Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

I guess I will take the hint...

Posts

I guess I will take the hint...

#1

I guess I will take the hint...

Marc Phillips

>I am going to guess that there must be a very exclusive clique here... since I get little to no response to my queries for help, but I notice lots and lots of responses to someone who broke their truck or comments about phallic logos, or whatever. I thought I was posting legitimate questions and looked forward to help from active turners.

I won't trouble you any further. I will just read the archives, since that is the usual response to any question I have had... although it would have been nice to actually interact with another turner and read what they had to say rather than just read an article.

Thanks for the help....

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Marc,

Unfortunately, I'm the guy who posted the truck story; just a "human interest" story of what we may go through as woodturning demonstrators. Life can be interesting at times. I'm not so sure about the clique theory; I'm one of those turners who paints, carves, and otherwise wrecks perfectly good pieces of wood, so I've had my share of turbulent posts.

I just went back through recent posts, your "spalted oak bowl" got 470 hits and several positive comments....not too shabby! I hadn't seen your "photo" post until now; with all the hornet's nest of activity going on lately, it's easy to overlook some posts. Unfortunately, I'm not the person to ask for photo advice..Just ask Jamie! (He's been scolding me for years about my poor shots!) I finally built a photo tent myself, and am trying to improve my photos as well. One thing I'm trying; I'm keeping a small notebook in my camera case, jotting down the settings that work best, such as light balance, etc. Next time, I will have a good starting point.

I hope you don't take the lack of comments personally; I'll bet several people will chime in, or point you in the right direction.

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#3

Steven Antonucci

I don't even know which question you're refering?

steve antonucci

>Marc-

Yes, there are cliques, and yes there are those that will help, but you completely lost me? How have we wronged you? Do you expect everyone to answer every question? Do you want 11 people to respond with the same info? Do you want quantity over quality?

What will make you happy? If I had seen your question and had a good answer, I would have probably spent a few minutes, but you completely lost me.

Please cite your post and I'll do my best to answer it if I know something.

steve

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#4

I Just Searched Current Messages

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>As of May 23 all of your posts had responses.

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#5

Brad Vietje

Hold on there, Marc...

Brad Vietje

>Hey Marc,

You asked a perfectly legitimate question, and I think something was wrong with the server this morning (or my local ISP), as I tried 4 times to respond, but could not post a reply. Maybe something similar happened to others, too.

You might get short -- even slightly curt -- responses from some of our resident photo pro's, who may feel like they've answered the same question dozens of times, but your question was fine.

Jamie has published a "Frugal Foto" or "Phrugal Photo" or "Frugal Photo" set-up, and usually suggests people start simple, and make small adjustments to the lighting and bounce boards until they get the desired results. I certainly can't top the professional help you can get from Jamie and John, so I won't even try.

BUT -- don't get yer knickers in a twist if you don't get dozens of replies. There are only a very few here on WC that tend to give out photo advice, but we can ALL get hot under the collar about phallic logos! Remember, opinions are like belly buttons -- everyone's got one, and nobody knows what to do with it!

Keep up the good work, and please keep posting the results -- sometimes I can even see them!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#6

Brad Vietje

Just Thought of Another Factor or Two...

Brad Vietje

>Barbara's response also reminded me that we don't all see this forum the same, which may be a factor. When I stop by Wood Central, I have all the newest messages on top, by thread. Others may have elected to sort this messageboard differently, so your post may not jump out and boink 'em on the noggin.

Since its pretty well established who the real photo whiz's are, photo questions tend to get fewer responses, since no one wants my photo advice, and most wait for one of the real experts to chime in. I read their advice, but don't usually venture to offer any.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

Keith Tompkins

>Also, Mark, many of us met on wood central, and have become good friends. Many of us have met through symposiums and other venues, and have visited each other's homes. There is a common interest that binds us all....hang in there, you'll soon become an old, familiar friend....believe it or not, newbies will soon start relying on your responses!

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#8

Ellis Walentine

No offense

Ellis Walentine

>As others have noted, the fact that you didn't get an avalanche of feedback on your recent posts in no way means you are being snubbed. I looked at your posts this morning and didn't know what to say, so I said nothing. Jamie Donaldson, who is well known here for his photo advice, pointed you to his website where he details a couple techniques and awarenesses that should have been helpful to you.

I think you would have elicited more responses if you had actually asked a question, rather than just posting three pictures with little or no explanation. That's why I didn't know how to respond. I still don't know what you are asking.

This forum is one of the most helpful ones around, and you are wrong to assume otherwise. Ask a question and you'll get an answer.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#9

Rob Wallace

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

Rob Wallace

>I'm going to guess that you either didn't like the answers you got, or simply asked a question that few people knew something about - this DOES happen! Just because you ask a question here doesn't mean that the collective wisdom on this messageboard will automatically be able to provide an immediate answer, or the answer you're looking for. Just because your desired answers were not forthcoming, it does not equate to being a "hint" that people are intentionally snubbing you or your question...

I'm also going to guess that with such apparently high expectations, you may never be satisfied... Also, with the 'attitude' that came across in your message just now, I'm not sure that many would be willing to take the time to respond to your next question.

The Woodcentral Turning 'board is one of the BEST sources of turning experience and related information out there. It is an erroneous conclusion you've made that simply because you didn't receive the answer you wanted (and apparently when you wanted it), that there are cliques here, or that no one is willing to help IF THEY CAN. This conclusion is very far from the truth. A very wide range of issues are discussed here (both on-topic, and off), and if you can't deal with the nature of how this forum progresses each day for the YEARS that it has accumulated turning information operating in this manner, it may behoove you to seek an alternate source for your information.

Good luck with other places to find the information you're looking for. There are many other sources on the Internet to look, but few with as broad a turning experience base as can be found here.

Rob Wallace

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#10

Steve Kubien

What I do...

Steve Kubien

>I use my belly button as a place to keep salt for dipping celery in while watching tv. Oh, too much personal information again, huh?

Marc, one of the things I like about WC is that I don't get a whole pile of "me-too" answers to anything I post. On some sites, you can get 20 "atta-boys" for something that looks like it came out of a pig, including/especially photography advice.

One of the things I have observed is how quiet this place gets after a heated exchange, such as the recent phallic-logo/AAW-board-members flap. Man, people tend to run to their shops after something like that, including myself. Then, in a few days or a couple of weeks, things get back to normal. During the in-between period, someone always gets the feeling that they are being left out because they post something, and nobody reposnds. You, unfortunately, were looking for photographic advise. Around these parts, that often means Jamie or John because they know their stuff. Others know how to take pictures (your current author excluded) but few can see a pic and critique it with solutions like they can and most of us don't try.

I have had extensive email-discussions with both of these fine gentleman and can 99.999999% guarantee you that you are not being ignored because of a clique or anything else. If I had to guess, I bet they just missed your post in the wake of the latest bruhaha (sp). Nobody is ignoring you. Keep posting. Keep asking. Keep offering help when you can. Keep your stick on the ice.

Rspectfully,

Steve Kubien

-now, does anyone know what I did with my carrot sticks?

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#11

Steve Kubien

And I just noticed....

Steve Kubien

>...that local photo-guru-and-all-round-good-guy, Jamie responded to your photo-advice query and hour and 20 minutes after you posted it. He directed you to his site and the phrugal-photo tent...square-one in taking pictures of round things.

Cheers,

Steve

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#12

Re:Jamie Donaldson demo

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>We saw Jamie's frugal photo demo at the Southern States Symposium. He really knows his stuff when it comes to taking pics of turnings. I believe that the poorest general knowledge skill on this board is photography (ME INCLUDED). John Lucas and Jamie are amoung our resident pic gurus. Either of them could teach you all you need to know.

Traffic on this board varies as the world spins. When major severe weather strikes, traffic falls off. The same happens for election day, holidays, world news events, warm enough weather to plant gardens, school is out- vacation starts, etc. Remember that facial expressions and body language are not here to save a posting that could have been mistaken.

Hopefully you will stay around long enough to become a regular!

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#13

Keep coming back....

Chip in Plano

>take what you like and leave what you don't. If you haven't joined a local woodturning club, find one and do so even if you have to drive a ways to get there. I joined 2....20 and 38 miles each way. I even volunteered.

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#14

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Marc,

I don't think your claim regarding cliques reflects the reality of the atmosphere on this board. I've been coming here for a long, long time now and I have posted up more than once. At times I get a number of responses and sometimes it's only one or two.

Sure you may see a lot of response to a post that has nothing to do with woodturning or woodworking. That is because of the community spirit which exists around here. Friends talk about all kinds of things when they get together.

To take a lack of response as some kind of personal slight reveals more about you than it does about the board. Sorry you felt that way.

Gary

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#15

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

Barry Elder

>Marc, did you ever stop to think that the "gurus" of photography on Wood Central might have their own life to live, a full-time job, a lot of time on the road going from demo to demo, art show to symposium, etc. None of us ever get all the answers to all our questions, but the computer gives us a wonderful source to search for information. Remember the old saw "Google is your friend"!

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#16

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

Jeff Willaford

>Marc,

I find it difficult to get specific answers when I don't know what to ask. If you can't glean the information you need from the articles perhaps they could help you frame a more specific question. I've received some excellent help with information about photographing turnings (and other toipcs) from members of Wood Central after asking specific questions.

I'm new to turning and to Wood Central but I've found the folks to be very generous with their time and information. I also try to search the archives to see if my question has been answered sometime in the past.

I'm also very lucky to have an excellent turner with a sense of humor down the road from me. Maybe a good question to post would be to ask if there are any turners in your local area that would be willing to meet with you in person.

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#17

Obviously I was wrong....

Marc Phillips

>.... based on the mature and insightful responses... only one rude response and I see that it was deleted.

Thanks for the responses, and I apologize for my initial post. The impression I got was obviously wrong and I am happy to admit it.

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#18

Brad Vietje

WOW -- Steve found a use for his!

Brad Vietje

>I'd have to gain a lot of weight to lost my carrot sticks, though ;~)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: I guess I will take the hint...

#19

Dick Hines

Re: What I do...

Dick Hines

>I knew there saw something you could use your belly boutton for besides catching lint. But I neves thought of salt.