Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

hand carved...

Posts

hand carved...

#1

hand carved...

GaryG in MD

>In browsing around for some turning info, I accidentally came across a commercial web site site selling various stuff. I noticed a set of obviously turned muchroom boxes. In the ad, it noted that they are "hand carved." My first reaction was negative, but it got me to thinking. Do you consider your turnings to be hand carved? I guess they really are, but I don't think I've heard many of us talk about it in those terms.

The lathe is just a spinning wood holder, and we create our pieces by hand, with hand tools. We even call some of them "gouges", just as the other carvers do. In the past, I've run into people who associate lathes with metal lathes -- they were surprised to find that I used the lathe to do free-form carving, as opposed to work constrained in some way by the machine. It might put us in somewhat of a new (and better?) light with John Q. Public if we did use the term "hand carved" for our work.

So, are we actually just a subset of wood carvers? Does that step on their feet in some way? It's an interesting thought. ...Gary

Re: hand carved...

#2

Re: hand carved...

E.T.

>I tell people that "wood turning is like wood carving, only at 100 miles per hour". The wood carvers don't understand.

I have heard/read wood turning being described as "wood lathing" or "hand lathing" which is awful. The people using these phrases obviously don't understand the process or the terms.

ET

Re: hand carved...

#3

Re: hand carved...

john lucas

>I think it is nothing more than high speed carving. You need to cut down hill with the grain the same as with hand carving. As your skills evolve you learn to sharpen better the same as in carving. fortunately it's harder to cut yourself but exploding pieces are a danger.

That's part of why I don't understand the group that won't allow carving on turning. Your simply extending the carving techniques from powered to non powered.

Re: hand carved...

#4

Re: hand carved...

Rick Allen

>You might say we hand carve three dimensional objects in only two dimensions.

Re: hand carved...

#5

Re: hand carved...

AndiWolfe

>I certainly agree that the lathe is a carving tool. In my case, it's my rough-out tool ;-)

Seriously, though, I find it puzzling why some people get so bent out of shape (pun intended) when turning moves beyond brown and round. The lathe is a very useful tool, but I find it somewhat constricting in terms of my own expression of ideas. I do enjoy seeing a beautiful piece of wood, but I would enjoy it almost as much to see such a thing in a polished plank as I would a turned object.

Re: hand carved...

#6

Re: hand carved...

John Roth

>People were making round objects and bowls long before there were lathes as we know them today. Historically, you will find many examples of round objects (probably turned with ancient lathes) that were embellished with decorative carving going back several hundred years. In fact, the concept of a turned object as a piece of art by itself is relatively new, likely started with the decorative lathes in the 1800s. Check out Holzapel's (sp?) book on decorative turning and see what was done using a combination of lathe turning and carving. The lathe is just one tool in the workshop and its application depends solely on the objective of the end product.

Re: hand carved...

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: hand carved...

Keith Tompkins

>John, You are absolutely correct....if anyone takes the time to study the history of turning, they will discover that the very best turnings were embellished with carving. Take a stroll through any antique store... study a pie-crust table, for example. Big bowls were almost always carved, not turned. Just try to find a genuine turned BIG bowl from the turn of the century. The lathe was, and still is, just another tool. I say use ALL of your talents, whether it be carving, turning, painting, whatever.

Re: hand carved...

#8

Re: hand carved...

GaryG in MD

>Rick, That's a very interesting perspective I hadn't thought of in exactly those terms. It's one of the reasons these new computer drawing programs work so well for designing and displaying turned works created solely on the computer to pre-plan actual turnings. Of course this also relates to the old "figure of revolution" that comes to mind from some math or engineering course I took long ago. I might note, having just seen Barbara Dill's demo and work, that none of this is true for multi-axis work. That's truly three dimensional in all respects, but it's still done on a lathe. I can't wait to try her split turning with 4 rotations. ...Gary

Re: hand carved...

#9

Re: hand carved...

GaryG in MD

>I guess "hand turned" is a good compromise. ...GG