Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

Posts

Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

#1

Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

charlie belden

>It appears, at least to me, that a shift in emphasis is taking place in the woodturners community, away from the actual process of turning and towards the end results - the turningS. And this shift in emphasis appears to be towards turningS as "art" FOR the "art market".

Where turning and turners were the focus and the free exchange of ideas and techniques was encouraged, this apparent trend appears to be focused on the "art market" - in which collectors , museums and art speculators are the "customers" and there are a host of intermediaries / marketers (art shows promoters, exhibition curators, galleries owners, symposiums organizers, etc.) between the turner turning the turningS and the customer acquiring / buying / investing in the "art" - the turningS.

While this trend will hopefully be of benefit to those who make their living turning, and probably to non-turners in the "art market" supply chain, my concern is the impact on the amateur turners - the people who turn for pleasure, not profit or pay. (OK - so it would be nice to be able to support the turning addiction, at least in part, by selling a piece or two now and then)

When an activity becomes a business - and the "art market" is a business - "market forces" come into play - one of which is Supply and Demand. If the demand exceeds the supply, the price of the things supplied goes UP. Another part of "market forces" seems to be to Maximize the Return On Investment (ROI).

Though anecdotal evidence of one of the impacts of this trend towards the "art market" here�s how the trend is affecting our local turning club - Silicon Valley Woodturners. With 60 to 80 dues paying members, the club could easily get 25 to 30 members to sign up for a $25 to $30 per person admission fee to a day long demonstration by a semi-pro or pro turner with a unique style or technique(s) - that they could teach. The demonstrator received $600 to $800, free transportation to and from the airport or train station, to and from the demonstration site and the quest bedroom and home cooked meals in the club president's home - where the demonstration was to take place. The club WAS able to attract prominent demonstrators five or six times a year.

Two years ago we could afford four demonstrators, last year three and this year - so far - none. Demonstrator fees seem to now start at $1000 a day - and go up from there. Our club is being priced out of the demonstrator market - and as a result, the new turning skills and techniques dispersal process, which has fostered the explosion of interest in turning (note "turning" and not "turningS") has been slowed down considerably.

Now, three day regional and national symposiums provide some of what is being lost, as are weekend and week long classes at turning schools and turning centers scattered about, primarily in the eastern United States. To have access to new turning techniques, approaches and styles, an amateur turner must now incur considerably more expense - in both time and money. And as a result, the dispersal of turning knowledge and techniques - to the less affluent amateur turners scattered acrossed the country - is being reduced.

Where 25 or 30 members could attend an up close and personal demonstration by the likes of Escoulen, Stirt, Priddle, Drozda, Rosand, Klein and Pho, we now have five, maybe six attending two or three day regional or national symposiums - once - maybe twice - a year.

Though I've not attended any of these symposiums, I'm guessing it's like trying to drink from a fire hose - more information packed into a relatively brief period of time than one can absorb - and maybe pass on to other amateur turners. [ Don�t even think about saying anything about drinking and passing it on! ; ) ]

Now some will no doubt suggest that there are plenty of books and videos and DVDs that are dispersing turning knowledge and skills. That's true. But if you've attended an up close and personal demonstration and got to ask questions, see techniques demonstrated in a way that you can really see and grasp it, were able to hold and closely examine pieces by the demonstrator and gotten to talk with and get to know the demonstrator a little - books, videos and DVDs don't come even close to what you can get from an actual demonstration - with 20 to 30 attendees.

At this point I have to express my appreciation for and admiration of the few pro turners I�ve had the privilege and pleasure of getting to know, just a little, and learning a great deal from. Their love of, dedication to wood turning and their willingness to make sacrifices in order to share that love of and dedication to, woodturning is amazing and inspiring. Just knowing that there are people who love to do what they�re doing and hopefully not just �getting buy� warms my heart. My hope is that they will benefit well from this new �art market� trend.

The other concern I have about what I see as a trend towards the "art market" is for the turners in, or considering entering, the "art market". The "art market" is a business - and the folks already in the business have far more knowledge of, and experience in, the market and a much better understanding of how it works. The new �product producer� for this market may enter it at a considerable disadvantage and thus may be exploited. I�ve known a few artists, primarily in the �music market�, who were taken advantage of and in one case, literally run into the ground (see Skip Spence / Mathew Katz).

I hope that some of the business side of participation in the �art market� as turners of turningS get brought up here and in other turning forums before this trend really takes off. It�s always good to have an understanding of the rules of the game, and a bit of knowledge of the game and the players, before taking a seat at the table and laying down your money (or time and effort).

I know there are many here who are in this game. Any sage advice you�d care to share?

I�m running out of ink so I�d better stop here ; ).

Re: Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

#2

Re: Charlie- some of what you speak is .....

Jamie Donaldson

>.... factual, and some speculation not necessarily based of actual facts. What in the real world has not gone up in price, say in the last 10yrs, and that will explain some of the increasing costs of hiring gypsy turning deminstrators. And part of that formula is which demonstrators are you contacting- some of the "famous" have become more famous, and command higher fees, while others have been starved out of the market. The market for the output for all but the most famous, sought by a few remaining collectors at the top, has crashed during the last 3 yrs, and we cannot afford the travel/show expenses when the profits don't exceed expenses. I was a self employed photographer for 42 yrs, 33 yrs. traveling 8~9 mos. per yr. in the horse business, and during mud season(winter) for the past 24 yrs. I have been a traveling turner, averaging 12~15 good juried shows per yr. I make 1-of-a-kind art pieces, not functional turnings which still can occasionaly find a buyer, and this yr. I'm doing only 4 shows, and mostly to see old friends and customers at shows I've done for many yrs. I have never had expectations of becoming a "famous" turner, but enjoy the process of practicing and teaching what I have been fortunate to be able to learn from many other turners. You will find there is a new generation of "mid-level" turners who are excellent demonstrators for reasonable fees, more in touch with their egos, or lack thereof! This will allow more targeted subject matter demos for your club, if you can get the members to consider the fact that they are the not yet famous turners in the field, and at present they are many and available! We do not make our living money doing demos, but generally suppliment our habits as part-timers. Check out who is demonstrating at these growing regional symposiums, and you will then have the means to vet potential less famous but affordable, and often more interesting, new faces on the scene.

Re: Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

Keith Tompkins

>Charlie, I really don't think the "art market" has anything to do with it...in this economy, sales cannot be good, so the full time turners may be forced to increase demo fees just to make a living. Before the economy tanked, woodturning was on the upswing, the next big thing. Now, how many can even think of spending thousands on a piece of wood art knowing they may be unemployed next week.

Re: Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

#4

Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

John Jordan

>Not much has changed in the last 20 years as far as the "art" of woodturning goes. There has always been a collector/gallery/museum component. The numbers may be bigger, but it's still the same.

As far as demonstrators, fees may go up like everything else. I have charged $600 a day for years. $1000 would make more sense. It's not much money when you consider there are likely a couple of more days involved in travel and preparation. If you think that's a lot of money, spend the day with the doctor, or plumber. :)

I love what I do, and am grateful for the opportunity to do it, but it is hard work-as is most anything worthwhile.

John

Re: Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

#5

Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

David Belser

>Charlie, I can't comment much about the "art market" but my personal opinion about the "brown and round" vs. "oh it's art" is that people that complain about to much art need to spend more time perfecting their "brown and round" vs. complaining about too much art. Just my 2 cents.

As far as demonstrators for club meetings, this is a topic that I'm involved in and interested in. As VP of the GSWT I end up planing our bi-monthly meetings and trying to find good demonstrators, talks and trips.

In my experience, there are quite a few younger or less well known or part time wood turners that give good demo. When I go to national or regional symposiums, I look for work in the IG that interests me and I check out the demos by "local" lesser know turners. Many of these folks are happy to come demonstrate for travel and hospitality.

I'm in that category myself, send me a plane ticket and I'll come talk and demo!

I think it is reasonable for someone that has "draw" and is turning full time - as their source of income - to charge $500-$1000 for demonstrating.

For me, my paying job is software contracting. I was recently surprised when I hired a plumber and his hourly rate was significantly more than mine! Right now when work is slow I can afford to take more time for wood turning. There are other really top notch turners that have to support themselves with "day jobs" and for them traveling and demonstrating can easily chew up any personal days and vacation time.

Do any members of your club take on the role of demonstrator? What about other neighboring clubs?

BTW, are you going to Albuquerque? I'd love to meet you in person. I like your approach to being creative.

- Dave

Re: Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

#6

Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"------WebKit

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Last year and the year before I was Program Chairman for the Montgomery County Woodturners(MCW) in Bethesda, MD. But I was also a member of the Capital Area WoodturnersCAW) in Alexandria, Virginia. What I did was to try to find demonstrators who would demonstrate at both clubs over the same several days. Often I would check with CAW-- by far the larger of the two chapters , sort of a big sister to MCW , and then "piggy back" on their ability to attract some of the bigger names. With two opportunities to demonstrate and receive fees, including, often, an additional workshop open to all who chose to register, the demonstrator would receive sufficient remuneration to make the trip financially worthwhile. If I may add, also, sometimes the "big name" would talk too much and not get much turning done; so , believe it or not, one our a local turners -- even a mere club member -- would actually prove to be a more instructive demonstrator. When things get tough, there's usually a way to tighten your belt and get around it.

------WebKitFormBoundarySfAM5CEf38Cf+ZX2

Re: Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

#7

Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

Jeff Willaford

>Charlie,

I'm at the other end of the spectrum from most who have replied so far. I'm so new to turning...everyone I meet, chat with, or read is an expert to me. While there is no club nearby I do have the good fortune of having a couple of excellent turners down the road. They have been very generous with their time and knowledge especially Carole Valentine.

I'm thinking that with 60-80 members there are probably a few great, or at least really good, turners in your club who mentor the amateurs and convey a world of technique and experience in the process. This is probably true of every club and even, as in my case, in many places where no club is handy.

As for 'pro or semi-pro' turners... For the whopping sum of $175 plus transportation and board I will attend the NC Symposium this fall and meet quite a few of them in person. No, it's not like going to the local club and seeing the pro for $30 but I'm sure my average 'cost per pro' will be that or less. Like I said, anyone with more than a few months experience is an expert to me and I feel confident I can learn something from each of them.

Where the "art market" is concerned, I personally feel it helps me understand there is no limit to creativity, imagination or talent in the wood turning world. I'll probably never produce anything considered high end art but I am thrilled to be able to turn a piece of a stump or broken tree limb into something to be admired.

Re: Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

#8

Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

charlie belden

>First let me thank you all for the Gypsy Turning Demonstrator's perspective. Having spent every other summer of my youth living out of a suitcase, every few nights sleeping in another town - or state - traveling all over the U.S. - by car - for four monthd - I can recall the trials and tribulations of traveling - a LOT.

Given the prep time and travel time and expense, it'd be tough to make a full time living doing demonstrations, especially if it's just one or two demos per trip.

About having members do demonstrations for our club and other clubs in the area and visa versa - we often have an hour long demo like that at our monthly club meeting and several times a year have turners in from other clubs. Hell, Malcom Tibbett has driven down from Tahoe, about a three hour drive each way, did and hour or so presentation - and driven back home that same night - for free.

Regarding "brown and round vs complaining about too much art" - I'm not concerned about the "art vs craft" thing. I am seeing a trend in emphasis towards the "art market" and noted one effect of that trend on our club. I'm also concerned about turners considering getting into that "art market" potentially being exploited due to their niavite (sorry can't find the acdcent mark for the "e").

I think one of the problems our club is having with demonstrations by pros and semi-pros is finding what a friend who scheduled speakers for the Kiwanis (s?) Club was faced. The club didn't want a speaker they'd already seen speak at the Elks, the Knights of Columbus, the Rotary Club etc., but they also didn't want bring in a totally unknown speaker . His assignment instruction - "Find us a Prominent Unknown."

Our club faces a dilema. Many club members, myself included, aren't willing to pay $30 and a Saturday, Sunday or two nights during the week, to spend 6 to 8 hours with someone we've never heard of and have never seen any of their work. Perhaps a bit of research on who is available for demonstrations and and a Power Point type presentation with a bit of background on the demonstrators along with photos of their work - a year in advance might work. But getting people to commit to something even three months in advance can be tough - as any program chairman knows - pros yes, amateurs / hobbyists not so much.

Silicon Valley Woodturners is one of three turning clubs in the San Francisco Bay Area,

one vertex of a 50 mile on a side triangle. We often team up with one of the other clubs and switch off who gets Saturday with the demonstrator and who gets Sunday.

We're about a 2 hour drive to Sacramento and maybe an hour and a half to Monterey. For the western states, that's a pretty Target Rich Environment for "gypsy demonstrators". The "tourist attractions" are pretty nice as well - a drive up the coast, prefereably in a convertible, is worth the trip all by itself - even without a trip acrossed the Golden Gate Bridge. And if you're into wine and wine country, Napa and Sonoma are about a two and a half hour drive away. (I'm starting to sound like an ad by the California Tourist Bureau).

So how does one find the "mid-level", up and coming demonstrators? I'm betting that spending some time on the AAW site would be fruitful. Any other suggestions?

As for going to a regional or national symposium/ gathering - the ones out this way are usually in Utah and Arizona or New Mexico and I'm not a fan of airports and airline seating. Add the remaining $5K balance on a dental bill and an upcoming 3 or 4 day high school reunion in Park City, Utah in September, the traveling budget is pretty constrained. But at some point I'm going to make it to one of these events and get to meet, and hopefully talk with and get to know folks I've met on this and other woodworking forums.

Hmmmm - I've gotten pretty good at turning small and delicate - with a parting tool made from an old bayonet saw blade - and a 1/4" bench chisel. I wonder if that would make for an hour long demo? And maybe a "Hey, it ain't that hard to come up with Wild Hare Ideas - and make them a reality - see." presentation might be of interest to some club members . . .

Thank you all.

Re: Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

#9

Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

john lucas

>Charlie I'm not sure there is a trend toward the "art market". Most turners are not interested in the market. They are interested in turning. Now they may be interested in turning things that resemble what you might call the "art Market" but most don't turn to sell.

Those that do turn to sell have more or less 2 choices. Non juried shows, where you turn whatever you want and try to sell it. Juried shows where you need a high quality product that quite often takes on the more "arty" look. I realize there are galleries as well and they fit in the same two categories above. Mom and pop type galleries that take only lower dollar craft items and the higher end galleries that take what they call Art.

I'll be if we did a poll of all the readers of this site there would be very few who are trying to do "art" for sale. Crafts for sale, maybe a fair number, but most just want to make shavings and have fun.

I'm probably not the one to answer the demo problem. Our clubs experience it also. By the time you add up the travel plus the turners fee we just can't do it but a few times a year. I don't blame them. I've talked to quite a few and these aren't really money making gigs. When you subtract the time that they could have been home making more product, they could be losing money.

I know that's a simplistic point of view and there are a lot of factors involved, such as keeping your name out there, helping to sell your DVD, tools etc. To make a living as a turner you need a lot of pieces of pie and hopefully they all work together you make you a decent income.

With all the expenses going up I guess something has to give.

What I'm finding lately is many club members really just want a good demonstration of something they can go home and turn. I think local turners can do that quite well. Get together with your club and find out what the turners really need. They might say they want to see Binh Pho but how many will actually go out there and turn and airbrush and pierce and buy all the tools needed to do what he does. Granted he's really intertaining and educational but I think most turners just want to be able to go home and turn a nice gift for a friend.

Re: Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

#10

Steve Kubien

Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"

Steve Kubien

>Charlie wrote, "So how does one find the "mid-level", up and coming demonstrators?"

Well, I do not know the answer to that but if I was one of them, I would put together a powerpoint presentation, along with some video if possible and send it to every club in the area I hoped to demonstrate for. Wanna see the pacfic northwest next year? Send clubs in that area your stuff. Wanna keep warm in the winter? How about the clubs in the southwest and Florida.

Now, I am not involved with booking demonstrators at my club. For all I know folks already do this.

That's my 2 cents on the subject, and I feel I ripped you off.

Steve