be interested.
In truth, I also need a 4" rest and a better 6" rest for getting in closer to small spindle work, which reduces the need for greater mass somewhat.
>I am assuming that you are referring to an American 1/4" tool that is 1/4" diameter, and not the English 1/4" which is actually 3/8" diameter.
These tools are useful for small turning, but the commercial tools are always too long, too flexible, and bend too easilly for me. That is why I make my own by grinding the 1/4" profile on the end of old 5/8" bowl gouges and 1/2" spindle gouges that are coming to the end of their useful life. They are a stiff and very controllable turning tool.
I have also cut the commercial 1/4" tools down to 2" long with no more than 1" of flute and 1" of shank, and glued them into a hole drilled in the end of a larger piece of steel. Old rifle barrels work good for this.
I would never buy a 1/4" spindle gouge, but if you were to make a larger tool that tapered down to the 1/4 near the end, we need to talk.
>Brad, I plan to make both spindle and detail, from the picture I would say the flute will be shallower on the detail than this one. Russ, you bring up a good point larger diameter tools can be ground so the cutting edge is like a much smaller diameter tool. A example is with Michael Hosaluk, he has a very shallow flute 1/2 and 5/8 diameter detail gouges, now the grind is 40 degrees with a large 28 degree secondary bevel. He has the strength of a larger diameter tool but the cutting edge of the next size down.
>My Jet 1/4 inch spindle gouge (true 1/4" shaft and made in Sheffield) is 6 3/8" from tip to ferrule. The flute is 4 5/8". I tend to use for finials or for fine detail where I can't get something bigger to work. It flexes a lot and you have to turn off the grinder and sharpen while the wheel is slowing down to keep from grinding it a way.
>Doug, I would like a 1/4" detail gouge but I can not go to NM. Could you notify me when they are done and I will have you send me one. Also just a treated 1/4 blank that I can make into a skew if it is a true 1/4" diameter tool. Let me know. TIA Dennis Y
>Now that I've wasted half a day with this mini tool here's what it will be.
7-1/2 inches long with a 4 inch flute, the shank will be 1-1/2 inches long. This is slightly long but the entire 4 inch flute can be used. I can only run them today because tomorrow I need to make a 5/8 fluteless gouge for Michael Hosaluk to try... round nose with a large secondary bevel rolled on it's side shears the wood good inside of a bowl, it should work outside too but let Michael try that.
I use the 1/4 spindle gouge to roll small beads and small coves, I seldom use the no name 1/4" detail gauge because I have a 5/16" from Packard and that is a sweet tool, shatters a lots less and the hand always picks that for small work.
The R&D for these tools could be 2 years because that's how long I had the steel. R&D always takes a long time in a big company but when your small it only takes a second... well maybe 2 before the first cup of coffee.
>The one little bowl gouge that I own is short because I broke it hollowing with it. looked at cutting 2" off of my detail gouge again last night, but I just couldn't do it...even though I should!
>Well the shanks on the 1/4 inch won't be turned down so they will remain .010 oversize (about 3 sheets of paper). The stock is to thin and needs to be supported when cut... I don't have time to make something, it's still that $399 production lathe.
Steve, I would cut 1 inch off the 3/8 spindle tools to start and see how that works... IMO a tool is better sold to long than short. Even that big 1-1/4 SRG is better when it's 1 inch shorter, I made one and it just felt balanced than gave it away, now I have to make another.
Dick, I've been kicking around the fluteless gouge for a long time, when rolled on it's side it appears to produce a nice shaving BUT I want to make sure the tool is not burnishing the wood this Michael will decide at the symposium. I'll make 10-15 to start.
>Wally, I never saw that tool but I sure this isn't a new idea. I start with round stock and mill a flat about 1/3rd of the diameter. The grind is what angle works inside a bowl say 60 degrees with a very large secondary bevel because a large cutting bevel gets in the way. I found a large nose radius and the tool rolled to about 2 o'clock works well, it cuts with or without a burr. This won't replace a bowl gouge but might help with torn grain inside a bowl.
It's something new to try, I'll make a few out of 5/8 diameter stock and let the guys decide how well it works, Bill Grumbine wants to try a 3/4 but it won't be made today. I'm willing to try something different because it just might work... now I have 30 tools here that didn't work so well. LoL
>Doug, my wife who turns five mornings a week, uses 1/4" tools about 75% of the time. She turns ONLY small stuff! Her roughing gouge is a 1/2" Ashley Isles about 6" long.