Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Pen mandrel compatibility question

Posts

Pen mandrel compatibility question

#1

Pen mandrel compatibility question

wilbur

>In looking over the accessories for the Sierra pen, I noted that the 7 mm mandrel sold by Berea Hardwoods for this pen has a diameter of 0.247". I happen to have a 7 mm mandrel sold by another company that specs the diameter at 0.243". There's also a statement that says that this mandrel "may or may not be compatible with other pen mandrels."

I'm sure that the 0.004" difference in mandrels is probably negligible in terms of compatibility with bushings from a different supplier. On the other hand, I once took a machining class and from what I remember, 0.004" seems to be a large tolerance for machined pieces and for runout issues. Am I being overly anal about this?

Re: Pen mandrel compatibility question

#2

Re: Pen mandrel compatibility question

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>Hi Wilbur,

Hmmm, I never measured mine... I use a Universal adjustable mandrel from LV and the bushings are from www.penblanks.ca (William Woodwrite), not sure about the measurements.

You can conceivably go with no mandrel at al if you use a dead centre as your drive and a live centre in the tail stock.... it works..

Take care

Jim

Re: Pen mandrel compatibility question

#3

Re: Pen mandrel compatibility question

Bill Howatt

>I recall reading in the LV catalog or perhaps on their site about putting a turn of tape on the mandrel if it is undersize.

Bill

Re: Pen mandrel compatibility question

#4

Re: Pen mandrel compatibility question

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Wilbur,

Yes, you are probably "overthinking" this. Very few mandrels, and bushings for that matter, are right on spec. I would try it, and you'll probably be OK. If you try the bushing on the mandrel and you actually feel "slop", then think about another mandrel, but realize that another one from the same company may be just as good as one from another company. These things can just vary!

On the other hand, I usually use mandrels from Berea, and occasionally from CSUSA.

I hope this helps.

Scott.

Re: Pen mandrel compatibility question

#5

Steven Antonucci

I get a callous if I am .0004 out of round :-)

Steve antonucci

>