Re: The Trend Towards The "Art Market"
charlie belden
>It appears, at least to me, that a shift in emphasis is taking place in the woodturners community, away from the actual process of turning and towards the end results - the turningS. And this shift in emphasis appears to be towards turningS as "art" FOR the "art market".
Where turning and turners were the focus and the free exchange of ideas and techniques was encouraged, this apparent trend appears to be focused on the "art market" - in which collectors , museums and art speculators are the "customers" and there are a host of intermediaries / marketers (art shows promoters, exhibition curators, galleries owners, symposiums organizers, etc.) between the turner turning the turningS and the customer acquiring / buying / investing in the "art" - the turningS.
While this trend will hopefully be of benefit to those who make their living turning, and probably to non-turners in the "art market" supply chain, my concern is the impact on the amateur turners - the people who turn for pleasure, not profit or pay. (OK - so it would be nice to be able to support the turning addiction, at least in part, by selling a piece or two now and then)
When an activity becomes a business - and the "art market" is a business - "market forces" come into play - one of which is Supply and Demand. If the demand exceeds the supply, the price of the things supplied goes UP. Another part of "market forces" seems to be to Maximize the Return On Investment (ROI).
Though anecdotal evidence of one of the impacts of this trend towards the "art market" here�s how the trend is affecting our local turning club - Silicon Valley Woodturners. With 60 to 80 dues paying members, the club could easily get 25 to 30 members to sign up for a $25 to $30 per person admission fee to a day long demonstration by a semi-pro or pro turner with a unique style or technique(s) - that they could teach. The demonstrator received $600 to $800, free transportation to and from the airport or train station, to and from the demonstration site and the quest bedroom and home cooked meals in the club president's home - where the demonstration was to take place. The club WAS able to attract prominent demonstrators five or six times a year.
Two years ago we could afford four demonstrators, last year three and this year - so far - none. Demonstrator fees seem to now start at $1000 a day - and go up from there. Our club is being priced out of the demonstrator market - and as a result, the new turning skills and techniques dispersal process, which has fostered the explosion of interest in turning (note "turning" and not "turningS") has been slowed down considerably.
Now, three day regional and national symposiums provide some of what is being lost, as are weekend and week long classes at turning schools and turning centers scattered about, primarily in the eastern United States. To have access to new turning techniques, approaches and styles, an amateur turner must now incur considerably more expense - in both time and money. And as a result, the dispersal of turning knowledge and techniques - to the less affluent amateur turners scattered acrossed the country - is being reduced.
Where 25 or 30 members could attend an up close and personal demonstration by the likes of Escoulen, Stirt, Priddle, Drozda, Rosand, Klein and Pho, we now have five, maybe six attending two or three day regional or national symposiums - once - maybe twice - a year.
Though I've not attended any of these symposiums, I'm guessing it's like trying to drink from a fire hose - more information packed into a relatively brief period of time than one can absorb - and maybe pass on to other amateur turners. [ Don�t even think about saying anything about drinking and passing it on! ; ) ]
Now some will no doubt suggest that there are plenty of books and videos and DVDs that are dispersing turning knowledge and skills. That's true. But if you've attended an up close and personal demonstration and got to ask questions, see techniques demonstrated in a way that you can really see and grasp it, were able to hold and closely examine pieces by the demonstrator and gotten to talk with and get to know the demonstrator a little - books, videos and DVDs don't come even close to what you can get from an actual demonstration - with 20 to 30 attendees.
At this point I have to express my appreciation for and admiration of the few pro turners I�ve had the privilege and pleasure of getting to know, just a little, and learning a great deal from. Their love of, dedication to wood turning and their willingness to make sacrifices in order to share that love of and dedication to, woodturning is amazing and inspiring. Just knowing that there are people who love to do what they�re doing and hopefully not just �getting buy� warms my heart. My hope is that they will benefit well from this new �art market� trend.
The other concern I have about what I see as a trend towards the "art market" is for the turners in, or considering entering, the "art market". The "art market" is a business - and the folks already in the business have far more knowledge of, and experience in, the market and a much better understanding of how it works. The new �product producer� for this market may enter it at a considerable disadvantage and thus may be exploited. I�ve known a few artists, primarily in the �music market�, who were taken advantage of and in one case, literally run into the ground (see Skip Spence / Mathew Katz).
I hope that some of the business side of participation in the �art market� as turners of turningS get brought up here and in other turning forums before this trend really takes off. It�s always good to have an understanding of the rules of the game, and a bit of knowledge of the game and the players, before taking a seat at the table and laying down your money (or time and effort).
I know there are many here who are in this game. Any sage advice you�d care to share?
I�m running out of ink so I�d better stop here ; ).



