In fairness, I think the delay is reasonable.
David Walser
>Sean and Ray,
I understand the frustration over the time it took for someone at the AAW to respond. However, the time it took was not unreasonable based my own experience. I've never served on the AAW board (and have no desire to serve on the board), but I have served on a number of boards and committees. I've also served in a leadership capacity on many of those boards and committees. The usual practice would be for a letter or statement to be circulated among the board or committee for the members' input before the letter or statement was published. When serving as chair, I might have had the authority to issue a letter without prior approval of the rest of the board or committee, but I never did nor would I have in this case. While I would have understood the need for a quick response, I still would have given the other board members the courtesy of soliciting their input before responding. Even with the most urgent of issues, the quickest I've ever been able to get a letter out of a committee is 2 days -- and that took a lot of behind the scenes effort to get people to read their email and to give me the okay!
If I had been serving as editor of the AAW journal, I might have felt I had the authority to respond without going to the board. I might not. However, there were at least two issues raised that demanded a response. One was the logo; the other was Alan Lacer's ability to serve on the board. Had Betty responded to the first question, the second would still have required a response from the board or an officer of the AAW. Given that, it would not have been wrong for Betty to have sought a single letter to address both questions.
Finally, when these questions arise, it is very tempting to give an "informal" response. As a member of the board or committee, you may feel you know the answer and you want to respond as quickly as possible. However, answering the question "off the record" is almost always the wrong approach because it short circuits the organization's decision making process. The fact Betty and the individual board members did not succumb to the temptation to respond in their individual capacities speaks highly of their discipline and professionalism. I do not and may never fully agree with the actions taken by the board, the editor of the journal, or the AAW itself, but in this matter I cannot criticize the speed nor the manner in which they responded to the questions raised.