Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

An interesting dichotomy:

Posts

An interesting dichotomy:

#1

Steven Antonucci

An interesting dichotomy:

steve antonucci

>A lot of opinions and discontent with the current state of the AAW (from what people have written), but how many of you are really unhappy? How many of you look at the AAW as an expensive magazine subscription?

One of the things I have noticed in my 1.5 years of being active in a club (two actually) is that the crowd is always larger when someone with a big name is doing something artistic than it is for other types of demos? Do people really want a magazine that will discuss the basics and aim for the middle, or is it better to set the bar higher than we are currently capable of producing?

I agree that the current magazine is somewhat guilty of abandoning the beginner working on a weekend in his/her garage for an hour here or there. Honestly, how interested in turning is someone like that? I'm not saying that it's good or bad, but if someone doesn't really want to get involved at a more skilled level, is it OK that they get left behind?

I would like to see a more positive and encouraging message for those beginners looking to get better. I think that the magazine has an obligation to represent every member's interest in every issue, and as I've stated before, it's up to US as the membership to get it done. Change starts at home.

Overall, I am happy with the AAW as an organization. They provide me with some level of protection if I am turning at a chapter event. They provide me with a forum to display my work. They provide me with 4 magazines per year that have some content that makes me a better turner. They run the National symposium which is a feat that we should not underestimate! They provide grant monies to members and chapters to get better at this craft/art/sport/hobby/passing fancy (IF YOU ASK FOR IT!)

Seems like a bargain? Now everyone go take a happy pill :-)

Steve

Re: An interesting dichotomy:

#2

I took my Happy Pill

Jerry Whitaker

>I agree Steve. It would be a lot more productive if we pointed our efforts towards getting the AAW to publish 6 times a year instead of 4. It is a perfect time to do it, since in my opinion , a certain magazine across the pond is very expensive and suffering a little in the quality department. Not intending to start another controversy here.

Re: An interesting dichotomy:

#3

I am that guy...

Thad

>I'm the beginner working in the his & hers garage on the weekends, late nights, & mornings. "Honestly, how interested in turning is someone like me?" you ask; my interest level would be "passionate."

I love turning, yet simply do not have as much time for it as I wish.

It's early in my ministry, I've not been married 5 yrs yet, & have 2 toddlers so far.

I actually spend more time on turning related stuff than I do turning because I can do those things in the 5-10 minute intervals life gives me. I have resolved that regular lathe time is a luxury at this stage of my life.

I understand all of the benefits Steve states to the AAW, and my perception of the association is that it is for the professionals. I do not feel the least slighted if the AAW isn't including beginners material in every issue. Frankly, that's a big reason I'm on WC.

Just my "unprofessional" position.

Re: An interesting dichotomy:

#4

Re:I am always dismayed by the .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... short-sighted and ignorant attitudes many have about the AAW. This logo rumor mongering is just another example of how a few individuals can send widening waves of disinformation as they pursue their own agenda thru a public forum. It is a socialogical fact that this generation of Americans has not been a generation of joiners and doers, but would rather "let Joe" do it." Look at what has happened to membership of long standing organizations such as Rotary, Kiwanis,etc. and how membership is a fraction of levels from 30 yrs. ago. Also typical is the fact that perhaps 10% of that membership is willing to actually work for the benefit of these worthy organizations. The interests of woodturners world wide have been championed by the existance and efforts of AAW, and yet some consider a quarterly magazine to be the only benefit of membership. I have been a member for 19 yrs. and a founding member of 2 chapters, attended 12 Symposiums and demonstrated at 5, and travel each year to demo at several of those affiliated chapters. These chapters exist because of the AAW, and serve as both a beginner and continuing education resource not available elsewhere. I know that the "gray panthers" that make up most of the turner demographics today have varied interests in turning, but mutual support must be centralized to have a supportive voice in this big wide world. It's also a fact that diversity can be a seed of fractional and factional events, which happens to be another normal aspect of human nature. No large organization can be all things for all people, and finding middle ground must be done thru internal efforts of a structured organization. Taking potshots from the outside is a pointless exercise, so those disenfranchised individuals are tilting at windmills rather than providing constructive efforts at improving benefits within an organization, for the long term betterment of all.

Re: An interesting dichotomy:

#5

Re: An interesting dichotomy:

john lucas

>I don't understand how you can say it doesn't have beginner material. There were at least 4 articles useful for beginners, the tape measure, the article on sharpening and honing and keith's article on design and Bob Rosand's article on the parting tool.

You can't fill a magazine of this kind with totally beginner articles, just like you can't fill it with advanced stuff. Being the Journal for the AAW you also are required to put things in there about the organization and it's activities.

It just confused me when people say they don't have anything for beginners when every issue has something. It's just not beginner articles from beginning to end.

Re: An interesting dichotomy:

#6

Steven Antonucci

Didn't say it didn't have beginner material?

steve antonucci

>I don't want a beginner magazine either, John. My point was that even the beginners want to see some stuff that's above their level (to aspire to), but not so far above them that they can't grasp for it.

When it takes you longer to sand out torn grain, heel marks, and that bash mark from the dismount than it does to turn the bowl, the last thing you want to see is an article talking about pierced, multi axis art pieces on 2/3 of the magazine. Balance is necessary.

I can't wait to see pages f useful tips returning to the magazine now that you are "the man..."

Steven

Re: An interesting dichotomy:

#7

Re: An interesting dichotomy:

Colin

>Steve, Just my thoughts I abandoned my membership of the AAW as to me living in Spain it was just a very expensive magazine subscription. This was made even worse by the poor condition of the magazine when it arrived. So I now spend my money elsewhere on another US magazine that has more content and always arrives in good condition.